|
Author
|
Comment
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 698
(3/14/02 8:25:21 am)
Reply
|
victory (VVV)
for some reason i would rather sing along to
"goddamn get your head outta your hand
here's to all the times we're gonna have
cooped up for a year with two best looking babes i've seen all year"
than
"I can't say....
.....That you love me.....
...So I cry........
....And I'm hurting..."
I
L
O
V
E
Y
O
U
Edited by: asschun at: 3/14/02 8:30:42 am
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 699
(3/14/02 8:29:23 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i would rather listen to just the music of blast off
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 700
(3/14/02 8:30:17 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i would rather make superficial cuts into my legs
o.O
|
SkyBlue523202
VIRGIN MODERATOR
Posts: 79
(3/14/02 8:40:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
asschun yet again makes a genius point!
Keep it UP
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 116
(3/14/02 10:03:07 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
hey, no argument here. blast off is one of the greatest melodies ANYONE'S ever written. pure billy joel.
|
RadicalRich1138
Registered User
Posts: 4
(3/14/02 10:09:01 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
you're right it is great, we going to hear it in a set soon?
|
BloodinthestreetS
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/14/02 10:44:39 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
haha....set
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 89
(3/14/02 10:49:21 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
Billy Joel wishes he could write a song like Blast Off.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 85
(3/14/02 11:15:04 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
(from other thread) "I Do" is "Leningrad," i think.
|
jimboner
Registered User
Posts: 52
(3/14/02 11:26:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
D&D cannot even be compared to Blast Off!, seeing as 90% of the time old weezer is a good deal beter than new weezer. This is no exception. ace: sarcasm?
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 435
(3/14/02 12:18:19 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
billy joel is genius
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 703
(3/14/02 1:23:11 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i cannot stand most of the new melodies
i love blast off...the music goes well...the vocals are kickass of course...i want more sftbh
|
TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 41
(3/14/02 2:12:27 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
since blast off is genius...doesnt that merit a proper studio recording and cd release. and it would be awesome live.
|
DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 149
(3/14/02 2:40:05 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
wasnt blast off made as a full band recording in the studio, sans mastering and tinkering?
|
BPrend
Registered User
Posts: 21
(3/14/02 3:20:35 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i doubt that they will rerecord it; and if they do, they'll probably change it and it wont be as good
|
zilched
Registered User
Posts: 45
(3/14/02 3:22:34 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
Blast Off is easily one of teh best Weezer songs. But I don't get what's so bad about DnD.
It's all opinion I suppose.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 171
(3/14/02 8:41:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
"(from other thread) "I Do" is "Leningrad," i think."
...this is true people. Probably pure coincidence, but it's almost exactly the same...in one part anyway. It's right at the beginning, during the piano intro I believe.
|
joescho84
Registered User
Posts: 2
(3/14/02 9:34:09 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
sets seem tobe just that... set. very little room for modifying unless weezer's willing to play a 25 song "set but not entirely set"
- joe
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 121
(3/14/02 9:35:07 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
BO is a better melody. D+D is a better song.
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 166
(3/14/02 9:37:16 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
you again, beeotch?
|
ichigo
FEMALE o_O
Posts: 60
(3/14/02 9:38:55 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
"i would rather make superficial cuts into my legs
o.O"
o.O you so crazy.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 94
(3/14/02 9:48:56 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
is that how you feel about other pre-green songs too? good melodys but not good songs?
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 713
(3/14/02 9:59:06 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i hate everything about D&D's music now
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 172
(3/14/02 10:02:41 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
HOW is "D & D" a better 'song?'
And isn't a good melody a large percentage of what makes a good song a good song anyway? I can see how a horrendously bad song structure might destroy a good idea no matter how solid the melody, but with something like "Blast Off"(or anything else from '92-'96 era) that's simply not the case. Yeah, the structure to "Blast Off" is not as concise and to-the-point as it maybe could be, but does it NEED to be in order to qualify as a viable piece of music?
EDIT: What's better/worse...a great melody with a bad song structure, or a so-so melody with a sensible structure? By Ace's standard, it would seem to be the latter...maybe I am reading him wrong though, I don't know. As far as bad structures are concerned, it IS subjective. But a bad structure is usually an ambitous one nonetheless(though not always of course), and I think an awesome melody with a bad(but ambitous) structure would be far better then a bad melody with a so-called 'perfect structure.'
Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 3/14/02 10:17:11 pm
|
TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/14/02 10:47:02 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
Why is it that everyone heralds weezer's new stuff for about 2 days and then all the sudden it sucks? Or they hate it until newer stuff comes out. Has D&D not improved?
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 186
(3/14/02 10:49:21 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
actually, tooloud, the debate with ace is usually about whether or not the new stuff can compete with the old
your perception is off anyway
|
TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/14/02 10:51:36 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
actually, niblet, i was commenting in general.
|
Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 80
(3/14/02 11:29:48 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
Ace, do you give up on a melody if you're dissatisfied with the lyrics and instrumentation? If the melody is great, then revamp it.
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 716
(3/14/02 11:35:00 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
ohoho
|
flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 2
(3/14/02 11:49:56 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
she's always a woman is a damn good tune. and at least he's twice as good as elton john.
