← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > victory (VVV)
New Topic    Add Reply

Page 1 2 3

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 138
(3/16/02 6:45:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Yes, everything is subjective. If it weren't so, this thread wouldn't be so long -- in fact, this whole forum might not exist because fact would overrule all opinions and therefore, any further discussion would be unnecessary.

"...you could probably say something very similar about the Green Album."

How do you mean? IMO, Green was a far cry from Blue, Pinkerton, or any previous B-Sides.

I agree that there are plenty of bands who keep their music consistently homogeonous [I can't spell...dang] and do it well. I don't think that's a format that would have made sense for Weezer, though. Blue and Pinkerton are great because they're unique. While to Ace that would be a negative aspect of those records, to us it's a positive.

"I personally haven't decided if weezer's change in sound should qualify as progress. I'm waiting for a couple more albums before I can assess that."

I'm torn as to whether or not I honestly think Weezer are progressing. So far I say yes, but I can't really make that my definitive opinion until they take a break from recording.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 190
(3/16/02 7:12:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
You said: "To me, that's a flaw of the Rolling Stones. Current Stones music sounds to me like they're trying to be the same band they were in the 60s and 70s. It doesn't work. They sound like what they are: a tired rehashing of their former glory."

I said: "...you could probably say something very similar about the Green Album."

...because many people would probably say that weezer was 'attempting' to recapture a Blue-esque vibe on Green(same producer, rediculously similar album cover, same title, similar[but less inspiring] songs, similar guitar sounds, etc) but came up short, sounding like a tired rehashing of THEIR former glory. Get it?

NIRweeVANzerA
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/16/02 7:58:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
(This message was left blank)

Edited by: NIRweeVANzerA at: 3/16/02 8:10:42 pm
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 141
(3/16/02 7:59:29 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I get it. But I disagree. Green was only a "rehashing" of Blue superficially: cover design being the most obvious similarity of all. As far as the music goes, Green is in an entirely different realm than Blue. Definitely not a rehashing of any previous Weezer sound, IMO.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 1
(3/16/02 8:19:23 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Just wanted to say I really agree with one of artfuse's earlier posts. "The lyrics are obviously not the focus of the album." Exactly. I haven't heard all of Maladroit yet, but from what I have heard, it seems like Weezer is focusing more on the instrumentals...the demos I have heard all seem very different from each other. Instrumentally, Slob just sounds very different from Burndt Jamb which sounds very different from Fall Together, and so on and so forth. It's kind of cool to see all the different directions V could potentially go in.

RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 93
(3/16/02 8:24:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Surfer,
Honestly i'm getting tired of argueing over this. But I do respect your opinion even though I don't share the same... I hope you do the same for me.

But artfuse,
I do agree with Surfer about the fact that the Green album was trying to live off past glory of the blue album. Like he said, same producer, self titled, etc etc. The production was quite simular and the songs were a dissapointment for the most part in comparison to the blue album. Also, I would definitely argue with Surfer that the newer stuff could quite possibly be characterized as digression(is that the right word?) as opposed to progression. But like him, i'm going to wait a little longer before I come to that overal conclusion.

-

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 191
(3/16/02 9:11:10 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
'regression' = opposite of 'progression'

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 143
(3/16/02 9:11:49 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I think the problem is that people keep comparing Green to Blue. That's a mistake that too many Weezer fans make: comparing the albums to each other. Each Weezer album is strong enough to stand on its own, without being constantly referred or compared to the others.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 192
(3/16/02 9:26:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
artfuse, superficial or not superficial, the Green Album WAS a 'rehash' that didn't quite match the former glory of the Blue Album...that's the point, plain and simple. Besides, how is your statement about the Rolling Stones NOT an example of a superficial rehash?

We could split hairs about 'superficiallity' all night long, but now you're practically arguing with your own statements.

radiusman, what happened to us SHARING the same opinions? That doesn't hold up anymore?...what a pitty.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 193
(3/16/02 9:35:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
"I think the problem is that people keep comparing Green to Blue. That's a mistake that too many Weezer fans make: comparing the albums to each other. Each Weezer album is strong enough to stand on its own, without being constantly referred or compared to the others."

...you can't blame people for wanting to compare Green with Blue! It's called the GREEN album for godsakes...It practically has the SAME cover...it's ALSO self-titled...it was produced by the SAME guy. What else are people supposed to think?!

