← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > gone but not forgotten
New Topic

Page 1 2 3

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/20/02 2:30:44 pm)
gone but not forgotten
the dawn and broken arrows. should they be on album five or never returned? ace previously mentioned the dawn was going to come back after album 4 and broken arrows had 'painful memories.'

scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 10
(3/20/02 2:39:32 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
They were both relatively good but are definitely not worth bringing back. Hopefully there are much better songs to use than those. If not we're in trouble.

Edited by: scratchy2213 at: 3/20/02 2:41:00 pm
the citizen of wen
Registered User
Posts: 84
(3/20/02 2:40:51 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i've been consistently underwhelmed by the dawn. i think it would need to undergo a major revision to be viable.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 60
(3/20/02 2:42:43 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
man, the riff on the dawn is amazing i think. maybe not in difficulty, but just the way it sounds.

and the 'and after all...' part in broken arrows is the best melody written post 2000.

i think, at least.

FMGreen
Registered User
Posts: 60
(3/20/02 2:45:50 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
and How Long? and Seafaring Jamb.

actually, i could care less about Seafaring Jamb...i just want that solo. that solo, repeated over and over, for 30 minutes.

I figure...the s2k songs are just getting released in the past 2 years...so it might be another 2 or 3 before we see Broken Arrows, How Long?, Seafaring Jamb, The Dawn...etc...

but im sure we will see them back soon enough.

as the old saying goes...album 7 is going to be THE masterpiece. now im starting to think that joke is actually the truth. i cant wait for the future.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 85
(3/20/02 2:47:59 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I'm with about the Dawn. Cool riff, but the song as a whole could somehow be improved.

Broken Arrows was good, but never felt completely right. I wouldn't mind hearing a new version of this, but don't expect it at all.

Wilson

grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 142
(3/20/02 2:49:42 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
the dawn yes....broken arrows, not so much...i'd like to see the kitsch disappear for album 5...and songs with lines like 'love canopy of dreams and broken arrows' definately have a fair amount of it....

if the dawn isn't even put on an album, i'd love to start hearing it live again...it was such an amazing show opener...i remember reading someone the other day say it was like the musical equvalent of saying 'hi how are you' and it totally is, as cheesy as it sounds...

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 470
(3/20/02 2:49:46 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
'The Dawn' needs to come back in some form. The "as the day goes on" part is just too cool to be cast away. Also, the way the 3 guitars work together in the main riff is interesting to me.

Broken Arrows? Everyone should go listen to this one again.. it's actually pretty good, but it was scrapped pretty quick for some reason. It needs a little work - the intro is quite weak - but when it gets going with the chugging guitar riff ("every hour, every day"), I like it. Just needs a little more energy or something.

jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 28
(3/20/02 2:55:03 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The dawn does have an excellent sounding riff.

"i think it would need to undergo a major revision to be viable. "

I'm pretty sure if it got the mala treatment that american gigolo and others got, it really could be good.

rockdevil13
Registered User
Posts: 26
(3/20/02 2:55:42 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
high up above needs to make a comeback. i like the melancholy in it.

grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 143
(3/20/02 2:57:55 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
the ORIGINAL high up above...with the organ....that song was great...

the citizen of wen
Registered User
Posts: 85
(3/20/02 2:59:51 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
ridd: the main riff was (IMO) the only interesting thing about that song, and even then it was tranquilizing to me. Then again, I'm one of the people that never liked Sandwiches Time, so my taste is probably suspect to begin with.

The more i listen to how burndt jamb has progressed, the more i want to hear that musical direction explored fully.

old shoes
Registered User
Posts: 45
(3/20/02 3:06:00 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i think the dawn could be AMAZING with a little work, especially with a little variation in the instrumentation, i can hear a piano on this song. broken arrows always sounded kinda clumsy to me, how long on the other hand is awesome.
more than any other song though i want dont pick on me to return, that song is great in a way i cannot put my finger on.

Ahmed Malik
fucking anime queen
Posts: 84
(3/20/02 3:06:22 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
weezer.no/ahmed/files/The%20Dawn.mp3

need to be brought back in no order :

The Dawn
Mr. Taxman
A Thousand Years
Purification of Water
Baby

milk denial
Registered User
Posts: 11
(3/20/02 3:06:42 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
How Long was my second favorite song demoed, next to Slob. It was excellent, especially the muted guitar crunch and BGV's. A better recording would produce one of the "holy shit" songs we miss i think.