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 717
(3/14/02 11:51:43 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
"i cant believe how bad i suck it's true"
do i need to go on?
|
flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/14/02 11:56:15 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i hear nothing great in D&D. over-reverbed vocals if anything. slob is the best song on the promo.
|
SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 51
(3/14/02 11:59:05 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
I dunno, there is something about the version of slob on the promo that sounds overproduced. I liked the demo alot better. The vocals just sound better on it and the whole song flows better, but hey maybe its just me and everyone loves it. whatever its still an awesome song
|
SkyBlue523202
VIRGIN MODERATOR
Posts: 87
(3/15/02 12:08:06 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
The first versions of a lot of maladroit's tracks sound better than the polished. But hey- shouldn't we give Rivers credit for taking so much time to work on making so many songs sound so much worse? (That's a lot of "so's" and a lot of TIME.)
p.s.- my last comment was more of a statment than a bitch about the new album.
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 190
(3/15/02 12:11:23 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i don't understand. how is that supposed to be interpreted if not as negativity toward the final mixes?
|
flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 5
(3/15/02 12:13:48 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
the sheer power of slob's chorus is an achievement. the demo didn't have that.
|
SkyBlue523202
VIRGIN MODERATOR
Posts: 89
(3/15/02 12:22:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
I meant that it takes a lot of work to ruin songs.
I give Ace credit for achieving such a feat.
this niblet... just don't take anything I say seriously and you will never be bothered by my posts.
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 191
(3/15/02 12:25:04 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
i don't take anything at all seriously
and i wasn't bothered
i was just trying to understand. even though you may think so, i have no personal vendetta or anything.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 175
(3/15/02 1:20:05 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
Whether Maladroit songs got better or worse over time(post mixing/mastering) is not really the issue...it's about the songs themselves. Despite slight changes in vocal approaches, drums sounds, etc...the core of the song is always intact. It's either generally pleasing, or somewhat unsatisfying regardless of how it's been recorded. Little things added or subtracted during the mixing process CAN help or hurt the song, but rarely do they change a person's general opinion of the song OVERALL.
The debate here is what makes "D & D" a superior 'song' to "Blast Off." If Ace would have compared it to something like "Fall Together" or even "Take Control" I would be far more inclined to agree with him. But "D & D" is barely a song(as fantastic as it is at the core). It only has two real parts, and they're both based on nearly the same chords in the same key, and the structure of the song as a whole is kinda' brief and less then 'perfect'...there was a whole thread dedicated to this a while back so I won't go too into the structure issues I have with this song. But basically, like I've stated before, the verse only happens once, and the chorus only twice(and the chorus is SHORT) = proper songwriting no no's. Yet Ace deems it a better SONG then "Blast Off" and presumabely any other song from Blue/Pinkerton/SFTBH era...based on what criteria exactly?!
I realise he is entitled to his opinion of his work and I 100% respect that...but he makes these arguements like they're actually justified by some fabricated pop song rule book, which even if it did exist, "D & D" would not fit the criteria of a well written song...which is my point. When I say there are problems with "D & D" it's in complete accordance with what Ace has preached for so long concerning proper songwriting formulas. It's too bad he doesn't always elaborate on his arguments about his songs, because his argument that "D & D" is somehow more of a SONG then "Blast Off" is completely throwing me off.
|
Dolemite
Registered User
Posts: 45
(3/15/02 2:10:43 am)
Reply
|
Well done.
But maybe Ase wuz just bullshittin, man.
|
Slim Mackeral
silm pensi *lolz*
Posts: 184
(3/15/02 2:13:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: Well done.
Lonely surfer, will you write a paper for me on the influence of latin music??? $$$
|
asschun
STILL admin STILL kill teh gayz
Posts: 721
(3/15/02 7:14:55 am)
Reply
|
Re: Well done.
TLS you still have not msged me concerning my paper
i will give you 24 more hours
|
starby
Registered User
Posts: 8
(3/15/02 10:56:55 am)
Reply
|
shit
slob sucks, d&d is ok, blast off kicks my ass, but longtime sunshine rocks my world. talk about a perfect mealody and amazing lyrics. mmm. and if blast off is one of the best mealodies EVER then why isn't the new stuff full of such perfection? dammit.
|
flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 9
(3/15/02 11:09:18 am)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
right on. longtime is better than almost all =w= songs i've heard. blastoff is great. D&D simply can't live up.
if there is a problem with the post-haitus music, it isn't in the songwriting- although i could stand to see some more complexity; it is all in the over-production in performance.
|
Dolemite
Registered User
Posts: 47
(3/15/02 11:34:02 am)
Reply
|
Lonely Serfer
You could make a lot of cash whoring out term paper tricks for a pimp like myself.
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 195
(3/15/02 11:42:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
it is in the songwriting too..... completely different approach
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 178
(3/15/02 6:21:08 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
You guys are kidding yourselves...it's ALL in the songwriting. Besides, the production isn't THAT slick on Green and Maladroit anyway...and even if it was that slick, I don't think it degrades the listening experience as much as you seem to think it does. You just think it's 'indie cool' to say that you prefer less polished, lo-fi recordings.
I totally admit that TLA is 'polishing' weezer's sound to a level of incredible genericness...but songs are songs and it's not all that bothersome. So they sound properly recorded, is that such a big deal?