...and if "Photograph" isn't a Blue 'rehash', I don't know what is.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 144
(3/16/02 9:43:21 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
How on earth is Photograph a Blue rehash? That doesn't make any sense to me whatsoever.

I'm not being self-contradictory. The Rolling Stones keep trying to make THE SAME SOUND, and after nearly 40 years, they just don't do it well. They're trying to be the same, and they can't be. After 40 years, fuck, it's time for a bit of a change.

I don't blame people for wanting to compare Green to Blue. I just think it's a flawed way to go about listening to Weezer's music.

"...you can't blame people for wanting to compare Green with Blue! It's called the GREEN album for godsakes...It practically has the SAME cover...it's ALSO self-titled...it was produced by the SAME guy. What else are people supposed to think?!"

Um, yeah. Those are all superficial. The MUSIC is different. The MUSIC is what matters.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 54
(3/16/02 10:04:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Weezer set themselves up for Green to be compared to Blue, as Surfer has pointed out. But to say Green is a rehashing of the Blue album sound, I think is unfair. We all know how different the two albums really are. If Green is seen as an attempt to recapture the magic of the Blue album, then it completely fails (even if it is just our sentimentality towards Blue). But if Green is seen as sidestep towards a new direction, then it has succeeded on several levels.

Wilson

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 194
(3/17/02 12:10:57 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Define 'superficial' for me...

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 151
(3/17/02 12:20:24 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I mean superficial as topical...surface. The opposite of any relative depth. Basically, the packaging of the music -- who produced it, album art, etc.

Superficial: Of, affecting, or being on or near the surface: a superficial wound. Concerned with or comprehending only what is apparent or obvious; shallow. Apparent rather than actual or substantial; Trivial; insignificant.

MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 102
(3/17/02 12:23:44 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
It appears Lonely Surfer and Artfuse are either going to:
a) break out into a fight
b) e-bang

insertsomethingclever
Registered User
Posts: 34
(3/17/02 12:24:26 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
a, then b.

Edited by: insertsomethingclever at: 3/17/02 12:26:50 am
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 152
(3/17/02 12:29:08 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
This is so GOLD.

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 468
(3/17/02 12:30:06 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
querro is homophbe why is he mod? lol i dont thikn it\s fare cuz he is mean and dumb olol =)

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 56
(3/17/02 12:31:08 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
choices a and b are both equally worthless

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 153
(3/17/02 12:37:07 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Thank you, TRL.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 195
(3/17/02 12:40:47 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
e-bang?!...now, I am very interested in the definition for that!

The Stones thinking no one will notice that they're 60+ years old by putting on some leather pants and running around stage like a bunch of monkeys seems pretty superficial to me. This superficial thing is completely open to interpretation, depending how look at it. Either way, it is still irrelevant.

...BTW - "Photograph" = nearly the same "Buddy Holly" chord structure, with extremely similar 50's-esque melody and backround vocals. How does that not make any sense to you? I'm not just pulling shit out of my ass here...it's true.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 196
(3/17/02 12:43:00 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Well, it looks like either way, me and artfuse will be 'going at it.'

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 154
(3/17/02 1:25:57 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
First off...just use your imagination to figure out what "e-bang" means. Ick. No offense, but...ick.

I can see how you'd define that aspect of the Stones' live show as superficial; to me, though, I'd say it's more of a rehashing of their past, than anything. I know that's a very fine line I'm drawing between "superficial" and "rehashing," but if you need me to explain the difference I see in the two, let me know and I'll do my best to show the dichotomy.

I don't see that much of a similarity in the melodies of "Photograph" and "Buddy Holly," and I find it odd that you see so much similarities in the bgvs...didn't Rivers do a good percentage of the bgvs on Green? I don't know. I don't remember the chord structure of "Photograph," suppose I should go back and have a go at it. Anyway, I'm not saying your opinions are invalid [opinions can't be invalid] but I definitely disagree with you on this one.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 197
(3/17/02 1:40:07 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
It's not the SAME EXACT song note for note or anything!...of course. I'm not saying that "Photograph" has the SAME backup vocals, or precisely the SAME chords, or the exact SAME melody...if it did, it would be the SAME song.

I'm simply saying that they have a very parallel sound. Similar(not the SAME!) chords, 'ooo weee ooos', catchy 50's-esque melody, etc, etc, etc...do I have to keep repeating myself?! If you, for some reason, don't hear that AT ALL...then you must be deaf.

Can anybody else back me up on this???...

