← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Ace's sense of melody
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
eversogood
Registered User
Posts: 8
(3/20/02 7:01:37 pm)
Reply
Ace's sense of melody
Hey ace, in trying to analyze your style of writing melodies.. i noticed you like to use 4ths, 6ths and 7ths a lot. Is this intended? I am also a songwriter and i feel i have a similar style of melody as you (only really really underdeveloped of course) ...maybe thats from growing up on weezer, i dunno.. but im just curious about if you use any theory, other than the major chromatic scale?

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 113
(3/20/02 7:04:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Tons of sevenths on blue and @#%$

Hardly any on green.

More on Maladroit

asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 785
(3/20/02 7:20:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
yea green lacks

eversogood
Registered User
Posts: 9
(3/20/02 8:22:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
it does lack..but i think the only reason it does is because they didnt expand on it enough like they did every other album..it was rushed.. i think if he had used this message board for correspondence on green..it would have been a much better album.. but whats done is done :\

Super NintenDEN
Registered User
Posts: 47
(3/20/02 8:25:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
yeah, green would've been a LOT better if they had tried to make it better, and if they had listened to us it would've been a lot better too, but part of the whole "green pop" has to have a lot to do with interscope too. There's no way interscope would've approved a lot of rock, or a more pinkerton sound. even though rivers wouldnt have tried another pinkerton sound.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 195
(3/20/02 9:27:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i used to force 7ths: no one else, across the sea

i don't force anymore.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 115
(3/20/02 9:30:08 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Ah, I think sometimes tweaking a melody can give it the edge it needs. Do you ever go back and tweak anything once you've initially laid it out, or do you just leave it alone and throw it out if you don't like it?

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 222
(3/20/02 9:31:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
let it flow.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 201
(3/20/02 9:37:19 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i dunno about that...

letting it flow or not 'forcing' it could also mean, not putting any effort for improvement of the songs, which could also explain how these songs are getting down so fast. Why not let it flow, then un-gay it after by throwing in a longer complicated bridge? or what not.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 118
(3/20/02 9:41:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I know, honestly, it really doesn't make sense, I mean.. what creator of any art is totally satisfied after their first go at it..

Also, I just want to point out one thing.. there IS a lot of editing done to weezer songs in terms of structure, lyrics, etc.. I mean, c'mon, we heard the Maladroit sessions.

But MELODY can be improved on.

rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 203
(3/20/02 9:44:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i think the structure in maladroit is pretty plain.

MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 138
(3/20/02 9:44:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Brian Wilson was the *master* of the forced 7th. He says he won't use the straight-up minor - gotta be the minor 7th. Sometimes minor 7th is just a bit too ambivalent....

Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 3/20/02 9:51:08 pm
UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 224
(3/20/02 9:44:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
melody is so fuckin hard.

jimboner
Registered User
Posts: 69
(3/20/02 9:49:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Brain Wilson = complete genious of modern music

No one else can compare

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 119
(3/20/02 9:51:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Melody isn't that hard, to me..

it's coming up with the right chords to back the melody that's hard.

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 225
(3/20/02 9:52:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
no man you've got it all wrong the chords are the fuckin easy part.

jimboner
Registered User
Posts: 72
(3/20/02 9:55:00 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Real Frogs must be friggin' gifted if he finds melody easy.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 120
(3/20/02 9:55:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
To each his own, sir..

I just know I've got a goldmine of melodies I can't use because I can't find the perfect chord progression to back them.

It's not hard to come up with a chord progression, and certainly not even hard to find one that fits.. but it can be mind-numbing to try to find one that fits EXACTLY.

This is why I never dig through my melody stockpile, because I usually end up improvising something over me playing guitar, and it's just easier to work with that.

idahoprime
Registered User
Posts: 10
(3/20/02 9:56:18 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
rezee.. the melody in maladroit is plain, compared to #2 but you have to admit its a step up from green. I can only imagine i will get better and better.

phil collins band
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/20/02 10:23:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I've tried both approaches, writing the melody first and then trying to back it with chords, and vise versa, and its hard, its best to just kind of let it flow, that's works pretty well. Though my lyrics really suck.