It just so happens that Pinkerton and Blue had kickass songs along with a less smooth production job(that's the sound they were going for back then), so you associate sloppy production with good songs, even though that hardly had EVERYTHING to do with why the songs were good(not that it hurt). My point being though, that if "Tired of Sex" had Maladroit/Green production, it would still be fucking cool.
EDIT: Asschun, you're never online...not as djfunkxxx anyway.
Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 3/15/02 6:37:55 pm
|
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 207
(3/15/02 6:31:34 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
i think that many of the new songs would benefit greatly, maybe not as much from different production, but from different arrangements and stuff like that. maladroit much more so than green. how the song is treated makes a big difference, take any good cover song as an example. I agree though that just the mixing doesn't make or break anything.
remember your thread about d&d?
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 134
(3/15/02 6:35:47 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
hey wow you guys still don't know what a good song is
|
BPrend
Registered User
Posts: 29
(3/15/02 6:41:10 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
we pretty much all agree on what is a good song, youre the one who is "different".
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 179
(3/15/02 6:44:31 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"hey wow you guys still don't know what a good song is"
...well, you ARE the supreme judge of what makes a good song good.
BTW, I like Green and Maladroit songs...however, not quite to the degree that I like Blue/Pinkerton(and B-Sides)...that's not a crime. I don't discredit the new Ace songwriting approach. It's just not as unique as the old approach.
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 135
(3/15/02 6:53:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
uniqueness is for amateurs
|
BPrend
Registered User
Posts: 30
(3/15/02 6:57:16 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
in some ways, uniqueness is for amateurs but most of the time, its not. although you only care for creep, kid a and amnesiac are both unique yet radiohead are not amateurs. much of u2's stuff is unique, but theyre not amateurs either.
|
EddieAdams
Registered User
Posts: 33
(3/15/02 7:00:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
for amateurs because professionals like there profession so they begin to make music for the masses, rather than for themselves.
|
kyle vh2
YES.
Posts: 131
(3/15/02 7:01:03 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I'm talking on AIM to the kid you made cry by calling him a faggot...
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 87
(3/15/02 7:01:43 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Screw Uniqueness, I just want some brilliant songs.
-
|
scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 4
(3/15/02 7:01:59 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
There is no sense arguing. What ace thinks is great we think sucks and what ace thinks sucks we think is brilliant. We just have to hope that one day he will lose it and start writing "sucky" songs.
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 183
(3/15/02 7:03:25 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
haha. holy fuck.
post in the AIM section
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 88
(3/15/02 7:07:55 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Scratchy,
I don't want Rivers to go back to writing "sucky" (yes I saw the quotes) songs... I want him to write what he wants to write. But what I do hope is that what he wants to write starts to head backward towards at least the type of songs he wrote for s2k.
I would never, nor could I ask another song writer to write stuff that he doesn't want to just to please someone else. Song writing is about yourself, and nobody else... for the most part.
-
|
scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 5
(3/15/02 7:53:01 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Radius I know what you're saying and I agree but I think you know what I meant.
|
GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 55
(3/15/02 8:18:39 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Yes, I like the new stuff (and i love the old stuff too). Just as songs, I think they sound better, and will sound better- because the whole band is contributing- they're rocking, they want to rock, and they want to keep on rocking.
|
weezergurl15
Registered User
Posts: 28
(3/15/02 9:13:31 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
You can have great lyrics and a really sucky melody, and the song will most likely bomb, but if the melody's good yet the lyrics aren't the best in the world then it's probably gonna fly. On the topic of Billy Joel, yes he is genius. Maybe it's something about just a guy and a piano that makes lots of music great. (longtime sunshine)
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 180
(3/15/02 9:41:15 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"uniqueness is for amateurs"
...haha...that is a very good comeback, and I actually agree with that to an extent(I know plenty of 'unique' local bands that would fit that to a 't'). It's also a broad generalization though, and implies that ANYTHING unique must be amature work. Unless that actually is what you think?
I am still of the opinion that amature work doesn't sell gold, platinum, or multi-platinum...and amature work doesn't get someone a major label record deal. So based on that premise, it's hard to go along with any arguments that Blue and Pinkerton are outright amature efforts. I view 93-'96 weezer as a VERY professional sounding band with the perfect dose of uniqueness...and it's not like the songs were solely based on creating some unique sound(far from it actually), the unique aspects seemed to be more or less thrown in for good measure, and though the actual 'uniqueness' was fairly subtle, it was enough to create extreme interest. It was a combination of the lyrics, fairly interesting song structures(far from gratuitous though), and 'real' band energy. Those three distinctly '=w=' elements are absent now, and that's why alot of old weezer fans are not as fond of the new material as you might hope they would be.
When you think about it logically...why would someone continue liking a band that approaches their music 180 degrees the opposite of the way they used to when they first got into them? There were qualities in the music that made them love weezer...if those qualities are no longer intact, what would possibly keep them hanging on?...it's like a different band. You made a conscious effort to completely re-evaluate your songwriting methods, and this is the reaction for doing so...it has to be expected, right?
Back when Blue first came out, did anybody else ever think to themselves, "why the hell do I like this band so much?...they basically sound no different then any other guitar driven punky/poppy/whatever band...but yet I am hella' into it for some reason." Then you thought about the lyrics, the perfect song structures(which apparantly weren't so perfect afterall), the vocal delivery, the killer guitar sounds, and everything else I've already mentioned. I remember thinking too, "if it wasn't for those little things, there wouldn't be much to weezer at all and I'd probably view them the same way I view any other band." Those things were very important.
