|
Author
|
Comment
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 53
(3/11/02 1:08:21 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
i think that in interviews rivers should start crediting limp bizkit and creed as the visionaries that inspired the weezer revival.
|
asschun 
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 633
(3/11/02 1:12:38 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
creed isnt that bad
it reminds me of maladroit
|
artfuse 
FEMALE
Posts: 77
(3/11/02 1:14:03 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Do you think he should praise Interscope for their keen business sense and compassionate, committed attitude to their artists, as well?
Rivers should do whatever he wants; that should go without saying. As this thread has shown, people will infer what they want to when they see his words in print.
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 222
(3/11/02 1:18:37 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
i just think its pretty amazing that i still think his stuff is great, even though i think creed and limp and the rest of the nu-metal crap is just useless shit-eating shit. i don't think maladroit sounds like creed. but if these are his influences now, who knows?
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 54
(3/11/02 1:21:34 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
"Do you think he should praise Interscope for their keen business sense and compassionate, committed attitude to their artists, as well?"
don't be ridiculous. of course he shouldn't praise interscope. but a shout-out to fred and the gang for their artistic contributions would be totally called for. and honestly, creed is the best thing since savage garden.
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 225
(3/11/02 1:27:05 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
savage garden had that one great song. that song like defined the summer of '98 for me.
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 82
(3/11/02 1:37:59 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Savage Garden, like a taco you bite into and like until you realize that the meat is SAVAGE GARDEN.
Oh fuck, not another taco analogy.
But no, if Rivers's influences continue down this path, it's gonna get fuckin' scary. Of course, he IS only half fucking with us, because he still likes some good stuff. He's just choosing to tell us that he likes Creed, etc.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 142
(3/11/02 2:13:48 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Don't forget about the techno/Euro-Pop/trance influences...
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 92
(3/11/02 2:33:13 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
yeah, coming to europe right after we finished pinkerton in '96 was a big eye opener. techno was huge, oasis was huge, it was a very exciting time. i knew from the moment we first tried to play across the sea at one of those festivals that pinkerton was going to bomb. i became determined to develop a style that festival people could connect to and enjoy.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 145
(3/11/02 2:34:46 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
I like what Ace just said.
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 417
(3/11/02 2:40:15 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
puts things a little more in perspective doesn't it?
|
jade
Registered User
Posts: 18
(3/11/02 2:44:56 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
it really does.
|
anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 82
(3/11/02 2:45:38 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
yeah I get it now, but that doesn't mean you can't write a "non-str.ophic" song or such and stick it on an album, and just not play it at these festivals. but since it's jam music you are leaning towards these days..
|
Smam
Registered User
Posts: 4
(3/11/02 2:46:17 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
ace, try playing across the sea at a concert now and see what happens.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 55
(3/11/02 2:46:22 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
heh, i wonder if this time people will be yelling "el scorcho"
side note: springfest = festival.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 146
(3/11/02 2:47:47 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
He's going for a more immediate style of music. Something that hits harder and demands crowd participation, even if people have never heard the song[s] before. He should have said this a long time ago. It does put things in perspective...
However...while Pinkerton songs may be alot less 'instant' at a large, outside, highly intoxicated venue, I'd say Blue was just as close as anything that he may be trying to shoot for now...as far as music that is festival-worthy and connects with the audience.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 98
(3/11/02 2:47:55 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
yes it does....
ace, what's a good example, in your opinion, of a band that has mastered the 'festival-friendly' sound? just curious....
they're playin slob on the radio...weeeeeird
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 418
(3/11/02 2:52:34 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
"Blue was just as close as anything that he may be trying to shoot for now...as far as music that is festival-worthy and connects with the audience."
True. If Blue was close, Green was bang-on. As are most selections from Maladroit, imo.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 147
(3/11/02 2:54:01 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
"ace, what's a good example, in your opinion, of a band that has mastered the 'festival-friendly' sound? just curious...."
...I think he's been hinting at Oasis all along. If so, I agree. I like Noel's songs. Noel is the master of the songwriting approach that Ace has been attempting for the past couple years.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 56
(3/11/02 2:55:14 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Photograph, Keep Fishin, Dope Nose, Island in the Sun, Jonas, Buddy Holly, Undone, No One Else....probably most conducive to a festival.
and my vote is for Tool as ultimate festival band.
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 226
(3/11/02 3:01:45 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
speaking of which, i really hope they end up headlining lollapalooza this year. that would just fucking rule. that's such a huge deal.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 148
(3/11/02 3:07:03 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Tool?!