UserName
where's my gay custom title.
Posts: 219
(3/20/02 3:08:52 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The Dawn fucking rocks, High Up Above fucking rocks (organ or no organ), Broken Arrows isn't that good.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 61
(3/20/02 3:11:04 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
dont pick on me's 'dont trifle, dont stifle me' is a good part. I wouldnt mind seeing that and how long either.

im talking about the 01.03.02 version of broken arrows, also. 01.04.02 was totally different and atrocious.

jkam

Posts: 49
(3/20/02 3:15:12 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
So Low....why?

1. Listen to the version from the GP show. Rivers belts this song out and it sounds amazing.

2. Great pre-chorus and chorus.

3. The music rocks!

4. Such a great buildup feel to this song. I love the way in swoops in and out and just nails you when the chorus comes in.

-Jason

Edited by: jkam at: 3/20/02 3:29:00 pm
eversogood
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/20/02 3:16:43 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
"dont pick on me's 'dont trifle, dont stifle me' is a good part. I wouldnt mind seeing that and how long either.

im talking about the 01.03.02 version of broken arrows, also. 01.04.02 was totally different and atrocious. "

its all about dont pick on me, broken arrows (1/3/02 version with better intro), how long & mr.taxman (older version with bgv)... broken arrows needs a better ending..i think thats what killed it..it sounds like he didnt know where to go from there so he just ended it. Mr. Taxman has a "green" feel but with a better solo... and dont pick on me i hated at first.. but when they added the new gutiar parts and bgv's...it grew on me quick ... YRAH!!!

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 62
(3/20/02 3:19:27 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
mr taxman has a good melody but in my opinion needs complete lyrical restructure.

SkyBlue523202
VIRGIN MODERATOR
Posts: 123
(3/20/02 3:20:52 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Why am I the only one who is obsessed with "So Low"?(EDIT: I just saw jkam beat me to the mentioning of the song) I don't know why no one here talks about it, but it's my favorite song out of all the demos combined. (ESPECIALLY the REVERB version.)

The original "high up above"... fricken amazing. It should be played that way or no way.

In broken arrows... when Ace sings out "baby don't you know..." you can't say you don't enjoy it. The line, "love canopy of dreams" -I don't know how exactly Ace made this so cheesy yet such a memorable line.

I liked the dawn in concert- I never got the same feeling from the demos.

I don't know what it is about "don't pick on me" but I can't figure out if I like it or not. Does anyone here like it ... or know what the blank in "pick up me(my?) _____ for free" is? I thought it was "donuts."

"and when I come down her BIG CHIP captures me." I can't believe I was such an idiot to think it was "picture captures me." WTF

I know I may get flamed for this one... but I've always had a love for Mr. Taxman.

Edited by: SkyBlue523202 at: 3/20/02 6:22:43 pm
TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 64
(3/20/02 3:24:46 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Ive never liked high up above.
It does sound like donuts.
But the other part is 'big chips,' because the song was renamed that, and not picture.
At least I think.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 37
(3/20/02 3:26:46 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I like the riff in The Dawn but I don't really think it's worth bringing the song back just for that. Maybe just work the riff into another song...

I really really hope that Seafaring Jamb comes back, either as a Maladroit b-side or on V. The solo rocks, and I actually really like the lyrics too.

Weezerphile
Registered User
Posts: 74
(3/20/02 3:26:53 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I think people's negative opinions 'Broken Arrows' would really have changed if it was taken just a little further through the recording process. With a little polishing it could be great.

'So Low' is, in my opinion, easily one of the best Weezer songs since Green, and should definitely be brought back. I actually think it could be a very successful single.


Rivers' really went through a little phase of writing....

293 Do You Want Me To Stay?
294 Faith In The Light
295 So Low
296 How Long?
297 Broken Arrows

scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 11
(3/20/02 3:28:25 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten

So Low was one of the most developed songs even in its early stage. Im not sure why it didn't make it. It had one of the best choruses of the bunch.

The keyboard version of High Up Above reminded me of "old" weezer. I miss that song.

wherewasmymind
Registered User
Posts: 196
(3/20/02 3:31:06 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
"The Dawn" is incredible, one of their all time bests. Its effect on the crowd as an opener is amazing. Great, great song.