In conclusion(haha)...new weezer songs ARE good, no doubt about it. But it's like listening to American Hi-Fi or something..."Flavor of the Week"(how appropriate)...when you listen to it, you're like 'yeah it's catchy, yeah it's a well written song, but SO WHAT?!...who the hell cares about this stupid band anyway, they won't matter once the flavor gets old." There's just nothing about it that creates interest, and nothing there to reel in any sort of long term fan base. If weezer's career had started with the Green Album, they would easily have the same status in my mind, and I'm not afraid to admit that. If Rivers doesn't mind being that sort of band though, then that's totally up to him. So it's not that the new songs suck...they ARE well written tunes with plenty of 'instant' appeal...but they simply won't matter outside the current fixture of poppy '00 guitar bands that pay homage to 80's hair metal...=w= is no different then the rest. Maybe that doesn't bother Ace...who knows...but it seems pretty obvious why it would bother older fans of the band. There shouldn't be any surprise.
|
MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 94
(3/15/02 9:46:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
The Lonely Surfer's Forthcoming book: "The Lonely Rock and Roll Life" will be published by Martin Books and available through your neighborhood bookstore May 14.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 181
(3/15/02 9:53:47 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
You forgot to mention...I'll be signing autographs and conducting a 'meet and greet' at the Barnes and Noble in downtown Manhattan the day it hits the shelves. Gotta' plug...
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 445
(3/15/02 11:23:58 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Excellent post surfer. However, I disagree that Green & Maladroit could be put in the same category as some of the other stuff that's out there today. To me the music has a whole lot more to offer than for example American Hi-Fi/Sum 41 and other such popular music. D&D, Dope Nose, Slob, Keep Fishin', Take Control, the majority of the Maladroit songs - while indeed catchy and well written like you said, in my opinion are more than just a trendy kind of 'flavor of the week'. They are in a catagory of their own that I believe can and will stand the test of time as Blue and Pinkerton have when looked back on in a few years. Also, I believe they can indeed be referred to as being 'unique' when compared to current musical trends.
I would go so far to sat that TGA and possibly Maladroit will be looked back upon as being important and monumental albums - just like how (in our eyes anyway) Blue and Pinkerton are. Crazy, huh?
|
JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 84
(3/15/02 11:34:27 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I think they way we (and the band) view Maladroit is going to be highly based on how it does commercially, despite the fact that all of us would rather not think so.
|
ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 446
(3/16/02 12:07:45 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Please clarify, JohnnyNo5. Are you saying that our opinion of Maladroit will be effected by how well it sells?
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 13
(3/16/02 1:12:23 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
yes, excellent post TLS> you have a good way of saying perfectly what alot of us are thinking.
i think.
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 89
(3/16/02 1:16:19 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Surfer,
I'd buy your book. Mostly cause you and I agree on just about everything.
-
|
sch2383
Registered User
Posts: 40
(3/16/02 1:48:19 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I don't know about the rest of you, but what makes =w= special for me is the lyrics. Not so much in the Green Album, but in Blue and Pinkerton. Those newer bands that were mentionedcan play their instraments and they their songs are polished to sound nice, but their lyrics don't hold the same meaning to me that =w= does. Maybe its because when I started to get seriously into =w= was when I was going through a wierd time in my life, when everything seemed to be upside down. I don't know for sure, but ace can write one hell of a song.
I am drunk, so if I say anything stupid/gay please ignore it.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 115
(3/16/02 1:55:43 am)
Reply
|
. . .
Agreed, excellent post, Surfer.
Although my opinion falls somewhere between yours and Ridd's.
Maladroit is a much more monumental album than TGA, to me. I happen to really like Green, but Maladroit has more to offer. We all know that. As universally approachable and as generally well-received as Green was, I think Maladroit has more "up front" value: it goes beyond pop appeal to bring back authentic 80s metal flavor [which, um, you guys already said] and the realism in the songs shows. You'd have to really not be listening to the songs or fall into that marginal [hopefully?] grouping of music "listeners" who only enjoys a specific type of pop to not embrace Maladroit. Upon Maladroit's official release, I predict that Green will be referred to as only as the previous Weezer album, but for the most part, will be momentarily forgotten as the world beyond the hardcore Weezer fanbase hears Maladroit. My thought is that the more intelligent general public will be blown away...and the masses will embrace the album for its energy and obvious skill.
Everyone knows Rivers Cuomo is a fantastic songwriter. Maladroit will give the world a taste at just how masterful he is at crafting pop-minded songs while controlling the album production and giving Pat, Brian, and Scott a chance to really show off their chops. That is what people generally want: perfectly crafted pop-oriented songs. That's what sells.
Pinkerton may have been Rivers' opera, but Maladroit shows his finesse as a conductor.
I have no doubt that many of you will disagree with me on this. Hell, when I read back on this later, I might even disagree with some of what I wrote [a problem with writing when drunk, for sure.]
Oh, well.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 182
(3/16/02 1:56:38 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"To me the music has a whole lot more to offer than for example American Hi-Fi/Sum 41 and other such popular music."