I don't view Blue as any less 'bang-on' as far as this type of songwriting is concerned. If anything, Blue is a more festival oriented sound then Green. Songs like 'O Girlfriend' and 'Don't Let Go' won't exactly get a rowdy sea of European festival goers pumped up, I wouldn't think. I can't think of one song on Blue that wouldn't go over well though. Maybe "World Has Turned..."?...I dunno. In any case, it would still have more of a festival vibe then either of the two Green songs I mentioned.
I WILL give props to "Hash Pipe" though for probably being the most festival conducive =w= song to date. It's explosive when they play it live.
Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 3/11/02 3:10:40 am
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 99
(3/11/02 3:10:38 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
eh I've got mixed feelings about that...but it would definately rule for the band...the chance to headline a huge event like that definately doesn't come around often...
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 228
(3/11/02 3:27:37 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
thats what i think. they just CAN'T turn down something like that. i wouldnt give a shit about having to sit through other mediocre bands and paying more than for a regular concert. this is just such a rare thing to come up, and i cant believe that weezer was actually offered this chance. i'd go no matter what.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 100
(3/11/02 3:34:24 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
oh I'd most definately go...I just couldn't guarantee there wouldn't be any pre-show whining about the price/shitty bands/5 hour drive...but still, I wouldn't miss that for the world...I really hope, if that was a legit invitation, that they don't pass it up...
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 419
(3/11/02 3:42:00 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
no, I was agreeing with you about Blue, surfer. However, I will say that the first couple of times I listened to Green, it had that kind of 'new but familiar' sound to it that kind of 'commands' listener participation - even more so then Blue (with 2-3 exceptions on both albums). I just think TGA songs are simpler, more 'universally accepted' and easier to 'get into the groove of', if you will. That's why other countries have really taken to it I think, and why it's been such a huge hit here in North America as well.
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 93
(3/11/02 4:09:47 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
i had seen the band setting up at soundcheck and laughed at them in an indie-highbrow sort of way. they didn't have guitars! they didn't have bass or drums! how could they possibly rock? how could they possibly go on as headliners after us? we were going to blow them off the stage!
we played our set and, as i said, quickly realized the "masterpiece" we had just created would drop like a brick in environments like this. indeed, our complex music was all but incomprehensible to the 40,000 young europeans who had come simply for the purpose of getting rocked and having a good time.
later that night, the sun went down and an ominous air gathered over the field as the crowd crammed together, packing towards the front of the stage. the excitement was palpable. the band everyone had come to see finally burst out of the darkness and onto the stage, hurling everyone into a frenzy of unified, mass po-going. it felt incredible, evil, and exciting. I wanted to run in and join the throng.
it was then that i knew there was much i wanted to learn.
i listened, intently. i noted the repetitive beats. i noted the fact that there were no jarring changes of feel, tempo, or harmony. i noted that i was being sucked in and forced to move, whether that meant dancing, head-banging or just generally rocking out. i noted the lack of "personal expression" and the lack of "emotion". most of all, i noted how much it rocked.
although the band's music offered little in the way of compositional practices which i could integrate with my own, the experience of hearing it that night opened my ears to hearing music in a different way. it took me years to come to terms with that.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 58
(3/11/02 4:23:46 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
what's the nature of the festivals you're playing in portugal?
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 3/11/02 4:28:37 am
|
anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 84
(3/11/02 4:33:56 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
wow, the europeans got to you too huh?
I don't know about all the techno shit over there, but they have a lot of things figured out . I've been to germany twice, and I was so impressed with how people were. everyone is so much more open minded. i missed out on a great festival last year when weezer played with a bunch of great bands in, hmm stuttgart I believe.
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 229
(3/11/02 4:48:35 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
in a weird way, green had the same exact effect on me. the more i listened to it, the more appeciation i began to have for simple, powerful, solid pop songs that just rock- nothing more, nothing less. i wouldn't have any of it beforehand. everything i listened to had to be all experimental and weird and hard.
i guess the pop thing sorta needed to be shoved on me, and that's what green did. there's so much i listen to now that i would never, ever, in a million years, thought that i would ever listen to before. and i'm just so glad that green forced me to see all that. it's a whole different world, and it's fucking fantastic. i still love all the other stuff, as well, but my music doesn't HAVE to be ultra-deep and emotional and "experimental" anymore. i think it's just something that i've always felt, but never really wanted to admit before.
|
Shefik 
^.^ shawny!! ¨_¨
Posts: 183
(3/11/02 5:04:38 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Me Be.. that's cool. I'd have to say that I agree that I like stuff that simply rocks.