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 503
(3/20/02 10:31:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Its hard to write lyrics without sacrificing heterosexuality. You have to give a little to get a little.

indyatom
Registered User
Posts: 66
(3/20/02 11:17:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i haven't thought about whether weezer does it or not, but i really like a moving seventh in a bridge, its nice to hit that, then bring it down to the 4. I'll go listen to all the albums again and see what goes on. I agree wish asschun, green was for sure lacking

Zia468
Registered User
Posts: 1
(3/20/02 11:26:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
yes, green definitely didn't live up to his/their true potential...

starby
Registered User
Posts: 18
(3/20/02 11:27:10 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
there's no such thing as a forced 7th if it is only in the mealody. i mean that if you take away the chords, the basis for saying 6th, 7th, minor, or whatever, it is just a mealody that can go anywhere and do what it wants. if a note ends up being sung as an 'f' with no chord, it is free to land where it pleases. it can land in an 'f' chord, a d minor, b flat, and a g 7th. but just because it lands on a g 7th and makes the g a 7th doesn't mean that its forced. an man i can't get away from turning nearly every 7th into a inor 7th, it just makes the chord seem less solid and maybe more transitional in a way. whatever though.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 122
(3/20/02 11:35:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Even if there are no backing chords, a melody still has a key, and if the melody lands on the major seventh of that key, it's a still a major seventh..

But it takes the right backing chord to have the chord of a major seventh. You know, I could be wrong, I don't know much theory at all.

Edited by: Real Frogs at: 3/20/02 11:43:45 pm
asschun
STILL admin
STILL kill teh gayz

Posts: 787
(3/20/02 11:39:21 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
wtf

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 267
(3/20/02 11:43:22 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
haha

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 117
(3/20/02 11:44:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
"Even if there are no backing chords, a melody still has a key, and if the melody lands on the major seventh of that key, it's a still a major seventh.. "

Exactly, you can't just land on a note and build any old chord off of it, it has to have some sort of logical progression.

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 228
(3/20/02 11:48:03 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
there are chordal root notes to a melody, these notes are derived from the chords themselves.

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 118
(3/20/02 11:51:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
right...what's your point?

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 269
(3/20/02 11:53:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
'chordal root notes' eh?

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 119
(3/20/02 11:57:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Last time I checked every single chord had a root note.

SRX Rawk
Registered User
Posts: 6
(3/20/02 11:58:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Chordal root notes or not:

GREEN INDEED LACKS. Well said.

starby
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/21/02 12:04:36 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I didn't mean that you could put any note just anywhere, and I know that there is a chord root structure to be followed by a mealody, all I was saying is that just because a note makes a chord a 7th doesn't mean it's forced. because that note could go into about thre other chords in that progression and sound just as good. Shit then. maybe I'll shut up.....now.

old shoes
Registered User
Posts: 50
(3/21/02 12:30:14 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
starby, you seem reasonably clued up in the theory department for someone that can't spell melody...

starby
Registered User
Posts: 20
(3/21/02 12:34:14 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Yeah I have a cousin with the same name/word/whatever and I guess that's just how it's spelled in my mind.

Sifter
Registered User
Posts: 54
(3/21/02 12:35:39 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
melody for smile>any maladroit song.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 277
(3/21/02 12:37:02 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Smile = OASIS

MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 145
(3/21/02 12:39:10 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I'm with sifter. green melodies are good.

starby
Registered User
Posts: 21
(3/21/02 12:40:05 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Smile= Almost Brian Wilson

dishboy03
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/21/02 12:41:39 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
yeah thats all green had going for it, the melodies were great i thought.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 278
(3/21/02 12:43:32 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Smile = OASIS!

Buddy Holly = Almost Brian Wilson

old shoes
Registered User
Posts: 51
(3/21/02 12:56:28 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
word up surfer.

JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 106
(3/21/02 12:57:31 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I agree... BH is probably the closest they've gotten to pop perfection. It seemed like around the time he was writing Pinkerton, he thought he'd already gotten pretty proficiant at writing pop tunes and was ready to branch out in terms of dynamics. I wonder what changed his mind.

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 473
(3/21/02 1:02:36 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
smile indeed sounds like an oasis tune. That's one of the reasons it's so great.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 91
(3/21/02 1:10:08 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I'm not hearing the oasis comparison. what song would you compare smile to?

Buddy Holly is no where near Brian Wilson. Not to say that BH is not near pop perfection, but it isn't nearly as complex or intricate as a Wilson tune.

Wilson

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 474
(3/21/02 1:16:19 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
smile would fit quite snugly on morning glory.

Dionysos
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/21/02 1:19:56 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
ridd here's a link for you

user.chollian.net/~xania/...elGets.htm

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 29
(3/21/02 1:20:58 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
very true

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 475
(3/21/02 1:24:26 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
shit! Thanks man.

Dionysos
Registered User
Posts: 25
(3/21/02 1:25:30 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
your welcome, enjoy!

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 280
(3/21/02 1:31:26 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
"Smile" = OASIS because...

#1) The tempo.

#2) The melody.

#3) The vocal delivery.