...what more does it offer exactly? I'm not trying to be stubborn, but I just feel that in being completely honest with myself, I have to admit that the new weezer material(with a few exceptions) really is no more special than anything by American Hi-Fi or Sum 41. I TRY to look for things that make it better then those other bands, but I can't find anything. Lyrically, I'd say your average Sum 41 song is far easier to relate to on a personal level(as pathetic as that is) and most of the songs are actually about something. Musically, Sum 41 is surprisingly quite impressive too!...kick ass riffage, solid drumming, lots and lots of energy...neato guitar work as well!...there's even some =vh= tapping in there, and some kickass two-part harmonized solos...wow. Sum 41 is totally winning this contest. Then last but not least, there's the song structures...waaaay more interesting then any given Maladroit or Green song. Hell, Blink 182 would even beat =w= in that category.
I think there are already so many bands that are 20 times better at doing what Rivers wants to do with his band. And why would Rivers pick now to start writing no-nonsense, metal riff-based music with meaningless lyrics anyway? Isn't that what you do when you're a teenager first startin' out in your garage with your friends?...not when you enter your 30's and you're 10 years into your professional music career. At least Sum 41 is young and exuberant, and it makes perfect sense for them to be doing that type of thing. Plus they pull it off really well, somehow. At any rate, Sum 41 still won't exist in 5 years, and if they do no one will be buying their albums. So...
Weezer aren't EXACTLY like Sum 41 or American Hi-Fi of course. But I feel they're basically doing their own version of the same type of thing now, only not as well...I doubt that it's conscious of course. I know Rivers has fun playing these new songs, and that's cool, but if that's the case why wasn't he writing this kind of material from the very beginning? Did he not want to write songs that were fun to play back then?...if so, why would that be?...especially if there was the possibility of him getting bored of the songs years later. Once you release a major label album and you have millions of fans that love those songs, you should probably come to terms with the fact that you're gonna' be playing most of them for the rest of your career, whether you like it or not.
I don't think it's too far fetched to say that Rivers kinda' changes with the wind, as far as stylistic motives are concerned. Blue and Pinkerton were more in the Pixies/Nirvana vein, 'cause that's what was big at the time. And now, Nu-Metal and punk bands that have fun with old metal are the big thing...so Rivers is jumping on that bandwagon. It's very convenient for him too, since he was already a metal head in his formative years and had probably been dying to actually write, release and perform songs like "Fall Together" and "Hash Pipe" for years, but could never do it 'cause there was no market for it. He probably never REALLY wanted to do the Pixie-oriented sound to begin with, and now that people aren't really into that anymore he can pursue his built-up metal tendencies without sacrificing his career. No wonder he's such a happy guy now!
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 183
(3/16/02 2:09:24 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
wow...lot's of intoxication tonight.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 117
(3/16/02 2:11:19 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
meh. drunk or not i stand by my post.
EDIT:
Okay. I'm sober now.
I don't really know enough about Sum 41 or Blink 182 or American Hi-Fi to get as deep into this as you, TLS, but I have a very hard time believing that any of those bands [especially Blink 182 with their sophomoric lyrics] actually care about the music and put as much thought into each note that they play as much as Rivers does. I'm sure they're committed musicians, but in none of the Sum 41, Blink 182, and American Hi-Fi songs I've heard do I detect much serious, devoted thought to the songs in general.
Rivers devotes more attention to structure, melody, the all around musicianship of the band, and song production than any of those three bands, and his adeptness at guitar playing is masterful. Part of that is owed to his subtlety; even when Rivers "rawks out" on stage in a solo, his poses come off [to me, anyway] as relatively modest. Rivers has power over his instrument, and he exhibits that by making his notes graceful. Most other guitarists with skill even close to his would break into frenzied, fret-climbing solos designed to show off their adroitness, but Rivers seems to realize that the song as a whole is more important than his skill at soloing. In that manner, he brings to mind a sort of modern George Harrison. George's solos were effing amazing, and a big part of that was his ability to give the song what it needed. Now, Rivers' solos are much more conspicuous than George Harrison's solos, especially in the early Beatles material, but like George, Rivers knows to keep the solos from overpowering the songs. IMO, that's a huge quality of musicianship. Rivers own the solos, he owns the songs, and IMO, he owns the whole fucking power-pop/pop-rock/whatever the fuck you wanna call it market.
Edited by: artfuse at: 3/16/02 1:08:28 pm
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 90
(3/16/02 2:53:31 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I'm completely sober.
However, i'm going to have to take back my previous statement about me agreeing with everything Surfer says.
I personally think that although Weezer's songs are simple, the main thing that elevates these guys from all those other Sum 41 and Blink 182 pop/punk bands is pure musicianship. All 4 of the weezers are incredibly good at what they do. And I'd have to say that Rivers is an exceptional guitarist. People go all out and about how Mark Tremonti is such a good guitar player, but personally I don't see it. I think he's seriously really shitty. As for Rivers, the songs might be incredibly easy, but if you listen, and I mean really listen to the way he plays his guitar, whether on solos, rock outs or anything of that nature, is purely amazing. Every note that Rivers plays has a personality of it's own. I personally think he's one of the greatest guitar players out there right now. But people don't really give him much of a chance. These Sum 182 and Blink 41 bands don't offer anything in this area. They aren't good musicians at all, they can barely play, and their live shows are something you might expect to see at a zoo.