But the problem is that I get too attached to music I like. If it really means something, I connect to it and it becomes a part of me. Therefore, I can't really enjoy music unless the songwriter put something of himself into the songs. In '94, Rivers invested his energy into the Blue Album. In '96, he imbued Pinkerton with his emotion. Rivers gave us his musical experimentation and his search for the perfect pop song in 2001 on Green.
So I guess I change my answer: being able to "simply rock" is a prerequisite. Anyone can rawk (sorry Me Be). Heck, I can rawk. But a piece of music has to be willing to offer me something more than that for me to care. A message, a feeling, a unique sound.. something. Weezer does that for me. Death Cab for Cutie, JEW, that dog, the R.entals.. They all fulfill this basic requirement to give me something that no one else can provide in musical form. This is different from the "experimenting" that Me Be mentioned.. Rather, each of these bands has a similar sound across albums, but it's that overall unique sound that gets me going.
I've heard Creed's new album before. I heard it on their last album.
|
jade
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/11/02 5:20:17 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Dude, why didn't you just say so, ace? This makes so much more sense.
I get attached to music I like, too. I think the problem for me is that stuff that rocks live doesn't necessarily make the transfer over to an album. Sure, it's great to rock out at shows...simplicity reigns there. But on an album, the thing that makes me like it and keeps me listening is the connection to the music...its depth and my ability to relate to it, to make it a part of myself (to steal a bit from Shefik.) I like music that means something...and Green didn't do that for me. Maladroit is a step in the right direction, but I just don't feel like it's there yet.
I can appreciate music like Green for what it is. Don't get me wrong. I understand that it's meant to do different things than Blue or Pinkerton, but at the same time, I miss what I got out of both of those albums. I think that's where a lot of the conflict comes from. It isn't necessarily that the new stuff is bad, it's just different. It was a bit of a shock.
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 389
(3/11/02 7:12:02 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Fuck 40,000 Europeans.
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 43
(3/11/02 7:54:54 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Wow, seriously. I mean, yesterday I would've thought that went without saying, but...
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 119
(3/11/02 8:37:24 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Goddamn Europeans... makes sense now though, but i think a lot of the stuff that isn't overly repetitious and formulaic can be ear candy to anyone as well.. say it ain't so for example.
|
Ahmed Malik
fucking anime queen
Posts: 70
(3/11/02 8:42:52 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
But Rivers, you have to understand that music like that usually only works well in a live environment, not on an album. What you noted as rocking, I would refer to as a jungle beat, but that's for personal reasons. An example, though not really a good one would be from the movie, Glory. There's this sequence towards the end where the all the characters get together and begin this humming thing (I'm sorry, I just woke up) which is quite hypnotic. I could be completely wrong, but I suppose that is the kind of thing you experienced during that headliner's act.
from the last sentence though, i understand that this not something that happened yesterday in portugal. it's strange the things that change you, even if it may be to dismay of others. now i can see how hash pipe emerged from your psyche.
|
Bayemon
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/11/02 8:52:06 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
I've always been a little torn between opinions of techno music. I like the sound and the simplicity, but then I miss the actual musicianship. It seems like anyone with a couple of friends, basic knowledge of how to use a keyboard, and a few synths could make some incredible techno music... but is there really any power behind that rawk? It makes you want to move, but you dont feel any emotion. I tend to like industrial more. where you have techno loops, and some breakbeats, but then you also have kick ass heavy guitars, and a singer with some emotion. now there is some rock.
also all that rocks does not have to be simple... thrash metal.
very complex. very fast. fucking rock.
Slayer. Anthrax. Megadeth. Metallica.
thats some good shit.
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 391
(3/11/02 8:57:03 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Those bands are fucking garbage, and techno is as gay as it gets.
|
pinktriangle
Registered User
Posts: 2
(3/11/02 9:17:32 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
SLAYER? ANTHRAX
oh man those are the worst fucking bands EVER
|
asschun 
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 634
(3/11/02 9:19:23 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
oh my god
it is europes fault
all europes fault
this does not surprise me
|
Bayemon
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/11/02 10:14:56 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
well whatever. that was the music I grew up listening to. sure beats the hell out of duran duran.
and it IS musically complex. which was my point.
|
GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 36
(3/11/02 10:19:21 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
is it me, or as far as european bands go, are bands from england much different from bands from the 'continent'.
On one hand, you have the beatles. On the other, you have that chick who did 99 luftbaloons.
that's why i like american bands the best.
|
asschun 
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 637
(3/11/02 10:38:32 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
no one else finds this story interesting???
|
zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/11/02 10:46:01 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
Wow, that's definitely the most interesting thing I've read in a long time, and honestly I can see where Ace is coming from a lot more now.