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 155
(3/17/02 2:02:02 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
TLS:
Down, boy. We're still just talking about music. Cool it.

When did I infer that you meant "note for note the same"? If the songs were note for note the same, or even close to that, there would be no reason for our debate here.

I agree with you that both songs are reminiscent of a 50s melody. That's oversimplified, though. But "Buddy Holly" always seemed like it was sort of a jestful 50s throwback. "Photograph" just takes a familiar sound and modernizes it. "Buddy Holly" and "Photograph," while invoking a 50s feeling, do it in very different ways.
These two songs share a few very very basic similarities, yes, but they are still so entirely different that to compare them the way you're doing comes off as a stretch.
Maybe our differences of opinion are more about word choice than anything. I wouldn't say that "Buddy Holly" and "Photograph" have a "parallel" sound. I would say that they're the most similiar in sound out of any other songs from Blue and Green; but that's it. And that's not enough, to me, to say that the albums have similar sound or that Green is a throwback/rehash/nouveaux to/of Blue.

What do you think of "December" in the case of this 50s-melody debate?

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 198
(3/17/02 4:05:18 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
"These two songs share a few very very basic similarities, yes, but they are still so entirely different that to compare them the way you're doing comes off as a stretch."

...whateva'. That is exactly the kind of comment that would infer you are looking for 'note for note' similarities. I mean, what more would two songs have to have in common for you to admit that they are similar, before they are just the same song? For two songs to convey a mere similar sound they're only allowed to have 'basic similarities.' The first time I heard "Photograph", I instantly thought, "this sounds alot like old school Buddy Holly weezer." That's all I'm saying...

I guess people hear things completely different...but all I know is that when the Green Album came out, the first thing ALL my friends told me was that weezer sounded alot like the Blue Album again. Sure there are obvious differences to any hardcore weezer fan, but for the most part, Green is a hark back to the traditional weezer sound, no doubt about it. The French phrase inside the cover even hints at it, c'mon! You[artfuse] can't seem to seperate yourself from the minut details/differences and look at it as an objective whole.

What I hear on Green is Rivers simplifying his traditional Blue sound to an even further minimalist degree, but trying to keep a few of the basic elements intact. I think it was very conscious too, because the summer songs didn't have that sound at all, and the only songs that don't sound as blue-ish on Green are "Hash Pipe" and "Island In the Sun", which of course were written much earlier then the rest of the songs(most of the Green songs were written in like the same week or whatever). It was probably simultaneously a songwriting experiment AND a way of temporarily getting the record company off his back by giving them the ultimate 'for sure' seller. He didn't take any chances making the songs interesting...he just said "fuck it" and gave them the perfect no nonsense pop album. I think Rivers is proud of himself for being able to produce such an accessible product so easily, and that's why he likes the album. It flows really well, it was the highest charting weezer album, and he didn't even put a whole lot of thought into it...it just came out. I'd be proud of that too!

So yeah, alot of things about Green ARE similar to Blue on a very superficial level(just like you've been saying), and funny enough, that's been my point all along as well. I just didn't bother to specify that the similarities were 'superficial similarities'('cause it's irrelevant...similar is similar), but you were very hung up on making that specification, at which point it went off on that Rolling Stones tangent where it wasn't even about the superficialness or non-superficialness of the Green Album anymore. But in connection with the Green Album debate, you were saying that the superficial qualities are only apparant in the cover art, Ocasek production, etc and nothing more beyond that...but I was arguing that the superficial qualities are in the music too(it's basically Blue without the frills)...however, you obviously disagree with that.

As far as "December" is concerned, it goes right along with what we've been talking about. That is a prime example of Rivers superficially recreating the traditional weezer B-Side sound(i.e. - "Devotion", "Susanne", and "Waiting On You")...which all happen to incorporate a somewhat 50's/60's ballad type sound, yeah.

insertsomethingclever
Registered User
Posts: 35
(3/17/02 4:10:35 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
TLS, do you ever quit?

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 199
(3/17/02 4:30:21 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Yes...as soon as people start making sense.

this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 209
(3/17/02 10:30:51 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
wow... for once TLS's fact checking is off, he must have been really pissed about this hissy-fight with artfuse

the phrase on the inside cover of green is italian


it isn't a big deal of course.... i'm just picking on you TLS

Sneper
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/17/02 11:16:14 am)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I agree with TLS about "Buddy Holly" and "Photograph". I hear many similarities between the two songs. Chord structure, the outro, etc. Just play the songs on guitar by yourself you'll see the similarites.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 201
(3/17/02 4:05:51 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I was probably confusing it with the writing on the oustside edge of the Pinkerton CD, which is in French if I'm not mistaken...it's irrelevant anyway, and I never claimed to be a flawless =w= fact checker in the first place. This whole debate is based on the OBVIOUS things.