"Broken Arrows" strikes me as pretty greenish, not quite up to par with most of the new songs. The "it's a love canopy of dreams and broken arrows" line, IS very memoriable. Good line, but the song itself is kind of meh to me. Not terrible.

Other songs I think shouldn't be left behind: We Go Together (with some lyric reworking, maybe), Don't Pick on Me, So Low, and Sandwiches Time (at least keep the chord pattern... you can ditch the falsetto and weird lyrics if it helps).

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 65
(3/20/02 3:31:07 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I dont know how in the hell keyboard high up above reminds you of old weezer! I thought it was completely different.

As for a riff not worth bringing back, caribooo, burndt jamb turned into an amazing song from a little riff.

Bayemon
Registered User
Posts: 36
(3/20/02 3:33:14 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I always liked the dawn. Though It seemed to me to need a little more after the climax... it starts rocking and then just drifts off into nothingness.. that riff is awesome though. Never really cared for broken arrows...

I really like change the world and living without you.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 38
(3/20/02 3:34:04 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I'm not saying the riff should be forgotten. I'm saying I was less than impressed with the song as a whole, so unless they change the song around a lot, they should let The Dawn go but reuse the riff somewhere else.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 66
(3/20/02 3:37:50 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Living without you made it all the way to the end and was a sad cut.

grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 144
(3/20/02 3:38:01 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
yes, so low is a GOOD song...the chorus is one of my favorites of the new stuff...the music is just fantastic...i'd like to hear it recorded again...with the vocals we've been hearing lately...

Weezerphile
Registered User
Posts: 77
(3/20/02 3:40:11 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I agree about 'So Low' sounding well developed since day one. It was the same with 'Living Without You' and 'Do You Want Me To Stay?'.


And 'The Dawn'? Yes it really rules. But yes, it still needs to lose the Nerf Herder rip-off ending.

Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 79
(3/20/02 3:41:53 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
So Low, We Go Together, the Dawn, and How Long? all need to come back at some point. the rest of the maladroit demos can die a quiet death

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 22
(3/20/02 3:44:55 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
For the most part I don't like high up above...,however, I really like the guitar parts to that song.

Bree Van Bri
Registered User
Posts: 27
(3/20/02 3:45:05 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I guess Sandwiches Time is gone forever, too?

scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 12
(3/20/02 3:46:09 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
TooLoud It reminds me of old weezer because it is such a melody based song and contains what I feel to be a very strong one. To me that is Weezer is or at least was about. The melodies.

wherewasmymind
Registered User
Posts: 199
(3/20/02 3:48:23 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I forgot about How Long?... another great song.

jon7572
Registered User
Posts: 6
(3/20/02 3:49:06 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The two songs I would love to see come back for V are So Low and change the world. Though theyre completely different, I always felt like those 2 songs had something special to them.

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/20/02 3:51:53 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Sandwiches time... yeah I don't think that one is coming back.... unless they play it live for fun.

eversogood
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/20/02 3:54:01 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Quote:
skyblue3051380583150 said : i don't know what it is about "don't pick on me" but I can't figure out if I like it or not. Does anyone here like it ... or know what the blank in "pick up me(my?) _____ for free" is? I thought it was "donuts." Again, another great line in that song, "and when I come down her picture captures me." I thought that was really rad- not too cheesy.

I know I may get flamed for this one... but I've always had a love for Mr. Taxman.



i believe it was donuts..that was my favorite line! lol.. i pick up my donuts for free? wtf? i love it! and he actually says "when i come down her big chip captures me" ... remember it was called big chip at one time.. or maybe i could be way off and thats just during the chorus.. and i wont flame ya..i loved mr. taxman too (with the backup vocals!)

Honkey Doorie
Registered User
Posts: 76
(3/20/02 4:01:06 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
with a little work, i think broken arrows could be one of the best weezer songs since they came back...also so low ruled, it is ashamed they didn't even attempt it for maladroit...

BottleOBlues
Registered User
Posts: 39
(3/20/02 4:02:28 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i'll use this post to share some views on the unused songs so far. I don't think i've done that for the non maladroit songs. I guess this is my correspondence. These are in response to the latest versions available.