What I think needs to be realized though is that music can be good in more than one way, obviously, and Green is great at what it is trying to do, which is not the same as the previous two albums, but succeeds in producing a light, pop album. Thanks for that story Ace, I would hope that will help more people see your view now.
|
Sneper
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/11/02 11:09:47 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
I wonder what band ace is referring about in his last post....maybe Chemical Brothers or Prodigy?
Edited by: Sneper at: 3/11/02 11:13:50 am
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 152
(3/11/02 11:10:12 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
I don't think it's the Europeans fault so much as it is just the fact that they happen to still put on big, outside, Woodstock type festivals in the summer over there...festival venues where bands at almost any level of fame can get the experience of playing to a sea of 40,000 people. If weezer had played a show like that here in the states, Ace would still be saying the same thing, but they've never had a chance to experience that in the US, since shows of that magnitude are not common place(too much violence or whatever), and =w= were never quite big enough to get on any of the Woodstock reunion bills...and who would want to anyway.
Whoever brought up the metal bands, makes a very good arguement. Metallica is all over the place with song structures, awkward time changes, etc...but they get a crowd pumping more then almost any act around! However, you could also say that stuff like "Hash Pipe" and "Fall Together" are actually steps in that sort of direction...it's weezer's unique cartoon version of it of course...but same type of riff/beat-based appeal.
|
weepeel
Registered User
Posts: 1
(3/11/02 11:36:26 am)
|
Re: what the fuck
god damn european's
GOD DAMN, ace... making basic music for basic people is easy
its been done
please make complicated music for complicated people
go back.
|
SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 33
(3/11/02 12:19:11 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Finally i can blame the failure of pinkerton on someone besides Rolling Stone, goddamn europeans. Anyway, does this mean you are gonna start using synths and drum uptempoed drum machines in your music like the beatles did with the sitars(i think thats how u spell it) when they entered their hippy acid stage (which, IMO, was a good period).
god i hate europeans....
oh yeah, and how come because they didnt like pinkerton, you knew it was doomed to bomb. Dont you think that was a pre-mature assumption seeing as how you didnt see the full US response yet. Im probably rambling on but im sick so fuck you.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 71
(3/11/02 12:20:22 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i can understand wanting to make music that makes people move and dance and head bang...but isn't that what most bands start out doing only to move on to more musical and lyric oriented music? examples: the beatles obviously, metallica to name a couple.
i guess ace is just moving backwards in his approach to song writing. personally though i'd rather recieve a letter from one fan telling me about how my song changed their life than see thousands of dancing teenagers. but then again, i'm not a rock star.
|
artfuse 
FEMALE
Posts: 79
(3/11/02 12:39:31 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
But Ace doesn't want to make music to appease a small group of listeners. Ace wants to rock the world.
I'm okay with more simplistic songs, Ace...just so long as they're intelligent and you put in the same amount of effort as you did on Blue and Pinkerton. In other words, don't sell integrity for success.
|
geekandproud
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/11/02 1:10:24 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
So what Ace wants is a rockin' live show?
Finally now, after all this time, I've seen the light. Things make so much more sense now. For once, I can see why Ace hates Pinkerton, and it's a pretty good reason, IMO.
Ace's last post makes me appreciate Green and Maladroit even more now; Now I can't wait to hear the new stuff live on their next tour.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/11/02 1:15:34 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Weezer = Radiohead.
The next record will be without guitars. . . Actually, i wonder what interscope would say if weezer turned in a house record. . . .
|
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 29
(3/11/02 1:21:24 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
then where the fuck did green come from? besides hash pipe, no songs on green are even remotely cool live.
pinkerton, you have el scorcho, the good life, getchoo, tired of sex, and why bother...all of which pump up the crowd.
man, thats such bullshit. go listen to that germany show that you rapped on undone. the germans were incredibly pumped up (WEEZAH! WEEZAH! WEEZAH!). that set was entirely blue and pinkerton, and the crowd was ina frenzy. you know why people don't get psyched for the shows? because alot of the time you just stand there, announce that "this next song is crab," and play it. then, you say "this one is knock-down drag-out." and on and on like your going through motions. the only time people get pumped is for the fucking confetti on only in dreams. it's gotten a little better, but the first midget tour blew. thats not how it used to be. weezon used to have a boot of el schorcho in which everyone in the crowd is singing "god damn you half-japanese girls," etc...you can feel the excitement from a mere recording, i can't imagine actually being there. If you want some fucking excitement, make it happen man. el scorcho may not be "structurally sound" or have some shitty techno beat, but its an awesome live song and makes for an awesome live show. who cares about a bunch of ecstacy popping european shits anyway? they only liked the techno bc they were high. nothing wrong with that, but don't base your entire musical catalogue on a bunch pill poppers.
