← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
New Topic    Add Reply

Page 1 2

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
Grimmas
Registered User
Posts: 82
(3/8/02 5:11:25 pm)
Reply
Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
according to the Michigan Daily...

heres' the list
*********************

The list is definitive.

Wholly and completely.

This was called for.

It was long overdue.

The 50 Greatest Bands of All Time in popular music. Our choices, but our choices are inpenetrable ó not able to be penetrated. There is no room for argument. We have not forgotten anything, or anyone. Each band in the annals of history has been considered for this list. We have forgotten no one.

Bands were selected for this list based on a few simple criteria. The first criterion was simply that artists would have to be in a band and in a band that plays its own instruments and music. The second criterion is that a band must have released two studio albums. However, there are times when we (those who made the list) have made specific additions or concessions with the selection of the list. These concessions were made in the name of the greater good of the list. It was our decision and we stand by it. Firmly.

This list, like other lists, should serve to incite discussion over a coffee table or some other piece of household furniture. It is nothing to get upset over. It is to enjoy.

ó The Michigan Daily Arts Editors



1The Beatles ó Would any other artist truly belong atop this list? The answer is a resounding, ìNo.î The Rolling Stones, The Beach Boys, The Velvet Underground ó all these bands find themselves leagues behind the Beatlesí songcrafting and influence. The Liverpudlians created the traditional concept of the album, and through that creation, inspired every musician who has picked up an instrument afterwards. Thirty-five years later, each Beatles song retains both relevance and greatness.

>>No argument here>>

2 The Rolling Stones ó Pepsi or Coke, boxers or briefs, ìEmpireî or ìJediî? Some debates are never settled. Southern Englandís answer to The Beatles is dirtier, more dangerous, and definitely more drugged out. They made being ugly into a fashion statement, and their more heavily blues influenced rock íní roll is still as relevant today as it was when the foot-stomping chords of ìSatisfactionî blared out of every teenagerís radio in 1965, angering parents everywhere and hooking kids for life.

<>

3 The Beach Boys ó Not all Beach Boys songs are about girls, cars or surfing. While the image of the southern California group conjures up simplistic songs with beautiful harmonies, the later efforts of the group provided some of the most interesting and complex music of the era. When Brian Wilson stopped touring with the group to concentrate on producing and dropping acid, The Beach Boys created their most accomplished work, none more impressive than 1966ís Pet Sounds, quite possibly the best album ever crafted.

<>

4 The Jimi Hendrix Experience ó With only three amazing albums in four short years, Jimi Hendrix re-invented electric guitar and managed to create heavy metal in the process. His (literally) fiery entrance on to the American scene at the Monterey Pop Festival in 1967 let people know that rock was inexorably changed. Although he was actually painfully self-conscious about his singing voice, Hendrix had a exciting and dynamic stage presence that just made music look damn fun.

<>

5 The Velvet Underground ó The Velvets charted only one of their four legitimate albums on the Billboard 200 (the fifth album involved none of the original Velvets) Velvet Underground & Nico charted at 199. Despite near non-existent album sales during their time as a band, the Velvet Underground garnered a small fan-base which continued to expand after the groupís demise. If traced through time the Velvet Undergroundís harsh, brooding and sometimes menacing brand of proto-punk mainlined itself into todayís indie rock.

<>

6. Frank Zappa and The Mothers of Invention ó There is no mistaking Frank Zappa and The Mothers of Invention. Avant-garde at its finest, Zappa and his entourage of musical misfits entwined social commentary, satirical lyrics, experimentation and jazz-influenced jam sessions into their vast catalogue of material. More than thirty years later, their music is as fresh and inventive as it was when originally released. After landmark albums such as Absolutely Free and Weíre Only in It for the Money, Zappa went on to do equally gratifying solo work, including a guest appearance on ìRen & Stimpyî as The Pope.

<>

7. Nirvana ó Thankfully, Kurt Cobain died before he blew it. If you consider Bleach to be a demo recorded by a mostly different band, then Nirvana released two great albums. Sure, Butch Vigís plastic production of Nevermind slightly hinders an otherwise stellar ìdebutî (see above) record, and Steve Albiniís trademark treatment of In Utero grates against some people, but the bandís energy and anger tear through regardless. William Burroughs, who once worked with Kurt Cobain, said that Kerouacís ìOn the Road,î ìsold a trillion Levis and a million espresso machines.î Kurt Cobain sold a billion cardigans and ten million slacker kids on the idea of working those espresso machines while living in their parentsí basements. At least he apologized.

<>

8. Led Zeppelin ó These rowdy boys from Britain didnít invent blues-driven rock or drugs-and-groupie-fueled excess; they just made them big enough to fill arenas and VH1 specials for years to come. Unfortunately, even these larger than life rock ìgodsî couldnít rule over that runaway train and it all came to a close, after five super solid albums and a few subsequent shitty ones, with one of rockís greatest drummers lying dead in his own vomit.

<>

9. Bob Marley and the Wailers ó Contrary to the widespread belief that Legend is the only album with Marleyís songs on it, there are actually close to a dozen that were released between 1973 and 1980, all of which are nearly flawless. Peter Tosh and Bunny Wailer, Marleyís original crew from The Wailers, left after Catch a Fire and Burniní, but with the Barretts and Al Anderson backing him up, Marley maintained his level of excellence on his other albums. Bob Marley became a political inspiration, and he was one of the most charismatic live performers ever.

<>

10. The Zombies ó One of the lesser-known gems from the British Invasion, The Zombies found success in 1965 with top 10 hits ìSheís Not Thereî and ìTell Her No.î Their rough garage band sound on their debut album Being Here evolved into a harmony-heavy-psychedelic-rock synthesis for what would be their second and final album, 1969ís Odyssey & Oracle. ìWhatís your name/Whoís your daddy,î timeless lyrics from ìTime of the Season,î are perhaps the most recognizable of The Zombiesí work, only to be marred by sexual innuendos.