-dawn needs to be scrapped. The riff can be recycled and used better within another song as a bridge to an extended jam or something.
-Broken Arrows and Seafaring Jam- can fade away as far as i'm concerned.
-Cygnus X1- has potential with the right lyrics.
-How Long- has a lot of potential. Strange how it sounds like STP.
-Porcupine- has a part or two that needs to be transplanted to a other songs but overall needs to be set aside.(most of the lyrics eat it)
-Saturday Night- sucks it big time and is boring as hell.
-Sandwiches time- is cool/quirky but doesn't need to be on an album, perhaps ep or single.
-Ain't Got Much Time-from 1-6-2002 would kick a lot of ass if they re-did it. I don't even remember when this song came about but it rules. Its just a little uninspired here. If it was redone and had a solo upgrade and emotion it would probably be a fav. Good Bass lines.
-Listen Up has potential but that probably won't be realized.
-Mr. Taxman-Gay lyrics/guitar, good drum and bass.
-Zep Jamb-More Gay lyrics , Good Groove song. Nice Solo.
-We Go Together-Has some potential.
-Living Without You-Great Harmony parts. I like this song alright.
-Acapulco-Kinda weak but also kinda refreshing to hear something different.
-Serendipity-Nice, I like this a lot but way to short. Would be good on Maladroit.
-Better Off Alone(cover)- Haven't heard the original but this isn't to bad actually. Interesting, i'd like to hear other cuts.
-Big Chip/Don't Pick on Me-Nothing about this song is exciting or interesting.
-I Wanna Know-Scrap This!
-So Low-One of the Best out of the post green era song. bring this back then revamp it. Chorus is great.
-Cryin and Lonely-Nice bass line. can't hear the guitar and vox very well.
-New Joint(clip)-Like what i hear


-Songs that must come back because they rule: Hot Tub, Wanda, 1000 Years, Long Time Sunshine, Sheila Can Do It, Think About, O Girl, Superstar(thanks), Modern Dukes(thanks), Too Late To Try, Nutsack Song.

yes i'm aware that some of these are river's solo show songs

Edited by: BottleOBlues at: 3/20/02 4:16:54 pm
FabFiveFreddy
Registered User
Posts: 6
(3/20/02 4:03:00 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I really like how rivers sings in broken arrows. of course, I'm still hoping that ain't got much time will make its glorious return.

mikeweezer21
Registered User
Posts: 24
(3/20/02 4:03:12 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
For a while, I thought that donuts line was "I pick up my donuts and brie"...

longtimesunshine
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/20/02 4:05:29 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
What about How Long? Out of all the maladriot demos, this song actually had a great change of pace right in the middle of the song. the lyrics lacked though, i mean. "two plus two equals me and you" isn't exactly rock.

agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 22
(3/20/02 4:09:34 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I liked the live versions we got of The Dawn. Personally I think it would be best as a live-only song.
Broken Arrows never really did much for me.
How Long, Living Without You, and Sandwiches Time are the songs I would like to see on albums.

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 75
(3/20/02 4:17:53 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I'd like to see How Long, Broken Arrows and So Low again. The riff from The Dawn should be used either in another song or they should keep the whole song.

ElDarklord
Registered User
Posts: 18
(3/20/02 4:23:55 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Yeah, Broken Arrows needs to come back along with So Low. Longtime Sunshine would be awesome also but I doubt we would ever see anything like that.

BloodinthestreetS
Registered User
Posts: 28
(3/20/02 4:28:01 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I miss So Low. On the other hand, Im not as big a fan of How Long as I once was. The more and more I listen to it, the more it sounds like a polished green song in the mold of Possibilities.

starby
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/20/02 4:34:00 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I also miss how long just because it has an amazing chorus. it kind of reminds me of a theme song or something. but true the lyrics are pretty lame, especially the 'i did it again did it again did it for you". man if that's not corny...

SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 63
(3/20/02 4:39:19 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i dont think he should revisit the maladroit rejects. They were rejects for a reason even though some songs were pretty good. Id rather hear new songs and the new direction he takes rather than revise old songs, which we heard a million times, to fit the new style.

JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 105
(3/20/02 4:39:31 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I wonder if Broken Arrows intentionally shared some lyrics with 1,000 Years...
1000 years: "Every hour of every day, she'll await for you.."
BA: "Every hour... every day.."

maybe im overanalyzing

jade
Registered User
Posts: 28
(3/20/02 4:46:45 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I sort of agree with SpaceGhost, but at the same time it's sad to see songs that had such potential not reach it and be scrapped.

I'd like to see How Long? come back, and Broken Arrows could rock with some work.