you have everything so backwards. if you want a fun live show, put songs in that you know will get the crowd pumped up. the s2k songs, like o-girl, got crowds going. they are fun songs. i can understand not playing across the sea or butterfly...but if your not playing them, why play KDDO which sucks and doesn't pump up crowds at all? what you need to do is expirement with your setlist a little and see what gets crowds going. drop the whole structurally sound schtick and play some good songs god dammit.
|
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 30
(3/11/02 1:32:10 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
oh and all you people saying "oh! now i understand ace. now i love green and maladroit!" are cop outs that are just trying to agree with ace. i can't believe you people are so fickle as to be convinced by someone saying "across the sea doesnt pump up crowds like techno" that green is good. if anyone else said that you would shoot him down in a second. OFCOURSE across the sea wont pump up crowds...it doesnt have the vibe...surfwax, jonas, el scorcho, o-girl, hash pipe are examples of fun live songs. green SUCKS live. maladroit is a little funner but its still not very good. nothing on maladroit can ever be as fun as el scorcho live. not because people love pinkerton, BUT BECAUSE EL SCHORCHO IS A BETTER SONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!
either go all out with the cool metal or dont come out at all. none of this metal verse/poppy chorus crap like fall together. if ACE wants a good live show, he could easily have it. instead he plays mother fucking crab.
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/11/02 1:39:35 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
TRL rules.
(not the show)
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 137
(3/11/02 2:09:08 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
if there was no pinkerton -> no huge fan support in summer2k after hiatus -> no label backing of green album -> rivers gets no chance to rock out in front of huge audiences -> rivers teams up with matt and damon albarn to make crappy techno -> nobody cares -> rivers's career in music is over
|
weezonftp
Registered User
Posts: 6
(3/11/02 2:10:23 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
right you are nib
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 92
(3/11/02 2:26:35 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
hey- dont blame us! rivers can like what he wants. a festival set is an entirely different proposition from a regular gig. you have to grab the crowds attention and not let it go for the entire set. you have to stand out. at yr own gig, you can do whatever the hell you like since everyone is there to see you anyway. prodigy are a better festival band than weezer, because of that simple fact. weezer are somethin you have to get into, and absorb. prodigy just smack you around the head and force you to listen.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/11/02 2:31:09 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
'If it wasnt clear before: weezer is just as devoted to you guys as you guys are to weezer. The last thing they want to do is make fans unhappy.' Karl 12/4/2000
|
geekandproud
Registered User
Posts: 16
(3/11/02 3:18:25 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
quit living and dying by pinkerton. it was a great record, but not as good as what we've heard from maladroit. no one's really accepting any change from the band. let them grow and evolve. stop thinking that pinkerton is the best thing weezer's ever come up or ever WILL come up with.
green's a great record, too. not saying this because i'm a "cop out" or for the sole purpose of agreeing with ace, but because it's straight forward, solid rock/pop. and it's catchy as hell. you can't help but getting at least half the songs stuck in your head.
Edited by: geekandproud at: 3/11/02 3:27:29 pm
|
weezonftp
Registered User
Posts: 9
(3/11/02 3:25:12 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
well said geekandproud
i agree we should listen to this new stuff for what it is rather than weigh it against @#%$ and blue
weezer ain't the same band they were in 1996 or 1994, or a month ago
the new stuff rocks, you all know it
|
UserName
Registered User
Posts: 133
(3/11/02 3:25:29 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
"quit living and dying by pinkerton. it was a great record, but not as good as what we've heard from maladroit."
this is the gayest fuckin thing i have ever seen.
|
Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 105
(3/11/02 3:31:41 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I was thinking about this the other day, sort of. I was thinking about how cool it would be to have rock concerts like they had in the 60's. If any band could do it, I think Weezer could, I sort of envision them leading something huge.
But I think that simplification for mass consumption isn't really the answer, at least not to such an extreme degree. I think that if Weezer brought something accesible but really original and rocking, then, ace, you would be able to achieve the effect you want, maybe even to a higher degree. I mean, it's sort of like saying 'just do something sweet', but you guys totally have the talent to just rock and still write poppy, accesible songs, and a lot of bands just don't even have that ability.