<>

11. Love ó The best band youíve never heard of. The Los Angeles group fronted by Arthur Lee was the first band on Elektra, only to be shoved aside for future label-mates The Doors. Guitarist Bryan MacLean and lead singer Lee composed most of the bandís work, but their first hit was a rendition of Burt Bacharachís ìMy Little Red Book.î Never attaining the popularity of fellow West Coast band The Doors, Love was more of a cult phenomenon than a mainstream success. With its soothing melodies and witty lyrics, their 1967 album Forever Changes remains one of the best rock albums ever made.

<>

12. Sly and the Family Stone ó In addition to helping to bring funk to the mainstream and being the first racially and sexually integrated groups in popular music, Sly and the Family Stone attacked politics and social issues in their horn and bass filled songs. Sly Stoneís drug problem and the end of the idealistic í60s took their music away from ìDance to the Musicî and down a darker path, but 1973ís Fresh remains a funk classic, with incredible tracks like ìIf you want me to stay.î

<>

13. Ramones ó Bands before them outlined what could be punk, but the Ramones were the first true punk band. Their songs were minimally complex, but incredibly catchy. Four chords would be mixed together behind catchy melodies and lyrics that at times, truly meant nothing. But the Ramonesí contribution to music as a whole meant more than anything. The Ramones self-titled debut set the standard, and created the genre. The Ramonesí vitality is felt to this day with the ridiculous amounts of all-too-prevalent pop-punk artists who shamelessly rip them at every chord change.

<>

14. The Pixies ó A respectable career in rock and roll comes down to knowing when to get out. The Pixies released five albums in four years and were just reaching their biggest audiences when frontman Black Francis (now Frank Black) ended the band. Nirvana acknowledged them as the inspiration for the quiet verse/loud chorus dynamic that made Nevermind a hit and spread grunge across the country. Bassist Kim Deal went on to moderatesuccess with the Breeders and Frank Black released a string of initially stellar and later unremarkable solo records. Though the band themselves were never cool, knowing about the Pixies will make you think that you are.


15. Parliament Funkadelic ó With a sound from outer space and a name history too confusing to even get into, Parliament ruled í70s funk. Lead singer and founder George Clinton and bass player Bootsy Collins took a cue from James Brown and Sly Stone, adding outrageous costumes and freaky science fiction to their infectious brand of funk. Despite a lull in popularity in the í80s, P-Funk, sometimes going by The P-Funk All-Stars, have stayed on the scene.

<>

16. The Kinks ó Early hits from this popular British import, such as ìYou Really Got Meî and ìAll Day and All of the Night,î sounded nearly identical. It wasnít until 1966 with the album Face to Face when The Kinks went from concentrating on hit singles into making strong, cohesive albums. Post ìLola,î Ray Davies and company fell apart musically and never reached the plateau they attained in the late 60s.

<>

17. The Yardbirds ó The term ìSuper-groupî is thrown around lightly these days, but this ever-morphing London group featured, over its six year run, three of the greatest guitarists of all time: Eric Clapton, Jimmy Page and the under-appreciated Jeff Beck. Depending on the line-up, their music ranged from the poppy melody of ìFor Your Loveî to traditional blues.

<>

18. The Who ó Hypocrites. In 1965 Roger Daltrey in ìMy Generationî declared, ìI hope I die before I get old.î Save for drummer Keith Moon, the band failed to commit to their own decree. Smashing instruments and trampled fans made The Who rock legends, if only someone had told them to stop making music after Quadrophenia the band may have landed a better position on the list.

<>

19. Buddy Holly and the Crickets ó Only 22 years old at the time of his death, Buddy Holly wrote the best rock songs of the late í50s, which are still heavily influencing bands today (e.g. The Strokes). While many of his songs were released as solo projects (ìPeggy Sueî and ìRave Onî for starters), Holly released classics like ìThatíll be the Dayî and ìMaybe Babyî with the one-time garage band. Less well known is the fact that Holly pioneered studio sound techniques that, although standard today, were revolutionary in 1957.

20. Guns Ní Roses ó In 1987 Guns Ní Roses slit the wrist of everything that the lighthearted í80s pop scene with their now legendary debut Appetite for Destruction. Guns captured all the greed, grit and excess that was L.A. in the 1980s. The band brought an element of danger and controversy to the rock world not felt since Led Zeppelin ruled the roost. Axl with his inimitable yowl and rattlesnake-shake coupled with toxic twin Slashís top-hat, dangling cigarette and low slung Les Paul made a duo that matched every ounce of talent with a pound of style.

<>

21. NWA ó The worldís most dangerous group came straight outta Compton and straight into the hearts and minds of millions of Americans sick of the bubblegum rap of the Fat Boys and their ilk. Ice Cube, Dr. Dre, Yella, MC Ren and drug-dealer turned producer turned rapper Easy E created gangsta rap by rhyming their life stories and ghetto-fantasies of shooting 8 balls, slapping bitches and fucking the police. The FBI turned out to be the better than any ad agency, selling millions of NWA units by coming out against the bands quiet protestation of the LAPD.

<>

22. Black Sabbath ó Despite the nonsensical cover featuring a blurred warrior with a plastic shield and sword, Black Sabbathís second album Paranoid is the definition of a heavy metal masterpiece. Tony Iommiís skilled guitar and Ozzy Osbourneís eerie vocals resulted in the darkest rock music of the early 70s. The group produced several classic albums and songs, but their legendary single ìIron Manî is perhaps the most well known guitar riff in rock history.

<>

23. The Talking Heads ó Long before it was cool to be geeky or to incorporate African rhythms into stripped down pop rock, David Byrne headed this group of art school punks from 1977 to 1988. Most people think of Byrne in the big white suit from the concert film ìStop Making Sense,î but Byrneís and the Headsí influence goes beyond their contemporaries, reaching into the í80s and í90s. Music isnít always an art-form, but for The Talking Heads, it was inseparable.