#5) The complex, yet perfectly flowing song structure.

#6) The B.S. lyrics that go together in a way that sounds like it's vaguely about something, but yet you know it's not about anything at all. <--- The biggest sign of Oasis influence on Green as a whole.

..."Morning Glory" is one of the greatest albums ever made. Production sucks, the singing is annoying as hell, Noel and Liam are pricks...however, the songs are great and none of that other stuff matters.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 281
(3/21/02 1:33:03 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Ridd, you are into Oasis?

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 476
(3/21/02 1:36:19 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
uhhuh

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 283
(3/21/02 1:42:00 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Morning Glory is easily one of my top 5 albums of all time. I can't get away from it...I never got tired of it. When I was in High School I was really obsessed with them for some reason, and I bought all the albums(that were out at the time)...Morning Glory is the only that stuck over the years though. There are some songs on Definitely Maybe that I really love...but the album as a whole wasn't so solid. Be Here Now was the same way. Anything after that doesn't really count.

MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 146
(3/21/02 1:49:05 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
songs on Morning Glory are too long. too much filler. too self-indulgent. Oasis could have used a little of the green treatment in tightening the songs up. that said, the songs themselves are pretty sweet.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 285
(3/21/02 1:52:16 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
The rain songs are filler...all the real songs are legitimate though.

weezergirl217
my real name is vivian, bitches
Posts: 18
(3/21/02 1:54:51 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
my sister's best friend went out with liam for a while back in the day. she's the one who named the album. i remember seeing him on this interview on teevee.. the person interviewing him asked where the name of the album came from.

"oh, this girl i was going with for a while came up with it ... *looks and points at camera with a mean face* don't expect any royalties!"

arse.

but ANYWAY. morning glory is a great album. "wonderwall" brings back oh so many memories.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 286
(3/21/02 2:36:48 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
So did Noel write the song "Morning Glory" AFTER Liam had come to him with the idea for the album name?

weezergirl217
my real name is vivian, bitches
Posts: 24
(3/21/02 3:10:41 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
liam was actually living with her and my sister for a couple months in san francisco.. during this time noel and the other guys would come and visit and, hah, "jam" i guess. i don't really know WHEN he wrote "morning glory" but she's definitely the one who came up with the album name.. it's this weird phrase she used to blurt out ALL THE TIME.. even when i was in elementary i remembered her saying it constantly. and yes, it was something she made up all on her own.

ElDarklord
Registered User
Posts: 21
(3/21/02 3:17:45 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I remember thinking that Smile sounded like an Oasis tune also the first time I heard it (which is also why I really dig Smile, being an Oasis fan). It actually reminds me more of some songs from the third album Be Here Now. Reminds me of Stand By Me the most I would say or a song like Don't Go Away. I'm not saying it sounds just like them but it sounds like that type of song.

VonBean
Registered User
Posts: 43
(3/21/02 3:33:40 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I hated Oasis for a long time, overkill on the radio and that little fit they threw in Vancouver over the flying water-bottles annoyed me. Then I saw the Behind the Music, and those two shitheads made me howl--they honestly hate one another and each proclaim themselves to be the backbone of the band. Call it the bastard factor, I guess, but for that reason alone, I now really quite enjoy them.

Edited by: VonBean at: 3/21/02 3:35:52 am
Honkey Doorie
Registered User
Posts: 83
(3/21/02 9:52:11 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i like how the melody to "across the sea" starts on the 7th....for some reason i find that very odd but very cool.

starby
Registered User
Posts: 22
(3/21/02 12:22:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
You mean that maj7 of 'you are'? Yeah I agree that is a good way to start a melody because it's kind of whispy and it almost makes the song less based on a solid formulated melody and more of a stream of consciousness idea, which is not too often used in pop music. Plus I think Oasis is cool but I never could dig their lyrics; it always seemed like they were trying too hard to be out there or overly simple pop. But all the same I do like them, just I think Definitly Maybe is better than Morning Glory, it's more rock and roll.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 124
(3/21/02 3:46:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I think that's what Rivers was talking about when he said he forced it, because No One Else starts on a maj7th too. And yeah, it's great.. starting on that note.. great.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 293
(3/21/02 3:53:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
If anything, it's a not so stream of conscious note to start on, which I think Frogs was hinting at. Alot of times the natural note to start on is the good ol' root or the fifth. Kurt Cobain had alot of problems getting away from that at times...he was pure stream of consciousness in his approach, and that's why. Nirvana songs are still awesome though right!?