...of course I realise you were just kidding, or 'picking on me' as you put it.

Whatever happened to the song "Don't Pick On Me" BTW? I thought that was one of the better tracks from the Maladroit demo sessions, and it had a killer solo. I loved the mellow Maj7 part too(the intro thing heard throughout the song). Anybody else like that song too?



Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 76
(3/17/02 4:06:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Pat does

monkeydunkredux
fucking anime queen
Posts: 211
(3/17/02 4:09:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
who cares?

Dude E
Registered User
Posts: 20
(3/17/02 4:10:33 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Don't Pick On Me was very cool, kinda dreamlike. No amazing piece of art, but just as good as most of Maladroit.

Much better than Possibilities, which if I remember correctly, replaced it.

JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 86
(3/17/02 4:20:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
the solo was pretty cool too. it fit with the song well.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 174
(3/17/02 4:22:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
TLS

I think the difference between our opinions all comes down to how we define "similarity" and differentiate any possible comparisons between the two songs. I maintain that I'm not trying to compare the songs "note for note" or anything along those lines; I'd like to believe that I'm looking at the two songs in the same exact manner in which you are, and we just see things differently.

To me, nothing on Green ever sounded like Blue. I'm not really sure why, perhaps I had already separated Green from any predating Weezer material before the album even came out; I
don't know. And it seems somewhat irrelevant now.

If anything, I'd say that Green is a throwback to the fresh-and-new *mindset* Weezer/Rivers had when they started recording Blue at Electric Ladyland. But, IMO, that doesn't reflect in the music. It's just Weezer trivia.

I agree with you that Rivers should be proud of Green. I agree that it was a "probably simultaneously a songwriting experiment AND a way of temporarily getting the record company off his back by giving them the ultimate 'for sure' seller." I'd be surprised to find that it was anything else. Rivers was exactly right to make Green so widely acceptable.

Can we move on now, please?


Just to "nitpick" a little -- the writing along Pinkerton is in Italian, too. I believe it's from Verdi.

"Don't Pick on Me" was a terrific song. I was sorry to see it 'die.' I also really dug the Maj7 part and the solo. That's a song I wouldn't mind hearing again.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 202
(3/17/02 4:33:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Move on to what?

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 147
(3/17/02 5:00:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
let us return to the old ways and THAT will be progress.

besides rap metal, green is the most significant accomplishment in rock music since grunge.

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 181
(3/17/02 5:02:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
easily.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 176
(3/17/02 5:10:24 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Move on from the "Buddy Holly"/"Photograph" debate. Time for a new topic.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 57
(3/17/02 7:12:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Rather sure of ourselves aren't we, ace?

Wilson

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 204
(3/17/02 7:12:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
New topic = ?

...so 'old ways' represents traditional pop songwriting techniques, I am assuming.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 205
(3/17/02 7:16:59 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
EXTREMELY sure of himself for a self proclaimed 'musical virgin.'

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 149
(3/17/02 7:17:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
well verdi meant a turn away from the romantic, dramatic, symphonic style of wagner and back to traditional song structures.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 183
(3/17/02 7:20:16 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
But Verdi, along with Puccini, are more in the vein of music which Nietzsche preaches against.


Or so I thought?

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 151
(3/17/02 7:20:24 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
COULDN'T BE SURER

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 206
(3/17/02 7:22:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Relatively speaking, does Blue qualify as 'romantic, dramatic, symphonic'?...or does it lean more towards traditional?

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 87
(3/17/02 7:22:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
rap metal eats more ass than emoass.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 152
(3/17/02 7:27:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
when i started writing blue i wanted to be neoclassical but by the time i hit no one else and say it aint so i felt the urge for romantic which culminated in pinkers**t

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/17/02 7:27:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
How do you feel about the neo-classical composers like Satie (sorta), Stravinsky (part of the time), Poulenc, and Milhaud? Is what they did a step in the right direction like Green is in your opinion?