<>

24. Radiohead ó Sans Pablo Honey, the Oxford quintet has a library of albums stronger than any current group in music today. While Radiohead has continued to release impressive albums, their best work in the last year has been guest starring on South Park in the lauded episode ìScott Tenorman Must Die.î Fun Radiohead fact: Their single ìParanoid Androidî from 1997ís Grammy-winner OK Computer, with its three songs for the price of one format, is based on The Beatlesí ìHappiness is a Warm Gun.î

<>

25. The Clash ó Forget the anarchism of The Sex Pistols and the ìsave the worldî malarkey of U2; The Clash were left-wing, passionate rockers who infused their punk with reggae and dub, and although their U.S. success was fleeting, the finely crafted songs of Mick Jones and Joe Strummer, especially on their í77 self-titled debut and í79ís London Calling, have given them deity status both here and abroad.

<>

26. Elvis Costello and The Attractions ó Remember what we said about discretion and knowing when to stop the rock? Case in point: Elvis Costello and The Attractions were never stellar, but what they lacked musically they made up for in youthful attitude and delinquent angst. Witness the snarling Costello spitting out the words to ìRadio, Radioî on Saturday Night Live in 1977 against his record companyís wishes ó the song is good, the posturing was great. If only it was just guys named Elvis who didnít know when to quit.

27. Pavement ó Pavementís disjointed lo-fi junk cultureíd music found a quasi-large audience in a group of mainstream jaded indie scenesters in the early 90s. Their sporadic songs sucked the apathy out of ìalternativeî and replaced it with lethargy. Pavementís early albums were marked by their stop-start guitars, blasts of feedback and white noise, off-kilter tempo and the laconic sustained speech delivery of Stephen Malkmus. Pavement was the ìMcSweeneyís Quarterly Attemptî of ë90s rock.

28. Cream ó The intoxicating guitar of Eric Clapton, the syncopated drumming of Ginger Baker and the intriguing, quasi-lounge singer vocals of Jack Bruce were a strange combination, but their flashy, psychedelic, blues based rock rises above the retroactive criticism it has received. Songs like ìSunshine of Your Love,î ìWhite Roomî and ìCrossroadsî helped bring Eric Clapton into the U.S. mainstream, for his previous work with The Yardbirds and John Mayallís Bluesbreakers went largely unnoticed.

<>

29. The Police ó They wanted to be punk so bad they could taste it, but they just plain werenít. A mixture of reggae, pop rock and jazz, mixed with Stingís yowling lead vocals and the superb backing of Stewart Copeland on drums and Andy Summers on guitar, carved The Police their place in music history. Internal strife, mostly between Sting and Copeland, broke the band up after their multi-platinum 1983 album Synchronicty.

<>

30. The Beastie Boys ó Brooklyn natives Adam Yauch, Adam Horovitz and Mike Diamond proved white men could rap with their White Castle inspired lyrics. The trio demonstrated they were more than clever lyricists when they began to play their own instruments on 1992ís Check Your Head.

The pairing of The Beastie Boys with up and coming producers The Dust Brothers culminated with 1989ís Paulís Boutique, their finest effort.

<>

31. The Stooges ó Hostile as hell. Not nearly as intelligent, but undoubtedly dirtier than the Velvet Underground, both bands addressed similarly subversive topics, but in dissimilar fashions. Where the Velvets were coy, the Stooges slapped audiences around with grime and sweat. When David Bowie mixed Raw Power people panned it for sounding too thin, but what the record revealed was Iggy Pop for the raving lunatic genius that he is.

<>

32. Simon and Garfunkel ó Sure, Paul Simon and his faux-afro loving partner Art where no better than a couple of pretentious English majors playing the guitar for their prude girlfriends on a hilly brush, but their lyrics and harmony remain unmatched. Their five albums together, from 1964ís Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. through1970ís Bridge Over Troubled Water produced pop classics that became standard, timeless ballad (ìThe Sound of Silence,î the first time they used an electric guitar) and comfortably dated time-capsule fare (Mrs. Robinson).

33. Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young ó While theyíre all right on their own, the addition of Neil Youngís oily high-pitched drawl takes Stephen Stills, Graham Nash and David Crosbyís vocals and forces them into tightly packed harmony. On DÈjý vu the dichotomy is at its most crystal clear, CSN singing with one voice battling it out with Y, not for dominance but for resonance. As close to perfection as four old addicts can get.

34. Public Enemy ó Hip-hop pioneers who ushered in the first socio-political consciousness into the genre. Most noted for their 1988 masterpiece It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back, the bandís militant message inflicted an unique controversy that separated them from, and often pit them against, the popular ìgangsta rapî uprise of the time.

<>

35. T. Rex ó Glam rock pioneers T. Rex never had the success on this side of Atlantic they enjoyed in Britain during their heyday from 1970 to 1974. Only the catchy chorus of ìBang a Gong (Get It On)î from their 1971 album Electric Warrior could get the attention of American music consumers. Marc Bolan, the towering singer/songwriter of the band, heavily influenced co-glam rocker David Bowie. T. Rexís career ended abruptly with the untimely death of Bolan in 1977. Rock.

<>

36. Neil Young and Crazy Horse ó The patriarch of grunge-guitar first teamed with guitarist Danny Whitten, bassist Billy Talbot and drummer Ralph Molina on 1969ís Everybody Knows This is Nowhere, spawning the masterpiece ìCinnamon Girl.î Despite the occasional side project and his work with CSNY (see No. 33), Young has remained faithful to the three, and they continue to make good old fashioned cantankerous rock.

37. A Tribe Called Quest ó Instead of following the trend of gangsta rap, Tribe, made up of Q-Tip, Phife and Ali Shaheed Muhammad, were artistic, intelligent, political and funny, all while blending jazz and hip-hop, creating a new form of music along with contemporaries such as De La Soul. Tribeís second album, The Low End Theory, while not the most commercially viable, is one of the best and most important hip-hop albums ever produced.

38, The Grateful Dead ó With the possible exception of Kiss, the Dead are the only band to have has also generated their own dynamic subculture. Alongside Bob Marley, the Deadís music represents the best of the ìpeace, love and gettiní highî theme. But listeners can hate Deadheads and all they stand for while retaining a genuine appreciation for the sheer technical virtuosity behind the Deadís unique blend of musical Americana.