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 36
(3/21/02 3:55:25 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
of coarse at least IMHO

anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 123
(3/21/02 4:02:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
personally, those maj7's really set an awesome tone for the rest of the songs. For me a vocal melody incorporates maj7's in a good few cases in some of my songs. And to me it never really feels forced. But I sense a lot of that has to do with the fact that I do have so much weezer influence, and those 2 songs are a couple of my favorites. It's hard to cut out influences in the song writing process. too many times I've made a pretty good song, but it seems like everytime I think it sounds like some other song I know, or can't quite place, and I'll just discard it. but anyways, rivers really is a melody genius. of course the old melodies were way better in my opinion. much more fun to sing along to, because they seemed to flow, and go all over the place, and have some pretty high parts. but now there is a whole lot of repetition, and lack of energy, of course with a few exceptions. the lyrics of course have a good deal to do with the singing part too.

starby
Registered User
Posts: 23
(3/21/02 4:49:41 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Hmm Ace....you said you don't like pushed 7ths and you don't use them anymore, but what about the first words in 'slave'? I'm pretty damn sure that's a maj7 there and that whole song has thast kind of vibe. The same goes for the mid in 'love explosion'. Well I could be wrong but that's what I hear.

*edit* after about ten more seconds of thought I now see the difference between the maj7 in slave (a natural progression in the melody to the next natural note) and no one else (could be e major, or sung as e flat just the same) but I don't think "pushed" 7ths are a bad thing, they add ambience and personality to a tune.

Edited by: starby at: 3/21/02 4:55:17 pm
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 125
(3/21/02 5:05:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
First note of slave is a maj7th, yep..

Another is YGYLTMS.

I just don't think the first note of slave sticks out so much because it's not as raw.. you've got that guitar note in the background. In the other songs we've mentioned it's just the voice/guitar/bass, so it KILLS on the first note..

Honkey Doorie
Registered User
Posts: 86
(3/21/02 5:52:01 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
writing songs where the melody starts on the maj7 is a very difficult thing...at least for me...i've attempted to do this and i just always fail...the melody sucks and i have no idea where to go after it...i also always have trouble hitting the maj7 when it is the first note in a song...it feels very awkward...but it sounds so cool...

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 93
(3/21/02 10:04:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
just a quick question are we talking 7ths as intervalls or scale degrees in weezers music?

cuz I know the first note of slave is the 7th scale degree. are all these references to the 7th scale degree?

Wilson

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 126
(3/22/02 12:06:43 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Scale degrees.. but only when it's a maj7th of the root chord. If the chord is a G, F# in the melody.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 94
(3/22/02 2:04:25 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
thanks.

I understand what it is... I just wasn't sure which ya'll were talking about.

Wilson

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 131
(3/22/02 2:19:53 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Well yeah, I assumed you knew, I was just tossing it out there for anyone who might not and is reading this thread like "what the hell.."

beenchasingamy
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/22/02 6:07:34 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
I know this is completely off topic, but god damnit Real Frogs, give me another fucking new song. I need something new to listen to....Megaman can only be played a few thousand times before I start to lose my feelings for it.

Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 133
(3/22/02 8:06:34 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
IM me: Real Frogs

you played me on the radio; you deserve to hear new stuff!

Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 49
(3/22/02 9:11:25 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i've been playing guitar for a few years, but i never took lessons... i just kinda bought a guitar and dicked around, so i don't know any music theory.

so could someone explain 7th intervals and scale degrees and all that? 7th interval is the 7th note of the major scale for the key that you're using, correct? if someone could enlighten me, i'd appreciate it. maybe it'd be better to email me, so this thread doesn't get cluttered.

WatchMeVanish@aol.com
or
StapledBaby@aol.com

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 65
(3/23/02 7:32:25 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
if your gonna email an explanation to him, please just post it here. im interested as well.

paperfacepilgrm
Registered User
Posts: 77
(3/23/02 8:27:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
are no one else, across the sea, and slave all in the same key?

SkyBlue523202
VIRGIN MODERATOR
Posts: 150
(3/24/02 10:52:33 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
umm... yeah this topic is now obsolete

dorkamania
Registered User
Posts: 21
(3/25/02 12:18:59 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
hey Ace,

what's your favorite weezer song?

FFeJ and Raven
Registered User
Posts: 70
(3/25/02 3:38:51 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
i want to be a musician, yet this entire topic sailed way over my head. not cool.

artfuse
FEMALE
Posts: 238
(3/25/02 4:35:14 am)
Reply
Re: Ace's sense of melody
Jesus, Molly, so what? People are saying things of interest and quality in this thread. So unless you've got something worthwhile to contribute, please go away and let the rest of us enjoy this thread.

Edited by: artfuse  at: 3/25/02 4:54:47 am
<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index