And bringing more of my personal definition of musicianship into the picture, Rivers still is the top of my list. My personal definition includes basic attitude of playing. The tops of my list of those who have incredibly high musicianship is Rivers, Kurt Cobain, and Billy Corgan. Their attitude towards music and playing is a really mature and very flamboyant (in a non gay way). I don't know if I really explain it, but when any of those guys get up on stage, you can just sit there and stare at them and be totally mezmarized. I remember once I was just killing time before I had to go take a midterm, so I threw in Nirvana's Unplugged video. Next thing I realized I snapped out of a trance and turned out I was 20 minutes late for the midterm and I didn't even realize. That's musicianship as best as I can personally define it. And none of those Blum 81 and Sink 142 bands have it.
-
Edited by: RadiusMan at: 3/16/02 2:56:54 am
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 184
(3/16/02 4:28:45 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
See, I'm sort of on the other side saying "you know, these shitty teenage punk rock acts like Sum 41 actually know what the hell they're doing, even though nobody wants to admit it!" The Sum 41 kids KNOW how to play their guitars exceptionally well...in fact, much better then any of the artists you just mentioned. Especially Kurt Cobain...same with Billy Corgan. I'd say those are probably two of the very worst guitarists of the 90's! Those guys were songwriters, and they openly admit to not even knowing(or caring) about guitar 'technique' on any level. The guitar was simply a tool for writing songs.
However, I do completely agree that Rivers is one of the best, most underrated guitarists around right now...I've always thought that...but he rarely makes use of his full potential. Even if he did I'm saying, that aside, there's really not a whole lot more in Maladroit or Green that I can't find elsewhere in any other poppy guitar bands of today...even in the musicianship department(Sum 41 is easily right up there with Mala, but I explained that already). Have you actually listened to an entire Sum 41 album?...they've got their shit together.
With Blue and Pinkerton, weezer defined their own unique genre of music that no one else could touch because they did it 'their way.' Now though, they're just doing it essentially the same way that everybody else does it...big chunky riffs with a metal edge, funky flying V's and Explorer guitars, songs about hash, gigolos, prostitutes, or nothing at all...you know what I mean. There's just something very juvenile about their so-called development as a band, at a point when it seems like they should sort of be going the other direction. You could easily reverse the order of their albums and it would make so much more sense. These newer songs don't demand the =w= 'respect' that songs like "Say It Ain't So" used to. If people didn't take weezer as serious as Rivers was hoping they would back then, they really aren't gonna' take them serious now. Normally, comparing weezer with a band like Sum 41 would be laughable, but these days it seems very realistic. Face it, =weezer= is very basic guitar pop now, and nothing more. They always were basic guitar pop, but Rivers used to reward the listener by always adding an intelligent twist to the standard formula(lyrically and musically). That was the charm...
I still listen to new weezer songs and go "yeah, Rivers definitely hasn't lost his ability to write a solid melody." But my feelings about the songs don't seem to go much further then that, for whatever reason. Probably 'cause the songs weren't written to make you think. That's Rivers' intent...that CAN be a good thing too. It's just hard to accept that it's a good thing for weezer when you loved the band for the exact opposite reason; the fact that the music DID make you think. That's the whole basis of what makes =w= no different then any other band around right now. The songs may be well written, but beyond that they just go in one ear, and right out the next...
|
milk denial
Registered User
Posts: 8
(3/16/02 4:58:39 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Ace....The Who
|
milk denial
Registered User
Posts: 9
(3/16/02 5:02:34 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
paragraphs suck
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 136
(3/16/02 5:56:12 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
surfer, you obviously have no idea what a good song is. best restrain yourself in the presence of the master.
|
kyle vh2
YES.
Posts: 133
(3/16/02 8:12:14 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I don't like Say It Aint' So
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 445
(3/16/02 9:13:26 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I wonder, does Ace make me laugh out loud with almost all his posts because he's Ace, or because he's really much better than all of you? Yes.
I don't really wonder, so don't answer the question. I KNOW.
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 14
(3/16/02 10:27:32 am)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
[edit] just stating the obvious...
Edited by: jackkoho at: 3/16/02 10:29:16 am
|
GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 61
(3/16/02 12:52:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
>' Now though, they're just doing it essentially the same way >that everybody else does it...
no, they're not. i dont' know of any other band that let fans have some input on the way the finished product sounds.
they kick so much other current bands' asses it's not funny.
and you must have a simple mind. because the new stuff makes me think. there are feelings there.
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/16/02 1:03:48 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"the new stuff makes me think. there are feelings there. "
this statement is laughable at best.
Okay, okay, maybe "O Girlfriend" *did* make you think of your girlfriend.
gimme a freakin break.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 119
(3/16/02 1:35:12 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
While the lyrics of Green and Maladroit don't really make me think, some of the songs do have emotional aspects to them. I think Ridd has said it before, that the end of "Simple Pages" is one of the best parts of Green, and Rivers' voice on that part of the song isn't too far off emotionally from Blue or Pinkerton.