39. The Roots ó The only instrumentally backed hip-hop group that matters, their longevity speaks for itself. Black Thought easily makes the top five-list of best emceeís of all time, and the band members consistently compliment each otherís styles to make for their crisp sound. Their onstage versatility combined with amazing beat-boxers and vicious lyrical exercise make their sound essential to the genre.

<>

40. Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band ó Silvio Dante, guitarist Little Steven Van Zandtís character on ìThe Sopranosî definitely wouldnít listen to The Boss and his stellar line-up of serious rock musicians. Make fun of ìDancing in the Darkî all you want, these guys may be the last unapologetic rock band that doesnít resort to goofy self-indulgence or post-modern ironic hatred in order to seem relevant. They know theyíre relevant because they know theyíre great.

41. Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five ó One of the three godfathers of rap music, he is the creator of the cutting and backspins that dominate the music today. Created a then-innovative sound by working with the ìwhoís whoî of golden age hip-hop. He and his group, the Furious Five, dominated the airwaves before you even came into your miserable existence.

42. @#%$ Floyd ó When youíre on acid, they suddenly become like Socrates, they make perfect sense and you wonder why no one else is looking at the colors pouring forth from your boom box, colors you can smell. Roger Waters is a god, and their jam sessions make Phish look like grandpaís polka band. Even their newer material has a refreshingly trippy quality that seems less store-bought than their many pseudo-indie ìI love drugsî progeny.

<>

43. The Doors ó Robbie Krieger, Ray Manzarek and John Densmore were overshadowed by UCLA film student turned sex icon leader singer Jim Morrison. Their 1967 self titled debut is one of rockís strongest first attempts, but their subsequent albums never matched the energy and audaciousness of the album. The whole record has a consummate feel of professionalism, which really gives the songs a big boost.

44. Weezer ó Their debut ironically melded KISSí stadium rock with the Beach Boysí pop sensibilities. Fueled by the smash-hit ìBuddy Holly,î Weezer rose immediately to fame. However, it was the morally bankrupt brainchild of singer/songwriter/dictator Rivers Cuomo Pinkerton that solidified Weezer musically. The darkly sexual record opened Cuomoís soul and desires to world and gave mainstream music a too personal shot in the arm. While Weezerís third LP displayed subpar songs from the previous two, it ushered in a renaissance from the band that had fallen off the face of the earth.

<>

45. The Faces ó Before Rod Stewart plummeted into his ìDo you think Iím sexy Ö î suck-fest, he and soon-to-be Rolling Stones guitarist Ron Wood were recruited to lead The Faces, who lived the booze and women lifestyle to the extreme. They are remembered mostly for their one major hit, ìStay With Meî and the use of ìOoh la laî at the end of ìRushmore,î but A Nod Is As Good As Wink To A Ö Blind Horse is an enduring album.

46. Pearl Jam ó They came together artistically just as Nirvana was dressing up the early í90s in flannel. Pearl Jamís first effort, Ten, is a hard-rock throw-back to the í70s with painfully-thoughtful lyrics by front man Eddie Vedder. While their later efforts have lacked the originality and intensity of Ten and Vs., they still stand as the true disciples of grunge-godfather Neil Young, and the fact that Vedder didnít parish as a young, tormented artist should not be held against them.

<>

47. The Meters ó Unlike the hard, cornered funk of James Brown, the New Orleans funk of The Meters is full of organ grooves and mellow rhythms. The group, led by Art Neville, never achieved any great measure of popular success, but their laid back style has been a massive influence for funk of the last decades.

48. Metallica ó Donít let recent events and albums cloud the truth: Metallica, for much of the í80s and for the early part of the í90s, WAS metal, not just a part of the genre but the genre in and of itself. Angry, bludgeoning songs about war and death like ìBatteryî and ìDisposable Heroesî driven by lightning fast downstrokes and patches of doublebass sold hundreds of thousands of albums and concert tickets all without the aid of MTV and radio. Metallicaís brash and unforgiving songs spoke to a generation of working class white teenagers like nothing else could, heavily influencing a generation of young metal-ers.

<>

49. Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band ó Lucid tentacles test ín sleeved/ ín joined ín jointed jade pointed/ Diíamond back patterns/ Neon meate dream of a octafish/ Artifact on rose petals/ ín flesh petals ín pots/ Fack ín feast ín tubes tubs bulbs/ In jest incest injest injust in feast incest/ ín specks ín speckled speckled/ Speckled speculation/ Fedlocks waddliní feast/ Archaic faces frenzy/ Ceramic fists artificial deceased/ ín cists rancid buds burst/ Dank drum ín dung dust/ Meate rose ín hairs/ Meaty meate rose ín hairs/ Meaty dream wet meate/ Limp damp rows/ Peeled ín felt fields ín belts/ Impaled on ín daeman/ Mucus mules/ Twot trot tra la tra la/ Tra la tra la tra la/ Whale bone fields ín belts/ Whale bone farmhouse/ Cavorts girdled ín latters uh lite/ Cavorts girdled ín latters uh lite/ Uh dipped amidst/ Squirminí serum ín semen ín syrup ín semen ín serum/ Stirrupped in syrup/ Neon meate dream of a octafish.

Fuck yeah.

<>

50. Tenacious D ó Comedy rock has never been so serious. They call themselves the greatest and best band in the world. They are the Thor and Loki of pop music, mightily overweight slinging acoustic guitars and clever songs like a musical sharp-shooting Legolas. They take no prisoners, only womenís hearts for th

this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 127
(3/8/02 5:22:48 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i will invariably always get pissed about something or other in these lists, but I think this is probably the best one I've ever read.


Ace must love being ranked above Pearl Jam and Metallica.

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 61
(3/8/02 5:27:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Did I miss something or are the Smashing Pumpkins really not in the list.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 109
(3/8/02 5:37:51 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
this list is a farce...you can never take a list seriously until it has creed and limp bizket on it.