Wilson

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 471
(3/17/02 7:27:55 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
AENFMJW;fjwkdawof;b3m32121

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 88
(3/17/02 7:29:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
If Green's so great then why do you revive more ss2k songs than green era songs?

anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 97
(3/17/02 7:31:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
i'm a big fan of that romantic symphonic style writing.
but what do I know? my tastes are shit says the big guy.
can't wait till the loop comes around again, to the more liberal ways. The pendulum always returns.

Dolemite
Registered User
Posts: 50
(3/17/02 7:33:14 pm)
Reply
Strings and shit.
Claszical muzak rockS!!!

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 100
(3/17/02 7:33:30 pm)
Reply
Re: victory (VVV)
romantic makes people feel

otherwise, it's just music to listen to. you can appreciate it for what it is, but it'll never mean anything to anyone other than a good melody or something kinda fun to listen to in the car

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 186
(3/17/02 7:37:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Newt:

It would seem to me that the S2K songs would leave more room for improvement/variation than the Green songs. When Ace redid the Green solos for the live shows, that was really the only improvement the songs needed.

I'm not saying that the S2K songs are flawed; just that because they are more intricate [for lack of a better word at the moment] there's more room to toy around and explore new possibilities in those songs.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 62
(3/17/02 7:40:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Artfuse:

I think he means Green ERA songs, not Green album songs. We don't know if all those songs are flawed or not.


Wilson

sch2383
Registered User
Posts: 55
(3/17/02 7:43:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I don't know about the rest of you, but ace's mind set before and after pinkerton is becoming more and more clear to me.

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 472
(3/17/02 7:44:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Wow, you're quick.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 188
(3/17/02 7:46:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Wilson:

I know he meant Green era. I'm going on the assumption that the majority of the Green era songs sound like the Green album songs.
Personally, I don't think Green [album] was flawed. True, the solos were bland and predictable and the album was a bit monotonous; however, that was necessary for the album to serve Rivers' purpose of having a widely accessible album. And they don't bother me as a hardcore Weezer fan, either.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 208
(3/17/02 7:48:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
The palm muted, two-chord verse on "Mad Kow" sounds alot like some 80's song, but I can never place the exact tune. Does anybody else hear that or know which song I'm thinking of?

Just thought I'd ask since we're on the topic of summer2k songs, and it's been bugging me for a long time.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 209
(3/17/02 7:54:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Green is completely void of flaws...that's why so many old fans are turned off by it. Imperfection can be very rewarding for the listener because it creates interest, and Green doesn't have that.

The flaw is that it has no flaws.

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/17/02 8:03:38 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
yeah kinda like that guy says in almost famous

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 211
(3/17/02 8:06:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
What's he say? I never saw that movie...

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 156
(3/17/02 8:08:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
I AM A GOLDEN GOD

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 91
(3/17/02 8:08:33 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
"Green is completely void of flaws...that's why so many old fans are turned off by it. Imperfection can be very rewarding for the listener because it creates interest, and Green doesn't have that."

Well put, Surfer

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 212
(3/17/02 8:10:39 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
"I AM A GOLDEN GOD"

...ha!...that should go on the main page or something.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 191
(3/17/02 8:13:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Good point, TLS.

asirem
Registered User
Posts: 37
(3/17/02 8:14:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
That's Fuckin classic!

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 192
(3/17/02 8:37:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
Almost Famous: the Bootleg edition owns. and cameron crowe fucking owns too.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 193
(3/17/02 8:38:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
i double post cuz i am a moron

Edited by: Kelly Kapowski Loves Me at: 3/17/02 8:51:19 pm
artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 198
(3/17/02 8:39:41 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
YES. The bootleg Almost Famous is incredible.

What did you think of Vanilla Sky?

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 452
(3/17/02 8:49:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
man i love this board

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 727
(3/17/02 8:51:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
gay

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 60
(3/17/02 8:53:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Lonely Serfer
i meant to see vanilla sky. only bc brodie is fucking awesome.

TLS: the guy in almost famous said something about the best stuff in rock being the stuff that isnt supposed to be there and gave some song as an example but i forget.

ace you need to start acting like a real rockstar and jump in a pool from a roof after you overdose on LSD

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 197
(3/17/02 8:53:41 pm)
Reply
artfuse
i dug vanilla sky lots. it's really well done and was a good change of pace for him. i'm glad he's making more films now instead of one every four years like he was averaging. He's just about done writing his new project, so hopefully that'll be out within a year or so.

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 80
(3/17/02 8:57:56 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
I love vanilla sky until the ending, the ending was lame, yes it was.