True, there really isn't much depth in the lyrics on Maladroit [or Green, for that matter] but it also really shouldn't matter. The lyrics are obviously not the focus of the album, and IMO, it shouldn't be all that big a deal. The music kicks, and based on what Rivers has sort of been saying, V will have 'improved' lyrics.
|
GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 62
(3/16/02 1:38:52 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
you can get alot of thought from simple things
to each his own
|
asirem
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/16/02 1:40:54 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Artfuse, do you see a similarity in the end of Simple Pages and Slave? It seems to me they both have similar "emotion" or "style" that gives them the same effect.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 120
(3/16/02 2:26:47 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Gumby Tom: I agree with you; simplicity does not negate the possibility of thought. Generally, I prefer simple lyrics to intentionally deep or emotional ones; I have a tendency to find such slaved-over intellectualism/"meaningful" lyrics contrived. As far as honesty in songwriting goes, simple is better, IMO.
Asirem: Yes, I do think that Simple Pages and Slave have similar qualites or attributes to them.
Edited by: artfuse at: 3/16/02 2:47:33 pm
|
dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 48
(3/16/02 3:18:21 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
How is a good song to stand out then, if all uniqueness is taken from it? The subject matter doesn't have to be unique to be good, that's obvious enough, but there has to be a 'something' about a song to make it stand out among other songs.
I think it has to have a good balance of uniqueness and conformity. Weezer has done that in a lot of their new stuff.
Wilson
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 185
(3/16/02 4:07:27 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"surfer, you obviously have no idea what a good song is. best restrain yourself in the presence of the master."
...that's very entertaining...my apologies.
What's your favorite Oasis song?
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 91
(3/16/02 4:16:26 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Surfer,
Now, I'm really starting to disagree with you. The fact that you can compare any pop/punk band to weezer is really outragious. Now, you are entitled to your opinion of course, and I've said before, I usually end up agreeing with you. But in this case, I happen to feel that you are extremly far fetched with your allogations. I'll give you the fact that Kurt Cobain was an incredibly sloppy guitar player. Maybe he wasn't the best example of the primary example of musicianship. However, he was the prime example in my PERSONAL definition of the word. As for Billy Corgan, you are starting to make me feel like you actually never listened to a whole pumpkins album. I mean Billy is a really great player. And you can't tell me that James Iha isn't amazing.
As for Rivers and his guitar playing: I think it's good that he doesn't take the full potential in his playing. That way we can be constantly shocked at the stuff that he plays. Would you rather he be like Mark Tremonti and play to his potential at every show and on every album just that everyone knows exactly what he can do as a guitar player (which in tremonti's case isn't much)? What people need to realize about guitar playing that it's not WHAT you can play on the guitar that makes you a good guitarist, it's now you make the guitar sound. This is what made hendrix so great. He could make that guitar sound like no other. You watch/listen to him play and you think "what did he do to make his guitar sound like that?". I get this all the time with Rivers, Billy Corgan and James Iha. I mean, Miles Davis couldn't hit extremely high notes like Maynard Furguson can, but you know what? As a trumpet player, I looked at Miles Davis and I said "How do you get a trumpet to sound like that?". It's all in how you can make the instrument sound, than what you can play. Fast playing means nothing, it's how well you can get the slow easy stuff to sound. And to tie it back into the present matter in hand, these punk/pop fucks might be able to play their fender/gibson guitars through a marshal to get the fender/gibson/marshal sound. But, they can't make you say "How do they do that?" as on their albums, it's quite apparent "how they did that" cause they aren't very good.
Then with songwriting: None of those bands can write a song for the life of them. I've listened to many artists and I can safely say that with melody, Rivers is royalty. He may not be the king, or the prince, but he's definitely sleeping in the castle (maybe he's a modern duke... sorry couldnt resist). There aren't many that i've heard that can write melody like Rivers... the only other that springs directly in to mind is Billy Joel, who as you've noticed is a name that has been creeping in a lot in these forums as of late. Both of their melodies are truly amazing.
I will give you that in many instances (far from them all though) Rivers song writing has started to the more "standard" forumula. But you have to remember that back in 1994 all the blue album was also just the standard formula. Many of the bands from that era's songs didn't stand up to the test of time. Weezer's has. Which is exactly what you will see happening maybe another 10 years down the road. Whether they are standard or not, there's ALWAYS just that little more in a weezer song that makes it just indefinitely better.
btw, I know I agree that I was agreeing with you on a lot of some of the stuff that you have said, but I didn't feel like adressing all of your issues rather just state mine.
-
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 124
(3/16/02 4:22:53 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
RM:
Did you read my post above? The edited one. We're saying pretty similar things, I think.
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 92
(3/16/02 5:08:16 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Artfuse,
I'm sorry but I can't see how your edited post above really has to do with my post. I was never talking about simplicity.
Sorry.
-
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 133
(3/16/02 5:09:46 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I meant in terms of what we were both saying in regards to Rivers' guitar playing. His restraint. His finesse. Etc.
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 95
(3/16/02 5:12:02 pm)
Reply
|
Re: victory (VVV)
RadiusMan, I agree with your guitar sound ideas..
but the blue album was not standard in 1994. It was quite a radical departure from what was popular at the time.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 187
(3/16/02 5:19:01 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
First of all, that Creed dude is not a good example of a guitarist who shows off 100% of the time. He's mostly a rhythm guy who plays within in his means. And how did he creep into this conversation to begin with?! Moving on...