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 14
(3/8/02 5:47:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i think that list is the biggest piece of shit ever compiled..first it leaves off some very good bands...and, secondly for what it says about kurt cobain...good thing he died before he blew it? fuck the people that wrote that...lists are all opinionated anyways...everyone picks and chooses their own influences...surely i dont rate frank zappa up in the top fifty, while they did...i think the whole thing is worthless

edit: seems they focus way to much on cultural aspects of the bands..ie..appearences on south park..trends each sparked off...does this make bands important..if so, then i guess nsync and all those bands could be ranked up there for all the trends they have given us...bah

Edited by: or0phin at: 3/8/02 5:52:22 pm
Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 35
(3/8/02 5:49:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
wtf, u2 is not on the list either.

jimboner
Registered User
Posts: 47
(3/8/02 6:06:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Where the fuck are Blur and the Pumpkins? VU should be number two.

chingchinonack
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/8/02 6:48:17 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
This list does seem pretty good to me. And about the Kurt Cobain comment...isn't it possible that he would have run out of steam, or that he eventually would have ceased to be so relevevant with the changing musical scene? Just a thought. I do think he's a master though.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 70
(3/8/02 7:01:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
He committed suicide because he sucked.

Edited by: Newt Floss at: 3/8/02 7:02:36 pm
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 110
(3/8/02 7:02:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
missing some great bands and the order is kinda fucked, but pavement's on there, and that at least gets the writer(s) some respect from me.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 110
(3/8/02 7:16:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
pavement being on there, i don't mind...but pavement being #27..i don't agree with.

P.ink floyd being in the 40s is also too low for them.

Chris820
Registered User
Posts: 13
(3/8/02 7:25:48 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
@#%$ floyd is overrated and boring.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/8/02 8:44:42 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
there are other pieces that go with the list, one of them was a piece that outlining specifically why U2 wouldn't be on the list.
and for whoever said the velvets should be number 2, I agree, but the other six guys that compiled this with won out.

EDIT: tenacious d was on there as a joke. the picture we put of them on the page was them in their underwear.

Edited by: A Preachers Son at: 3/8/02 8:51:17 pm
sonicicefusion
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/8/02 8:45:52 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
why is tenacious d on there.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 111
(3/8/02 9:07:55 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Why the hell is NWA and Public Enemy on there instead of run dmc?

how about Judas Priest? Iron Maiden? Van Halen?

Chris820
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/8/02 9:27:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i second the van halen comment.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 20
(3/8/02 9:34:08 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
had VH stopped making music after 1984 they woulda certainly made the list. But the overwhelming gayness of everything post- 1984 immediately rules them out.
And don't complain about the Rolling Stone having bad records, or the Who, because while both of those bands have put out some shit -- their previous work stands above it. easily.

I should post some of the gay emails we got from girls on campus complaining that Janet Jackson and girl-groups like Bananarama and the B52s weren't on the list. They were bitching because apparently the list wasn't an E.O.E. employer.

ArthurDent again
Registered User
Posts: 30
(3/8/02 9:46:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Damn, my first post was removed. Anyways the Cobain line is great and the list is quite good. The only complaint I have with it is that Queen isn't on it. But oh well, it beats the shit out of Spin's list.

Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE
Penis, please.

Posts: 196
(3/8/02 9:50:42 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
whoever said u2 should be on it... um. u2's alright, but they certainly don't deserve to be on anyone's best-50-bands list.

skratchaholik
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/8/02 10:03:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
fuck that, where is Rage Against the Machine? I like Tenacious D and all, but they SHOULD NOT BE number 50. I am glad the Roots made it.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 21
(3/8/02 10:56:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
RATM = overrated and gay.
See previous posts for tenacious D explainations.

jimboner
Registered User
Posts: 48
(3/8/02 11:02:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Hey, RATM ain't that bad, they kinda declined as they grew older though. Rivers should listen to only Lou Reed tunes, think of the amazing shite he'd write after listening the "Sister Ray" 4 times in a row.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 22
(3/8/02 11:10:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
amen.

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 588
(3/9/02 1:12:58 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
radiohead is only 24?

Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 36
(3/9/02 2:49:11 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
u2 belongs, definitely. they were band of the 80s, and joshua tree is consistently in the top on best album lists along with achtung baby. all that you can't leave behind and war are up there too.

ArthurDent again
Registered User
Posts: 31
(3/9/02 2:59:39 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
U2 is one of the worst bands ever. As far as I'm concerned they have 2 songs, "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and that other song, you know, the one that sounds like every other song that they have recorded. And yet they claim to have 6 or however many albums??! Christ on a bike! And then Bono has the nerve to bitch at everyone else in the States about not caring about the bloodshed going on in Ireland, what a cocksmoker. We all know that Ireland is a piss poor excuse for a country and that God-willing those drunken Bible-toting redheads will exterminate themsleves as soon as possible. Anyhow, I mean, really, U2's "best album", the Joshua Tree has three relatively decent songs, and those were all of that album's singles. I'm sorry, if you're best album has only three decent songs, then you are not good enough for any top 50 list.

Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 37
(3/9/02 3:07:37 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
(This message was left blank)

Edited by: Sifter  at: 3/9/02 3:11:59 am
Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 38
(3/9/02 3:11:30 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
considering that u2 through each album has changed a ton over the years your reply seems pretty uninformed. joshua tree is great music through and through but i'd say achtung baby is their best album.

lets not forget u2's live show, which is one of the best. weezer's live show on the other hand fucking sucks.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/9/02 3:11:55 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
considering that U2 changing for the gay-er and continuing despite the changes to remain gay at or beneath an initial level of gay warrants their lack of inclusion on this list. U2 is green album gay.

ArthurDent again
Registered User
Posts: 32
(3/9/02 3:11:56 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
You mean they went from poor whiny potato farmers to rich whiny potato plantation owners?

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/9/02 3:14:22 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
you forgot the adjective gay, to be used as a quasi-prefix to the 'poor white potato farmers' bit.
u2 is definitely gay.

ArthurDent again
Registered User
Posts: 33
(3/9/02 3:15:49 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
touchee.