MerkinMuffley
Registered User
Posts: 136
(3/20/02 4:59:47 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
need to make comeback:
1) Broken Arrows - easily best post-green song
2) Mr. Taxman (and it's "gay" lyrics) - the bluesy verse vocal part is among his best and the descending chords in the "that's what you get . . ." line are badass
3) How Long
4) Ain't Got Much Time - not a big fan of the verse...maybe recycle the rest.... cut and paste, like the contrived blue stuff.


Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 3/20/02 5:04:51 pm
bathroommonkey
Registered User
Posts: 31
(3/20/02 5:04:52 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
change the world, now there is a song that i miss. one of the last versions that we got had the best opening, rocken! i just really enjoyed that song.

also hope that broken arrows and how long? and dipidy.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 68
(3/20/02 5:09:42 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
scratchy that's all weezer has been about since the green album (the melodies).

and serendipity was on ace's playlist, bathroommonkey, so it looks like youre in luck...

jon7572
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/20/02 5:16:01 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
yea, so was change the world! While both songs rock, I dont think either will make the actual album.

indyatom
Registered User
Posts: 62
(3/20/02 5:23:30 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
the dawn rocks
the intro is absolutely killer, easyly the best of this era... the song should without a doubt be brought back. I immagine its bad ass live...especially when the intro stops and the little power chord progression comes in, you have to get excited when you hear that live

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 254
(3/20/02 5:24:38 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
"The Dawn" was another one of those structurally awkward songs that Rivers wrote(which is weird considering his desire to keep within the bounds of perfect pop song structures), but if it was the very first track on an album it would be totally cool opener...just like it was an awesome live opener. It's not really an actual 'song', but it could be a cool 'thing' to put at the beginning of a record, just as a quick introduction. It doesn't belong anywhere else on an album though... it has to be #1.

I LOVE the weird little guitar riff, and the few vocals that ARE there sound really cool.

phil collins band
Registered User
Posts: 11
(3/20/02 5:29:52 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The Dawn was an awesome song, and the chorus for How Long was the closest thing to old school weezer yet. They both need to be on Album 5. I agree with TLS that The Dawn has to be the first song, we've had two straight albums now with horrible openers, this would be a nice change of pace.

FFeJ and Raven
Registered User
Posts: 59
(3/20/02 5:31:56 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Although the verse lyrics blew, I love So Low. It's my favorite of the recent songs.

We Go Together was great until the lyrics and solo got changed for the Maladroit demo. I love the reverb "woo oo woo" bgv.

How Long I think is just really solid and really good.

The rest (that I remember) are all okay/good/all right but not something that stands out.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 71
(3/20/02 5:33:04 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
yes, the dawn as it is right now, should be an opener. It contends with my name is jonas in opener category.

but if this were to become an album song, if the process goes like maladroit, it will probably be longer with different lyrics.

kustomboy
Registered User
Posts: 14
(3/20/02 5:35:47 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I thought The Dawn was gonna be a good solid opener (alot better the gigolo) for maladroit. I wasn't hip with Broken Arrows right away but i've fallen in love with the song recently. One of the best non-maladroit tunes recorded for the record. So Low I thought was gonna be in the front running for Maladroit too, but that didn't happen. And Living Without You deserves to be on the record more than crap like Possiblities, Love Explosion, and American Gigolo. I can see where The Dawn would have taken the rock vibe down a notch, but Living Without You, Broken Arrows and So Low would have kept up their end of the rock spectrum.

silversun
Registered User
Posts: 10
(3/20/02 5:37:50 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
for me the ideal situation would be a resurrection of mr taxman, so low and how long... i agree with the people who mentioned so low -- i have always thought that so low had something special that few of the other new ones have

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 74
(3/20/02 5:38:01 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Possibilities has come a long way, give it some credit at least.

davealmost
Registered User
Posts: 3
(3/20/02 5:39:21 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
theres not a chance the dawn should be the opener. where as jonas comes out with great energy, the dawn is like i do. the crowd is kinda like ok, now what? no excitement. and the kids want excitement.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 76
(3/20/02 5:41:22 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
the dawn has way more energy than i do.
what do you mean should be the opener? to the fifth album?