EDIT: I meant to mention this, but forgot. I think Weezer is more ready for this than ever since Scott is in the band now. As Pat said, he just wants to play his bass like John Paul Jones
I think the most important thing here is, and I hope everyone agrees with me, I can sense a major change in popular culture soon, and it can't get any worse, really, so I hope it's for the better (i.e. like the 60's). I think that Weezer could totally catalyze this. No festival will ever go nuts for 'Don't Let Go', I think I understand what ace is saying about trying to make completly accesible songs, but to win the game, I think Weezer would be best off playing by it's own rules.
Edited by: Salvatore Paradise at: 3/11/02 3:35:52 pm
|
rezeeWeerez 
I am Penis.
Posts: 123
(3/11/02 3:34:24 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I am portuguese...i went to portugal for this last christmas and I see what ace means about pinkerton would bomb in europe, but I don't think it is the complexity of pinkerton that would bring them down, but rather the dark emotion of it. But keep in mind, this is a "Super-Bock" festival...super bock is a portuguese beer company, a big majority of the people there are gonna be drunk, guarenteed...so its no surprise they just want happy songs.
Edited by: rezeeWeerez at: 3/11/02 3:36:54 pm
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 60
(3/11/02 3:43:49 pm)
|
stadium rock is boring
the fact that weezer is pimping themselves out as stadium rock whores is the gayest thing they have ever done, including Teenage Victory Song. Moviestar, what is that crap? lame.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 72
(3/11/02 3:46:35 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i can't imagine basing what i do on the reaction of some drunk people in a country i've never been in.
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 93
(3/11/02 3:46:55 pm)
|
Re: stadium rock is boring
teenage victory song contains the greatest line in rock history, so it rules. kinda.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 61
(3/11/02 3:49:34 pm)
|
Re: stadium rock is boring
'mash you in the gnads' ?
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 138
(3/11/02 3:51:10 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i wasn't trying to bash the new stuff, but if rivers had never made pinkerton his career in music would be nowhere near where it is now, if existent at all. i really liked blue as soon as i heard it, but if green were the follow-up i would have just dismissed the band entirely and i wouldn't have gotten into it enough to find out where rivers was coming from when making his music. if it weren't for pinkerton weezer would have a career that lasted a couple years (a hiatus would not be tolerated by fans or the label) and they'd be quickly forgotten by the general public....... something along the lines of what i perceived third eye blind's career to be like
rivers can do what he wants musically at this point, but it's not cool of him to denounce the album that elevated his status to where it is
Edited by: this niblet at: 3/11/02 3:54:23 pm
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 94
(3/11/02 3:51:32 pm)
|
Re: stadium rock is boring
damn straight.
(edit: this was directed at nathan's recognition of The Greatest Line in Rock Historyô, not to the post above me which is gay. well, i havent read it yet, but its presumed gay until proven otherwise.)
Edited by: Hirose at: 3/11/02 3:56:29 pm
|
FFeJ and Raven 
Registered User
Posts: 42
(3/11/02 3:51:54 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Holy shit! Someone changed the subject line.
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 94
(3/11/02 3:54:40 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
don't blame the europeans. i would feel the same way in central and south america and asia. basically the entire world except the e.mo subcommunity of the u.s.
pull your heads out of your butts.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 62
(3/11/02 3:59:18 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I doubt if many people here would fall into that sub-community, we just aren't like the mindless herd of SamGoodyHMVVirginMegaTowerRecords album buying consumers who pick up the hot new release
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 139
(3/11/02 3:59:43 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
very few have long-lasting careers making music that has mass appeal for the world audience
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 73
(3/11/02 4:00:33 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i hope no one on this board listens to e.mo. i'm listening to the smiths right now, i don't own an "e.mo" cd. i don't even know what the hell e.mo is except shitty.
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 95
(3/11/02 4:00:38 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
ace... that festival comment has put so much in perspective for me. although i dont necessarily agree, it totally helps to see where yr coming from with the pinkerton thing.
|
asschun 
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 639
(3/11/02 4:01:10 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
fucking world
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 63
(3/11/02 4:01:53 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
not true, what about meneudo?
they had a long-lasting career AND world impact
Edited by: Nathaniel Hornblower at: 3/11/02 4:03:27 pm
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 95
(3/11/02 4:04:14 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
"very few have long-lasting careers making music that has mass appeal for the world audience"
we will. we're going to be the kings.
|
asschun 
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 640
(3/11/02 4:08:02 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i fear that
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 102
(3/11/02 4:09:08 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I don't think you necessarily have to listen to @#%$ to fall under that category...it seems like he's just saying in general, people at their concerts here want to be 'moved', whereas everywhere else they just want to be rocked...that's probably a horrible generalization, if it makes any sense at all...