And since when was being a good live band part of the criteria for making the list, assfuck.

karlophone
**Champion of All Time**
Posts: 12
(3/9/02 3:28:42 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
only missing Devo IMHO. other noted omissions are fine for the top 100, but Devo (the 5 albums 1978-1982) has cultural importance far beyond most bands.

anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 79
(3/9/02 3:30:24 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
bono and U2 have become bitches for the recording industry unlike in the past (i.e. this year's grammys)

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/9/02 3:52:55 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i got shot down on the devo thing.
and i just checked.
u2 is still gay.

anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 81
(3/9/02 4:03:40 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
DEVO fucking rocks.
i'm not just saying that.

DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 105
(3/9/02 4:04:16 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Buddy Holly and the Crickets, Jane's Addiction, the Residents, the Smiths, it goes on and on... so many should be said, so many shouldnt, its a vicious cycle
whoever said Public enemy shouldnt be on there doesnt know anything about music, period.
again, with U2... a truly great rock band whos been consistent and truthful. they should be recognized... and saying theyre bitches to the recording industry is totally ignorant. you dont know shit
but as far as lists go, dont put too much credit in them, especially if its from some daily newspaper

YeahYeah
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/9/02 4:21:08 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
adding to daflavah's recent comment- i must admit a truth...U2 is NOT gay...rather far from it...their contributions to the music world even political world have gone far and beyond what a majority of the other bands out there have, listed... their music has meaning behind it and judging them on their recent accomplishments in a negative light is just.....well lame.... give it a few years... its probably just a phase of ignorance youre going through...
(i am not U2 obsessed....therefore i will state ANOTHER band that slipped by this oh so great list....how bout making another list with Sex Pistols....YES...and The Cure.

ArthurDent again
Registered User
Posts: 34
(3/9/02 1:44:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
U2 is gay. Buddy Holly and the Crickets ARE and SHOULD BE on the list.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 115
(3/9/02 3:34:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Rivers will be pissed that KISS is not on there.

if VH is not on there because of their gayness in the mid 80s..then take out metallica as well.

NWA beat black sabbath...damn.

DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 108
(3/9/02 4:11:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
EXPLAIN WHY U2 IS GAY.
ITLL BE THE WEAKEST ARGUMENT EVER

DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 110
(3/9/02 4:48:24 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
SEE
IF YOU CANT BACK UP AN ARGUMENT, ESPECIALLY A WEAK ONE, DONT SAY IT

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 26
(3/9/02 5:57:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
gay.

DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 112
(3/10/02 1:15:06 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
great comback preachers son

YeahYeah
Registered User
Posts: 11
(3/10/02 3:46:54 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
hey daflavah..maybe gay to him means..."i have no argument i am sorry and bow to the higher intelligence of good music that i could not understand or comprehend" :)
(with all due respect...of course)

Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 72
(3/10/02 5:58:50 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i'm gonna have to agree that U2 = gay.

they just suck ass.

apart from 'with or without you'.

Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE
Penis, please.

Posts: 210
(3/10/02 6:20:21 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i kinda like "stuck in a moment you can't get out of" also. but beautiful day is absolute shit.

oh, another good one is "in a little while." i dled this after i read that this was the last song that joey ramone heard before he died. his brother played it for him, or so i read, and when the song ended he had already passed away. when you listen to it, it's pretty haunting if you think of it in that way. good song overall, though, as well.

Scully5
FEMALE
Posts: 23
(3/10/02 9:52:47 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
U2 should've been on there. (whatever, i tell you, I love their older songs, they are GREAT)

@#%$ floyd should've been ranked higher.

The list was decent, but it would've kicked ass if Devo had been on there.

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 378
(3/10/02 9:55:18 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Preacher's Son is the winner.

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 606
(3/10/02 10:21:28 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
24. Radiohead ó Sans Pablo Honey, the Oxford quintet has a library of albums stronger than any current group in music today. While Radiohead has continued to release impressive albums, their best work in the last year has been guest starring on South Park in the lauded episode ìScott Tenorman Must Die.î Fun Radiohead fact: Their single ìParanoid Androidî from 1997ís Grammy-winner OK Computer, with its three songs for the price of one format, is based on The Beatlesí ìHappiness is a Warm Gun.î

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 54
(3/10/02 10:43:26 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
That's probably a list that I agree with the most out of all those "types" of best of things printed. and no, god no, u2 should NOT be on there. Like someone said, they have two good songs "sonday, bloody sunday" and that song that sounds just like all the rest of their songs.

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/10/02 11:29:27 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
bono is a piece of shit. and any band whose guitarist calls himself "the edge" is gay

DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 115
(3/10/02 11:36:52 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
what losers...

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 116
(3/10/02 11:46:27 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
if any hip-hop/rap artist should've been on there it should've been the beastie boys (although they are a genre all their own). Radiohead should be higher, the same list in 5 years should have them higher. I may have missed it, but where's Oasis, though i'm not a huge fan, they were HUGE in the mid-nineties and they have some pretty great tunes. If Oasis isn't on there, U2 shouldn't be on there, U2 were good when they actually stood for something, now they're just rich old guys.

Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 40
(3/10/02 12:34:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
they still stand for something, just listen to the end of walk on. fuckin.g great, uplifting musical moment.

also, u2's songs sound...nothing alike, especially if you look at it album to album. they've changed+evolved a ton over the years.

and Mebe, if you like those songs you should check out the song One.

mrtpitiesfools
My penis grew 5 feet since
I left Jane's board.

Posts: 126
(3/10/02 12:35:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Vanilla Ice should have been on their. If it wasn't for him, Fred Durst and all the other white boy rap/rockers would still be working at Arbys. hehe

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 64
(3/10/02 12:45:03 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
oasis? are you kidding me! they already have the beatles on there, why would they have a band who is no better than a beatles cover band on there? p.ink floyd definitely should've been higher...top 5, no doubt.

Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 58
(3/10/02 1:05:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
oasis is no more a beatles cover band than anyone else. don't be a fag.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 64
(3/10/02 1:49:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Awesome to see Buddy Holly and the Crickets on that list. P.ink Floyd were in their place, shouldn't be moved up any higher.
This is a minor complaint because that list was pretty durn good, but what about Sonic Youth or, more importantly, Chuck Berry? Chuck Berry is HUGE.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 83
(3/10/02 2:07:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
u2 is an enigma to me. i want to have their kind of popularity but i have absolutely zero interest in their kind of music.