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 15
(3/20/02 5:49:35 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i know it's just discussion, but frankly, i don't think it would be good to keep going back to old songs and getting stuck in the past. i'm kinda concerned they keep going back to the summer songs rivers called "an experiment in sucking." if we want the band to make incredible music again, they have to keep cranking out new songs and styles, instead of trying to "fix" old songs.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 257
(3/20/02 5:52:06 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
"The Dawn" is a different kind of opener. It has all these dynamic peaks and valleys before it reaches the rocking climax at the end. I think it has a neat hypnotic quality, and would make an interesting opener. It wouldn't be an in your face opener...just a subtle piece that grabs you and gets you excited for what's to come on the rest of the album.

I think "I Do" actually would have made an awesome opener for Green. It would have the same effect as "Doll" by the Foo Fighters on The Colour and the Shape.

A short, slow, sappy song right before the drum intro to "Don't Let Go" would have been super cool.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 80
(3/20/02 5:53:52 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
its funny how everyone begged for the summer songs to be released on an album when the green album came out because those were 'real songs' and now that they have been theres still gripe.

anything is a lose-lose situation for the band.

SandwichesTime
FEMALE
Posts: 35
(3/20/02 6:03:43 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
shiiit, i actually agree with lonely surfer on something for once
exactly, about the dawn, it's not really a 'song' but would be an awesome intro on an album.
anyone else think that the dawn is a nietzsche reference? or am i the last to think this?

sandwiches time: good song, i don't need to see it on any album though. certainly not.
broken arrows: good, has a trifle of cheese, but good
how long: i appreciate this song a lot, and it contrasts to most of the others well. organ=great

the rest is all noise

thisfallingangel
Registered User
Posts: 4
(3/20/02 6:04:36 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
i'm kinda concerned they keep going back to the summer songs rivers called "an experiment in sucking."

but look how some of the songs have changed over the last couple months as far as lyrics go...love explosion is one example (i know it doesnt go as far back as the summer songs) but those summer songs always have the potential to change as well.

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 83
(3/20/02 6:06:45 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
kodos, why not bring back songs we've heard that have potential to be great? when weezer tries different styles, most people shit on it anyway (the green album, anyone?)

the citizen of wen
Registered User
Posts: 87
(3/20/02 6:31:12 pm)
SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
ok, now i'm pissed.
somebody says:
"Saturday Night- sucks it big time and is boring as hell."
and NOBODY corrects him?! Saturday Night has grown on me more than any of these other lame-riff-to-vanilla-power-chord-chorus songs has. it was cool way back when they demoed it in DC, and got even more rocking when they worked on it most recently.
That song and Burnt Jamb were the songs that made me think weezer had a shot at coming back full-force with awesome, fun songs. It sounded like weezer was about to record a really good, really fun "party" album, as lighthearted as a lot of blue seemed to be.
But then this really uninspired, shitty phase happened and we got frankenstein crap like "the dawn" and the absolutely godawful "change the world". And then some really straightahead, pop-punk junk like "Taxman" and "Possibilities" that, to me, are just as boring (but not quite as reprehensible). Argh. It's a wonder Maladroit is listenable at all.
Anyways. LONG LIVE SATURDAY NIGHT.

Edited by: the citizen of wen at: 3/20/02 6:43:34 pm
TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 85
(3/20/02 6:38:32 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
saturday night from the may 2001 sessions were great.
the maladroit session version - not so great. it turned all dark.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 190
(3/20/02 6:39:53 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
sandwiches you're rad

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 87
(3/20/02 6:41:28 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
it is a nietzsche reference?

Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 501
(3/20/02 6:42:55 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
Please stop trying to pick up chicks, sir.

This is embarassing for all of us.

indyatom
Registered User
Posts: 63
(3/20/02 6:43:49 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
i have grown to love saturday night too. i love the octave up power chord. the only thing i would change is maybe be the bass line, on the last verson of this song it was pretty much a quarter note follow of the melody. Not that there is anythign wrong with that, there are alot great songs like that (most of pinkerton) but i think that this song would be alot more fun if it had a different bass line.

the citizen of wen
Registered User
Posts: 88
(3/20/02 6:46:10 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
TooLoud - i liked the maladroit session Sat. Night as well. it just sounded more rocking, like take control's revamp did.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 40
(3/20/02 6:50:36 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
I actually preferred the DC demo of the song...they just sounded like they had so much more energy.

indyatom
Registered User
Posts: 64
(3/20/02 6:52:36 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
did anyone else like "ain't got much time" ?