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 242
(3/11/02 4:11:11 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i dont get it - do you want to play this kinda music because you actually like it, or is it just because you want to have a huge following?
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 96
(3/11/02 4:11:15 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
horses for courses
|
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 32
(3/11/02 4:14:05 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
". you can't help but getting at least half the songs stuck in your head." - geekandproud.
look, guy, who cares if songs get stuck in your head? the exact same thing happens when a backstreet boy or n'sync song comes on. those get stuck in your head all day. annoyingly catchy songs aren't good, they're just radio fodder. there are exceptions, like buddy holly. or big me by the foo fighters...
i don't hate maladroit, and i dont "live and die by pinkerton." i want weezer to move on. but i also want rivers to have some motivation and to actually care about what he writes instead of slapping a number 500 on it or however many songs hes written. the beatles started with annoyingly catchy tunes, and the progressed to greatness. weezer started with the perfect album..it had the perfect mixture of everything, then changed their style a little with pinkerton, and then completely regressed with green. this is how the logical order of albums shouldve been...green-blue-pinkerton...annoyingly catchy tunes can only get a band so far. ace needs to take it to the next level, and maladroit isnt even close to that. maladroit is just some pop music that is trying to be metal. reminds me of american hi-fi..and that is not good.
i want rivers to make a great rock album. its only appropriate that the man who spawned thousands of shitty @#%$ bands buries them. but c'mon, do you think maladroit can do that. rivers needs to go all out rock...that means take december and d+d out. that means ressurecting the fun style of the s2k songs. he needs fun, rockin tunes. green was too annoying to get huge, i sometimes had to turn it off bc the lyrics were so gay. its not a coincidence that weezer's best 2 singles since their return have been dope nose and hash pipe. Two s2k songs with that same good rock vibe, nonsense lyrics that have no traces of gay in them. can't rivers see a pattern here? maladroit has the same gay lyrics as green, except this time to wannabe metal songs. rivers, if you wanna get huge, you need solid ROCK songs, good singing, and crazy cryptic lyrics. THAT IS ALL. take all of the pseudo-@#%$ songs (d+d, december) and THROW THEM IN THE FUCKING TRASH CAN. ROCK
|
zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 60
(3/11/02 4:15:28 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
that's because all the e.mo kids do is whine, bitch, complain, and cry themselves to sleep
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 85
(3/11/02 4:20:41 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
To Rivers, it seems, music is about entertainment.
To most of us (including me), music is about a lot more than entertainment.
I would rather write a song that several people loved immensely and felt great emotional attachment to.. a true LOVE for the song.. instead of writing a song that thousands of people think sounds cool at a concert or on the radio. Who gives a shit, I mean, honestly..
And ace, you keep accusing Pinkerton-lovers of being e.mo.. have you taken into consideration that most of us here despise the whole e.mo thing? Just because it (seemed to) spawn that type of music doesn't mean it IS that type of music. It's just cathartic rock.
|
Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 106
(3/11/02 4:24:33 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Yeah, fuck e.mo.
I want Weezer to be big huge rockstars, personally. I don't see how that could be a bad thing. I think all the bullshit exclusivity (word or not?) that alot of people into music propogate serves only to strengthen the whole pop music circle, and therefore limits the amount of different and interesting music that recieves full distribution. So I mean, if Weezer were rockstars and made bunches of money, than maybe ACTUAL BANDS could get more freedom to make great music.
|
Cyprine
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/11/02 4:24:59 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Blue, like everything Weezer has created thus far, is far from perfect. However, you do have a point to a certain extent, TRL. I do agree that some of the past offerings sounded halfhearted at best, but I think Weezer is getting better, not worse. Incidentally, I believe "Death and Destruction" is one of the best tracks on Maladroit. Instead of evaluating the music solely based on lyrical content, I'm increasingly becoming more focused on the tune. I've never thought lyrics were Weezer's strength; they're always quirky, at times childish, yet endearing.
Pinkerton is not the next level.
S2k songs had their fair share of gay.
I'm also curious as to whether ace's goal is rock or pop perfection, or both? In any case, he's got his work cut out for him.
Weezer's music gained my favor solely because it was quality feel-good/power pop music, a niche that lately has found a prevailing vacancy. I can't object if they keep going in that direction. From commencement, Weezer has thrived in the mainstream, and that's where they should stay, there's nothing wrong with that.
Edited by: Cyprine at: 3/11/02 4:32:05 pm
|
zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 61
(3/11/02 4:29:21 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
"I want Weezer to be big huge rockstars, personally. I don't see how that could be a bad thing."