Second of all, I didn't say that Rivers should be showing off his guitar skills. My point was, that since he usually doesn't, it's not really a relevant arguement as to why weezer is better musically or whatever.
Thirdly, this is not JUST about guitar skills. We're talking about songs as a whole. The appeal of weezer's music in say 1995 was the fact that they had the energy and loud guitars of any ol' punk/alternative band at the time, except they had unique lyrics, unique melodies, and tasteful guitar work. They were like a smart punk rock act. Now though, I can't really say the lyrics are that much more unique then any other band, the melodies are solid but no more memorable then "Flavor of the Week" by American Hi-Fi or "In Too Deep" by Sum 41(both those songs have REALLY good melodies too!...that's why they were hits), and the guitar work is far less tasteful and follows the same stylistic approach as any other metal/punk band around right now(lot's of palm muting, typical sterile high gain sounds, etc).
I'm not trying to 'whine and bitch' here...just making observations, and providing a logical explanation as to why some 'old school' fans simply aren't going to understand where weezer is headed with these new songs. I can't speak for everybody, but I think the consensus is that these new songs are definitely good on a certain level...they just don't sound good coming from weezer(a purely shallow, nostalgic point of view, but still true to the way some people can't help but feel). We are all well aware of what a good song is, but not all 'good songs' are good weezer songs. There's a different(not to be mistaken with 'higher') standard in place for =w=. Unoriginality can be a good thing for some bands, but that's never what has made weezer good. Weezer without the originality is...i dunno what.
BTW - "there's ALWAYS just that little more in a weezer song that makes it just indefinitely better"
...on the Blue album and Pinkerton yeah...totally. And it wasn't so much that it was BETTER...it was just distinctly different then everybody else. When you heard the "Sweater Song" on the radio you knew it wasn't just any ol' mid 90's alternative act. Only three lousy chords, BUT the opening arpeggio stood out like a sore thumb, the singing was honest and delivered with force, the words were bizarre and intriguing, it had an incredible climax, and the solo kicked ass...it was AWESOME!...and that's far from being my favorite weezer song. It was inspiring music and it spoke to a certain(yet very wide) demographic of people which made being a weezer fan a blast at the time. It's all nostalgia...I'm gay.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 135
(3/16/02 5:24:34 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
Being a Weezer fan* is more of a blast now than ever before, because the band is incorporating us into the actual album process.
*even though Ace says we're not Weezer fans...
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 188
(3/16/02 5:40:44 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
I'm talking strictly about songs.
It's SUPER cool that weezer is letting us participate in the album-making process...but that's irrelevant to this topic. Alot of that is pretty much an illusion anyway. Rarely did Rivers ever improve on anything the way people were hoping he would...and I think the new songs are fine just the way they are anyway. They are done the best that those types of songs can be done.
...anyway, chatting with Rivers about random stuff is tons of fun. However, that has no bearing on the actual music.
|
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 137
(3/16/02 5:59:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
TLS
Agreed. I just wanted to make a point of what is the coolest thing about being a Weezer fan currently, rather than in the past.
I'm really tired of hearing everyone compare 2002 Weezer to any other Weezer. IMO, any comparison is worthless and irrelevant. A band should change. A band should progress. A band should not sound the same 10 years after their formation, nor should they necessarily stick to any one style or mindframe. I know this has been said countless times before, but I can't help revoking the example of the Beatles. If they'd sounded the same in 1968 as they did in 1962 or 1964, they would have lost quite a bit of their appeal. To me, that's a flaw of the Rolling Stones. Current Stones music sounds to me like they're trying to be the same band they were in the 60s and 70s. It doesn't work. They sound like what they are: a tired rehashing of their former glory.
I'm not accusing you of anything, TLS; I'm just sort of rambling. Nothing what I just said should be taken personally.
Hey...rather than letting this kill the interesting musical discussion that had been going on in this thread, can we just take what I just said as a side note, and go back to discussing the music? Sorry...
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 189
(3/16/02 6:31:31 pm)
Reply
|
Re: Lonely Serfer
"To me, that's a flaw of the Rolling Stones. Current Stones music sounds to me like they're trying to be the same band they were in the 60s and 70s. It doesn't work. They sound like what they are: a tired rehashing of their former glory."
...you could probably say something very similar about the Green Album.
Besides, there are plenty of bands who's sole appeal is based on the fact that they never stray too far from their original formula(i.e. - AC/DC, Metallica, U2, etc.), and I'd say that although the Stones seem like a 'tired rehashing of their former glory' to you, there are millions of Stones fans all over the world who love the fact the band has never changed, and they still get the same show, and the same type of songs as they did 30 years ago. I think alot of people were totally expecting weezer to be that kind of band, but Rivers threw us a curve. He's allowed to do that though. I have completely accepted the weezer transformation. At this point I would not wish for them to ever attempt to recapture the 'golden era'(as people have put it). That doesn't mean I can't prefer one era over the other though.
"A band should progress."
...people are ALWAYS saying this. I could not agree more that a band needs to progress. The debate is over whether weezer actually IS progressing. I personally haven't decided if weezer's change in sound should qualify as progress. I'm waiting for a couple more albums before I can assess that.
So basically...everything is so damn subjective that there really is no such thing as a valid arguement. It's fun to pretend that there is though...
|