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 186
(3/17/02 9:02:58 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Open Your Eyes fucking rocks. Owns Vanilla Sky.

Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 133
(3/17/02 10:29:07 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Yeah Ace, I think you should advocate drug use and rebellion on the next album.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 35
(3/18/02 12:21:45 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
he already advocated that with the green album.

RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 101
(3/18/02 12:22:23 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
I know i'm like half a page late on this,

But I am a big believer in imperfection makes perfection. Though anyone i've told that to doesn't seem to understand what I am talking about. But I think that's what made Pinkerton and the blue album so great.... It's the imperfection of it. I mean Weezer took for the green album 70+ songs and demoed them a hundred times, then kept throwing away songs until they had the oned they wanted and then demoed those songs a hundred more times and then went into the studio and worked out every little detail until it sounded perfect. Even though the green album is technically "perfect" to me it's "imperfect". It's hard to explain and I don't have the time cause I should be studying for finals, but if you guys still don't understand about "imperfection" makes "perfection" just let me know and I'll type until topic is dead tomorrow night after my finals.

-

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 214
(3/18/02 1:29:14 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Imperfection doesn't really mean perfection...it just means better, and more interesting.

When you listen to an old Led Zeppelin record, it's never aboslutely perfect(even though they're probably considered the greatest group of musicians ever assembled). There's alot of spontanaity there, which means you're gonna' have a few warts...it gives it character, and that's what makes it great. Same with the Beatles. Same with Van Halen. Same with Nirvana. Etc...etc...etc...

Emotional lyrics aside...Pinkerton had that same spontaneous appeal from a performance stand point, and I think that's why alot of fans are really into it. You can actually hear the band 'rocking out'...it's very natural, and it doesn't sound like they're holding ANYTHING back whatsoever(musically or vocally). I think people connected with Pinkerton not only on an 'easy-to-relate-to' basis, but they connected with the performance value as well. It's a very honest representation of what the band sounds like, which complimented the honesty in the words. Even if it sucks...at least it was 'real.'

JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 96
(3/18/02 1:34:36 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
the Pixies are a good example, but Rivers doesn't like them now =/

I think his view of music as a whole has changed.

flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/18/02 1:46:00 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
i hear you Radiusman...

a lot of people have been saying-myself included-that green sounds better after hearing the promo. it's odd. perplexing.

in a sense, all weezer sounds better in retrospect.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 206
(3/18/02 1:57:11 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
RadiusMan and Surfer:

On which side of the imperfect/perfect line would you put Maladroit?

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 105
(3/18/02 2:00:33 am)
Reply
Re: victory (VVV)
"I think his view of music as a whole has changed."

Of course.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 215
(3/18/02 2:06:41 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Maladroit is definitely on the more perfect side of things. Not quite to the same degree that Green was, but darn close. There is no 'real' energy...the songs that rock only rock on a superficial(hehe) level. The riffs are heavy so it naturally sounds sort of rockin', but the band isn't really going all out, if that makes any sense.

flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 13
(3/18/02 2:14:25 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
in terms of fiction writing, eh... if that can apply...

the stakes aren't high enough. in fiction writing, stories have to have high stakes. someone has to die. or lose their job. or flunk out of school. or something.

the stakes are high with blue, 'cuz they had to make a good record, seeing as how they were young and fresh on the DGC bill. stakes are high on pinkerton, too, 'cuz they were at a point where no one took them seriously, so they made a serious record.

you'd think the stakes would have been high with green, but they had the entire music industry's buzz-central backing them.

with mala, and with future records, there are no high stakes at all. they're rich with a huge fan base.

Edited by: flippyweez at: 3/18/02 2:20:12 am
this niblet
Registered User
Posts: 211
(3/18/02 10:00:15 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
that analysis has absolutely nothing to do with the music itself. which is dumb on many levels. first you make a (weak) point about the stories in fiction writing, then you make a comparison to weezer where you ignore the content of the art form. you're talking about weezer's career history as if we're all deciding whether or not the biography is good.

flippyweez
Registered User
Posts: 16
(3/18/02 11:31:31 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
the point is not mine. all fiction writers know this.