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 382
(3/10/02 2:12:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
You gotta start saying Weezer is the best band in the world in interviews.

Not like a bitch, and say 'we will tour and be gay all over the world to be the biggest band in the world' like Bono does.

Like Noel and Liam Gallagher were doing. And start harassing FLIGHT ATTENDANTS and shit. Noel and Liam are the coolest people in the world because they're such assholes.

BE LIKE THEM. The beard is a good start.

Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 96
(3/10/02 2:14:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
But U2 popularity means like, social activism and tours in Bosnia. It took a goddamn long enough time to get you guys to come to Kalamazoo.

UserName
Registered User
Posts: 119
(3/10/02 2:18:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
you don't get much gayer than u2.

Smam
Registered User
Posts: 2
(3/10/02 2:21:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Kalamazoo show rocked

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 119
(3/10/02 2:23:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
a) Guns n' Roses should've been lower on that list.
b) where is Rush?

UserName
Registered User
Posts: 121
(3/10/02 2:25:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Rush is in Canada where they belong.

Shefik
^.^ shawny!! ¨_¨
Posts: 168
(3/10/02 2:26:59 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
"Noel and Liam are the coolest people in the world because they're such assholes." Personal heroes..?

I love the fact that everyone here has been mercilessly slandering U2 left and right, but no one's actually said what they hate about it. I challenge someone to say that they LOATHE The Joshua Tree.. and give a valid reason. And so help me, if someone says "gay"...

UserName
Registered User
Posts: 122
(3/10/02 2:28:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
I loathe The Joshua Tree, as well as any other gay2 album, because theyre fucking boring...and gay.

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 56
(3/10/02 2:33:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Kalamazoo= Fuckin amazing

Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 97
(3/10/02 3:45:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Yeah, definetly...Kalamazoo was sweet. It's sort of lame to live in though.

I just think U2 is too flat and boring. They never really 'rock' or anything, just play their thing. I like 'The Sweetest Thing' (assuming that is indeed what that song is called), though. And I mean, it's not all bad, but just in general, they shouldn't win 50 grammys every year like they do.

Hirose
Registered User
Posts: 77
(3/10/02 3:49:38 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
my argument for hating U2 is that they're gay.

now you give me a valid argument for liking U2.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 65
(3/10/02 4:17:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
My problem with U2? They're monotonous. "Where the Streets Have No Name," "With or Without You," and "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" could all be the same song as far as I know. In fact, when I was little, I thought they ::were:: the same song. Those songs are so similar to me, I had to go to allmusicguide.com to find out what they were called. "Sunday Bloody Sunday" is the only U2 song that stands out to me.

Shefik
^.^ shawny!! ¨_¨
Posts: 177
(3/10/02 6:39:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
I think the argument to call U2 too flat or monotonous isn't valid. You could easily say the same thing about the Green album, Return of the R.entals, O.zma's Rock and Roll Part Three, or anything by Pavement: if you don't like the style of one song, you're sure as heck not gonna like any of the other songs. Variations on a theme is a better way to think of it than "a bunch of the same song." Where the Streets Have No Name, Sunday Bloody Sunday, and In God's Country (along with the rest of The Joshua Tree) might sound similar, but if that's the kind of stuff you like, then who cares about a constant style of sound? I have a few friends who hound me all the time about Weezer's crunchy guitars. I like it.

Edited by: Shefik  at: 3/10/02 7:22:08 pm
UserName
Registered User
Posts: 131
(3/10/02 6:47:36 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Shefik...gayness.

Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE
Penis, please.

Posts: 219
(3/10/02 7:11:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
this is funny as hell:
www.theonion.com/onion380..._3808.html

scaldalupo
Registered User
Posts: 42
(3/10/02 7:17:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Just because those three songs from the same albums sound alike doesn't mean that all the other songs on their ten or so other albums sound just like them. That's like saying that since half of the Green Album all sounds the same then all Weezer songs must sound exactly like that.

Plus, Bono being an asshole has nothing to do with their music.

Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE
Penis, please.

Posts: 220
(3/10/02 7:20:18 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i don't think i could ever get into them, if only for bono's crap voice. i can't stand it.

mcnellis
Registered User
Posts: 39
(3/10/02 7:24:22 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
the feeding of the Somalis with the single loaf of bread is hilarious.

djstandby
Registered User
Posts: 1
(3/10/02 8:57:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
best list I've read in a while... anytime you can see captain beefheart getting some respect its nice

missing?: fugazi, blur, bjork, husker du, sonic youth

but of course in any list there must be bands left off

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 627
(3/10/02 9:47:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
yea i cant understand fugazi and sonic youth being left off while there are other bands of lesser importance/greatness on there

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 29
(3/10/02 9:50:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Fugazi and Sonic Youth were both mentioned in the discussions surrounding the creation of the list. And in fact were mentioned in a separate article that ran that day which was something to the effect of "Bands that were also considered" more or less.
Almost all of the bands that people have mentioned were included in that article.
Lists like this never can please everyone.

Oh, I just checked:
U2 is still gay.

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/10/02 9:51:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
i agree with queero. to be huge you have to have some mission. u2 has their save the world schtick, but being a complete asshole would do the trick for you. you can start by getting in an unprovoked fist fight with brian on stage.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 68
(3/10/02 9:54:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Well, those are my reasons for not liking U2. I've heard quite a bit of their material, two of my friends are obsessed with them and have made U2 sadly unavoidable to me. Perhaps to some the Green Album is monotonous, I can understand why people would say that. I happen to like Green, though.

I still say ol'Chuck Berry should have made the list, but it was a durn good list overall.

insertsomethingclever
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/10/02 9:55:19 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
I don't like U2 because I think they're boring. Although, I do like the song, "Sunday, Bloody Sunday."


To whomever said beastie boys should've been on the list: They were #30.