TooLoudTurnItDown
Registered User
Posts: 88
(3/20/02 6:55:22 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
dc demo was superior, yes.

indyatom
Registered User
Posts: 65
(3/20/02 6:56:36 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
i agree

the citizen of wen
Registered User
Posts: 90
(3/20/02 6:58:31 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
all those DC demos were standouts (except maybe zep song). i would have loved to hear them continue working on a sound like that.

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 107
(3/20/02 7:21:09 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
I would like to see Dawn used as the opener for Maladroit. It could still be added. I have one cd where if you press rewind when you first start playing it, the track numbers go negative and it goes into a hidden intro.

I could be done.

Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 111
(3/20/02 7:27:48 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
yes, bring The Dawn back. somehow.

thisfallingangel
Registered User
Posts: 7
(3/20/02 7:58:02 pm)
Re: SATURDAY NIGHT!!!!
99er what cd was that? i cant remember...ack! i used to have it too.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 113
(3/20/02 8:01:03 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I liked the solo in "Listen Up" much more than the one in "Seafaring Jamb".

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 105
(3/20/02 8:03:19 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
Agreed about the DC demos, I still think that version of Burndt Jamb is the best I've heard. Maybe the final mix will change my mind, but I think the do do do's fit the mood of the song perfectly.

jade
Registered User
Posts: 30
(3/20/02 8:09:48 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I agree. I prefer the DC version of Burndt Jamb as well...I liked the song better without the lyrics, just the doo's. I think they just fit better. I miss the simplicity of the doo's.

WeezBrit
Registered User
Posts: 31
(3/20/02 8:20:12 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I liked the old version of Jamb live better than the D.C. demo. The way they have it now is the way it is supposed to be in my opinon.

zen brain
Registered User
Posts: 107
(3/20/02 8:20:59 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
It's not necessarily a simplistic matter for me, but rather what fits with the song. It would be a great song for certain recreational activities like the title suggests, and I think the doooo's fit that atmosphere, gave it the laid back feel. It's still one of my favorites on Maladroit, just not nearly as good as the DC demo.

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 108
(3/20/02 8:21:58 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The cd was Less than Jake, Losing Streak.

Brown Cow
Registered User
Posts: 19
(3/20/02 8:22:05 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
That negative time sounds awesome. "The Dawn" could be a somewhat hidden track inbetween two songs, shit, the Beastie Boys do it all the time.

Super NintenDEN
Registered User
Posts: 46
(3/20/02 8:22:58 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
how can everyone prefer the dc versions of anything? the dc version of any song is worse than the next time they recorded it. that didnt make much sense, i'm lame.
but anyways, i'm sure it has a lot to do with the bassist at the time. scott brings a lot to the band.

asirem
Registered User
Posts: 58
(3/20/02 8:29:18 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
I absolutely loved broken arrows. Living With Out You was by far my favorite demo, it was sad to see them go.

GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 81
(3/20/02 8:44:27 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
The more I think about songs that got cut for other things (dating back years, not just to the summer) the more and more songs I'd like to see again.

-The Dawn :it's not a full song, but i love at how some live shows, he'd say 'good morning' afterwards

-So Low- realized this was a great song when i first heard it at detroit in sept. -my friend and i just turned to each other and gave each other a thumbs up

-Saturday Night- thought the pre-metal version sounded better, but metal version had better lyrics.

-I wanna know- great song, but can anyone figure out some of the lyrics. I mean, i have:

"i wanna know
which way you go
cause there's a million ways to flow
and there's a million other ways to pay your rent
tuckus (?) on the side is heaven sent
giblets (?) never run away
they come for free"

either i'm on crack, or geez...i must be on crack

Ahmed Malik
fucking anime queen
Posts: 87
(3/20/02 8:58:08 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
"saturday night" is awesome, as was "listen up". "i wanna know" sucks balls.

longtimesunshine
Registered User
Posts: 5
(3/20/02 9:06:18 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
the intro to the dc. saturday night was one of the best post-@#%$ moments, in my opinion. listen up had a great chill feel to it. with that said i doubt we'll ever see these songs again. perhaps thats a good thing

Ahmed Malik
fucking anime queen
Posts: 89
(3/20/02 9:09:27 pm)
Re: gone but not forgotten
dc saturday night sucks compared to the toronto version. toronto was 100X better. it's funny how people forget such things....

Page 1 2 3 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>


Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index