"the content of the art form" ...?
i wouldn't call weezer "art." my application was an indirect metaphor, an analogy, to high stakes. now that i read it again, it does apply. the high stakes rule applies to the writers as well as the characters; and, my comment was merely a reference to the lonely surfer's comment regarding why the music on mala seems superficial, like they're holding back.

fuck biographies. the fact that there are little high stakes in the latest =w= is a truth. it's why (if you can withhold yourself from denial) record five will probably be a letdown.

jade
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/18/02 12:03:54 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
I see more of an analogy to fiction writing in that of a character...a character is its problems, and that's what makes it interesting. It's what the story is framed around and what holds your attention.

If you try to write a story about a perfect character, not only is it difficult, but no one will be able to relate to it, so few people will care. People might look at it as a great literary accomplishment, but it could still lack the ability to truly speak to people. I think this applies to why we liked Blue and Pinkerton so much...not only could we relate more to the lyrics, but the 'flaws' in the music made them so much more interesting to listen to. With Green, especially, there was very little that held my attention. Maladroit is a step in the right direction, but it still isn't as interesting.

This is a roundabout way of saying I agree with RadiusMan.

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 140
(3/18/02 1:22:13 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
What are you talking about, weezer (their music..) is "art"

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 214
(3/18/02 1:27:54 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Any creative expenditure is art.

RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 104
(3/18/02 1:46:22 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Surfer, I can kinda see where you are coming from where it just makes things more "interesting" however I still stick with my point overall.

I'll try several analogies as it's so hard for me to explain this for some reason.

First: With art, you can have a painter who's strokes, use of color, and painting ability are so great that he can paint a picture and it almost looks like a photograph. It's perfect in everyway. But in essense it's really NOT perfect because it doesn't mean anything it is almost NON human. Cause it's not human TO *be* perfect. Or you can have a guy who does abstract art, who's strokes aren't so nicely painted, colors don't exactly match, and a picture that looks more like a murder scene than a photograph, but yet it's the fact that that it didn't look nice that made it so perfect.
Okay, that wasn't the best example but here's a better one.

A couple months back, I wrote a song that I thought just perfectly solidified an exact moment of an instance that was only about 1 second long. I mean what I felt in that one second, was exactly what was on the paper. I sent the lyrics to a fellow songwriting friend of mine, who's a much better poet than I am in just about every way. And he sent back "corrections" on my song lyrics (which if you ask me was a pretty dick move). I read over the song lyrics, and you know what? Poetically it was so much better, and the words he swapped out made much more sense. Poetically he had perfected it. But it had lost my perfect transfer from emotion to lyric. So while it was poetically perfect, it was more imperfect as my original lyrics while imperfect were so much better. And perfect to me. Needless to say, I didn't use even a 1 of his changes.

Does that help explain it at all? I'm having a hard time explaining this, but I think that you pretty much understand what I am saying.

As for Maladroit, I too would put it more on the perfect side. Though I disagree with the person above (I think it was surfer) who said that it still didn't have energy. I think that Maladroit has a lot of energy, but still lacking somewhat in emotion.

-

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 141
(3/18/02 1:48:48 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
well.. that's such a fine line... you wanna strive for perfection, but when you reach it, it's imperfection, that sucks.

RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 106
(3/18/02 1:55:58 pm)
Reply
Re: artfuse
Brokemyrecord,
I hate to say it but I think that is correct. And I'll tell you why. It's cause it's inhuman to be perfect. We've seen this with Ace's need to write the perfect pop song... we know where that is leading.

-

funstalin
Registered User
Posts: 14
(3/19/02 3:03:00 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
if this is anything like fiction writing its more oprahs book club than pynchon.

christ steinbeck
Registered User
Posts: 2
(3/19/02 6:27:39 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
the production/performance on p.ink is as "honest" as the music. matt's bass slides before the coda of t.o.s., rivers' voice crack in butterfly, the buzz in the good life... whether its contrived or not is another matter (although everything is contrived to some extent) but the record sounds like its from the heart. the production on green is as emotionally devoid as the songwriting.

spongebobsquarepants
Registered User
Posts: 8
(3/19/02 6:36:16 am)
Reply
Re: artfuse
which is exactly what was intended

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 757
(3/19/02 9:41:01 am)
Reply
Re: victory (VVV)
Waiting and waiting
You got me waiting
Waiting on you

I asked you if you had a good heart
You answered, "Yes, I'll never do you harm"
I asked you if you had a good heart
You answered, "Yes, I'll never do you harm"

hmmm.......

No... everyone, everyone
Everyone I know
Take control
Whoa-oh
Whoa-oh
Whoa-oh


i cant decide


Page 1 2 3 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index