Plenty of good bands were left off the list, but I'm more surpirsed that weezer even made it to begin with...

Edited by: insertsomethingclever at: 3/10/02 10:39:34 pm
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 26
(3/10/02 10:07:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
the longer weezer sticks around, the more they'll start popping up on lists like that. and as of now, its all because of pinkerton.

every list will have something like this: "weezer made their debut with the refreshinly poppy blue album following the death of grunge, but it was their second album, pinkerton, that marked the bands greatest accomplishment and progress. however, the album was first plagued with widespread rejection by fans and critics alike, and commercial failure. cuomo hid away for 5 years while pinkerton garnered a cult following, and finally re-emerged with the green album, a fun album but a significant step back for the band"

ace better make another masterpiece or his legacy is pinkerton

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 31
(3/10/02 10:08:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Yes, Chuck Berry should've made the list, and when we do an "artists" lists he will certainly make the list, along with Bowie, Robert Johnson and scores of other 'artists.'
Chuck Berry wasn't a band.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 70
(3/10/02 10:18:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
I'm trying to think of the name of one of Chuck's backing bands and I can't, so you win. :]
Can't wait to see your Top 50 Artists list.

Not to nitpick or anything, but any specific reason why Sonic Youth didn't make the list? Just curious.

karlophone
**Champion of All Time**
Posts: 13
(3/10/02 10:19:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
re: chuck berry comments:
yeah, like most of these kind of lists its sorta whitey dominated. Very tough for these list compilers to toss in massive yet practically forgotten influences and "soul" acts besides hendrix and sly, if that means a few less white guy bands make the list. but you gotta remember whose making the list: college students, ages 18-23*. Of course they will be focusing on "rock: 1965-2000", because thats what they know best. Forgetting our roots is the american way, etc.

(this comment can also be applied to old school whitey influences, i.e. Carter Family, Hank Williams Sr. etc. who also get the shaft ...theres no such thing as the perfect list of course)

*im assuming, correct me if im wrong

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 71
(3/10/02 10:28:50 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Karl:
I agree with you, but I think that could easily be solved by a little more careful speculation. If I made a list of my top 50 bands, I think I'd have to put at least Smokey Robinson and the Miracles on there, too. But I think I'd have more black musicians on a Top 50 Musicians/Artists lists than on a Bands list.

As much as I like reading the lists, the idea of those lists bugs the hell out of me. Ranking things should be an archaic practice, IMO. Taste is too subjective.

A Preachers Son
Registered User
Posts: 32
(3/10/02 10:30:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
well, as karlophone did point out, we can only write for the most part what we know -- which is a large reason as to why we haven't done an artists list, and won't for quite some time, as the amount of research the list will take is completely mind numbing, there are obvious choices, Gaye, Dylan, Robert Johnson, Duke Ellington, Patti Labelle, I mean tons upon tons of Motown artists were neglected, and Jazz artists, like @#%$ Brubeck Quartet, Miles Davis, Dizzy, and pop acts, Nick Drake, David Bowie -- the artist's list is a giant undertaking, and one that will take forever to compile.

Sonic Youth didn't make the list. We decided not to put them on the list. I don't recall why. Tons of bands were left off that could've made the list, and tons are on the list that people disagree with.
If nothing else, they are interesting conversation pieces.

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 118
(3/10/02 10:38:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
oh yeah, beastie boys are on there, cool.

Sonic Youth is a great band, they almost go hand in hand with pavement for me. Some newer bands that could be mentioned if it is your taste, the smashing pumpkins and beck.

insertsomethingclever
Registered User
Posts: 8
(3/10/02 10:38:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Why is N.W.A. on the list? Is it more because of the music itself, or because of the big influence it had on people, or something else?

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 72
(3/10/02 10:40:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Definitely an interesting topic for conversation. I find the conversations generally more engaging than the list themselves, but that's no flaw of the listmakers [generally]. Certainly not in your case.

Yeah, I was just nitpicking over Sonic Youth.

I definitely agree with you that a Top Artists list is going to much harder to compile. I tried countless times to create one a few years ago, to no avail. I kept changing it every day, I couldn't make up my mind. I love music too much to narrow things down that specifically, I suppose. I'm lame.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 78
(3/10/02 11:06:23 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
Speaking of the Onion and the greatest band of all time, look at my horoscope for this week:

Libra: (Sept. 23?Oct. 23)
Though you never intended to do so, you will soon trade your dignity for the guitar tablature to several Creed songs.

Hell yeah! Creed fucking rocks!

insertsomethingclever
Registered User
Posts: 9
(3/10/02 11:08:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
(This message was left blank)

Edited by: insertsomethingclever at: 3/12/02 7:36:34 pm
YeahYeah
Registered User
Posts: 16
(3/12/02 3:11:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
almost seems like its easier to make 50 of the worst bands of all time list...(there might be LESS disagreement...)...

i must say aside from the music... i like that for the past 20 some odd years that u2 has been around- they have been friends..maybe that has something to do with their success too- because they stuck together...does anyone have any opinions on friendship within a band and its importance to the band as well as the music?

this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 159
(3/12/02 3:20:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
no, i don't care how often u2 fuck each other in the arse....... or the gay music they make about it

Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 42
(3/12/02 6:55:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
it is important I'd agree. I think their friendship and cohesiveness plays a big role in u2 being the best live show in the world and making the songs they do. the only band that compares with u2 live is radiohead, who I'm sure are friends and have gone through a lot of shit together as well.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 82
(3/13/02 9:40:57 am)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
People need to stop talking about U2. Now. It's not even funny anymore.

the amazing jelloman
Registered User
Posts: 6
(3/13/02 6:05:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
42 bands better than the fucking Doors? This list is bullshit.

Me Be Beatleweez fan
FEMALE
Penis, please.
So nieve.

Posts: 277
(3/13/02 7:24:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Weezer 44th greatest band of all time
the doors werent all that extraordinary either. they were pretty interesting and sorta innovative, and theyre actually one of my fav bands to listen to, but they dont belong at the top of any "greatest bands" list, imo.

Page 1 2 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index