Honestly I couldn't care less if Weezer becomes larger than life, or if they go back to playing small venues. What matters to me is that the emphasis is placed where it should: on the music. I think that's the problem right now, everyone focuses on becoming huge and will go through any means to get there. If your music is good enough, and deserves to become that big, then it will. I would not have a problem seeing Weezer in a large stadium, as long as the music rocks.
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 401
(3/11/02 4:30:42 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
He wants to make faggots dance and like his songs long enough for them to climb the charts, and then never listen to them again.
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 140
(3/11/02 4:32:42 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
ace, if you manage to make music that the group at this board loves to the extent that we love your first two albums, and that the rest of the world can also rock out to, you'll be a god.
you haven't done that yet though.
and you don't have to make crappy pop for the world to love you. the world loves radiohead, and so do the people on this board.
what i think you're striving to do is to have the artistic and popular success of the beatles....... very ambitious.
|
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 34
(3/11/02 4:35:29 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i try to listen to music for music instead of lyrics. but have you ever listened to Green with someone who isnt in to weezer? you'll start thinking to yourself: "wow. this is really gay"
and if the s2k are somewhat gay then green/mala is pure faggotry.
i didnt say that pinkerton is the next level. i said that it was a bit different from blue and could be called progress. it pisses me off that weezer's hugeness is right at river's fingertips and he isnt taking advantage. if he knows whats good for him, take control will be the next single, and keep fishin wont be a single at all. and id rather have quirky(blue)/childish(pinkerton)/cryptic(sk2) lyrics than gay (green, mala). i think mala is better than green, but i wont call that "getting better" bc besides take control + dope nose, the album goes in the totally wrong direction.
|
sch2383
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/11/02 4:38:52 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Ace, I admire your balls for saying "we will. we're going to be the kings" please do. Hopefully that will kill the boy bands.
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 120
(3/11/02 4:39:06 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I said this in another thread but.. matt moved to europe, didn't he?
|
Cyprine
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/11/02 4:40:56 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I was one of those people who weren't into Weezer that listened to TGA-I didn't think it was gay, I thought it was refreshing, and easily the most accessible Weezer album.
I do agree that "Take Control" would make the best choice for first single.
|
Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE Penis, please.
Posts: 244
(3/11/02 4:41:01 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
i want weezer to be huge. its actually really important to me.
wouldnt want the music to revert to complete shit in order to accomplish this but, thing is, it hasnt done that at all. in my opinion anyway. this stuff is different from blue and pinkerton, of-fucking-course, but as ive said probably 600 times before, it's great music anyway.
and, this is what i'm thinking/hoping-- with the next album it'll start turning around again, songs w/ that personal hold to them. not cry-and-crap-me-in-the-pants emotion, but just something that you can tell actually means something to rivers. more than anything i think that's what people miss. and people will have to accept that variation of it if they wanna stay fans of weezer (if it happens at all). because it really doesnt seem like this basic style of songwriting will change any time soon.
|
zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 63
(3/11/02 4:42:12 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
Spain
|
Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 97
(3/11/02 4:43:44 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
maladroit is growing on me more and more and more. its a party record.
and stop saying 'mala'.
someone censor 'mala'.
|
sch2383
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/11/02 4:45:19 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
The Beatles conquered the world with their catchy early stuff and then moved into their heavier (better) stuff. When they did this they took most of the world with them.
|
geekandproud
Registered User
Posts: 17
(3/11/02 4:47:19 pm)
|
Re: what the fuck
I couldn't tell you about the BSB or NSYNC, only because I don't listen to the top 40 radio stations. Only time I've heard those guys in the past year is when they sneak into the Muzak playlist in my store. From what I can hear, all their stuff sounds the same. Wrong board, though, for discussing the merits of boy bands.
Back to the argument --- Those songs are 100x more disposable than anything Weezer's done, because Weezer's continually improving and changing things up. Don't dismiss the new stuff as crap just because they don't sound like the older records.
Alright you said you're not living or dying by Pinkerton (I'm assuming the same goes for blue) yet you make the same tired argument of "Blue was perfect, Pinkerton ruled, Green sux0rs."
Quit living in the fucking past. They aren't *TRYING* to re-create Buddy Holly or Undone. Give up on it and give the new shit a chance. They've pulled a total 180 and aren't the same band that won over millions by doing a "Happy Days" spoof.
They're trying something brand new, and they deserve tons of credit for that. There aren't many (if any) groups that could almost completely change their styles from album to album and make it work. If ace was TRYING to make Buddy Holly 2, he very well could. But he doesn't want to, so quit hoping for it.
|