|
Author
|
Comment
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 86
(5/4/02 10:36:56 pm)
Reply
|
I am gay.
details magazine - (june issue) - "Rivers and crew are back, tossing a few Sabbath riffs into their Sugar Pops. Sure, it sounds exactly like the last album. But when's the last time you heard "Hash Pipe" and didn't smile?"
Exactly like the last album? Was this reviewer actually listening to Maladroit?
Edited by: Queero McGayguy at: 5/4/02 11:05:13 pm
|
Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 263
(5/4/02 10:38:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
Maybe the reviewer accidentally bought the green album twice.
|
Funkathrusta
Registered User
Posts: 201
(5/4/02 10:56:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
haha.
|
BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 149
(5/4/02 11:02:57 pm)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
i remember a review said that o girlfriend was the summer song o girl
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 87
(5/4/02 11:04:08 pm)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
Also linked from the maladroit big page:
www.angelfire.com/indie/t...weezer.htm
Even though this reviewer took a decidedly personal tack with their writing style, at least it's not the stereotypical hack review. I agree that Burndt Jamb and D&D are two standouts but I disagree that Fall Together is tripe. Also, I think the idea of Pinkerton fans being less likely to have abandoned ship might be an overstatement. Although there is more here for them to like than on TGA, I still don't think they would have been that much more enthusiastic if it had been released in place of Green.
The point about fans being too bitter to take a listen to Maladroit may be true but I think it's ridiculous. I can't understand why a fan of a band wouldn't give them a second chance, or even a third chance, when a previous release was an album worth notice. It's like a director whose work you enjoy. If they make a crappy movie, it doesn't mean all of their following work will continue to suck. A misstep is allowed and any band (or songwriter like Rivers) who can put out two albums like Blue and Pinkerton has a real likelihood of revisiting critical success in the future. Is this faith unwarranted?
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 268
(5/5/02 12:33:58 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
a great album will conquer all naysayers
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 518
(5/5/02 12:36:00 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
Chocolate starfish and the hot dog flavored water is proof of that
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 90
(5/5/02 1:09:50 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
"a great album will conquer all naysayers"
Well, it should. so here's to conquering. What sucks is when an album is great and critical praise isn't enough, with chart position and commercial success becoming the focus. It could be my imagination but it seemed that with the popularity of TGA and the buzz/press regarding Maladroit, the praise in hindsight for previous =w= output started coming from quarters that had given less than stellar reviews in the not so distant past. Fair weather reviewers suck.
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 528
(5/5/02 1:13:01 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
I think roofrat killed lonely surfer in order to take his place
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 270
(5/5/02 1:13:24 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
yeah, you guys don't remember but we go dissed HARD on the first two records
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 271
(5/5/02 1:19:27 am)
Reply
|
Re: this evening's heterosexual topic
it's pretty fucked up the way the reviews change over the years.
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 250
(5/5/02 1:19:53 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I don't really think critics have any say in how good a record is. A lot of records that are considered @#%$ now were panned by critics. You can review a movie.. movies are easier to judge as being good or shit, but it's a much more difficult thing to do with a record. It's a matter of taste.
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 531
(5/5/02 1:23:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
RF:
I take offense to your movie comment. Yes, they can be easier to judge sometimes, but not always. Two prime examples are Eyes Wide Shut and AI. Two heavily debated films, that will be looked upon as classics in the future....even with the flawa they have.
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 252
(5/5/02 1:26:28 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
Didn't say easy, I said easier.
For example: Pearl Harbor. Good or shit? EASY.
Movies like Eyes Wide Shut and AI are more difficult, and have more to do with taste.
AI was thirty minutes too long.
|
ElDarklord
Registered User
Posts: 33
(5/5/02 1:53:37 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
Amen Real Frogs
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 254
(5/5/02 1:58:57 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
But really, look at the albums that are now considered c.lassic..
Nevermind.. who gave that a shining review in '91?
Rolling Stone panned all the Led Zeppelin albums when they came out.. I'm not a Zeppelin fan, but those are c.lassic albums, right?
Meanwhile, Andrew W.K. - FOUR STARS
Edited by: Real Frogs at: 5/5/02 1:59:54 am
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 536
(5/5/02 1:59:35 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
Hey, let's talk about AI because I'm stupid.
Edited by: Queero McGayguy at: 5/5/02 9:36:21 am
|
ElDarklord
Registered User
Posts: 35
(5/5/02 2:11:59 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I agree with the execution comment on the last 30 mins of A.I. I don't actually dislike the last 30 mins entirely, just some parts that were poorly executed. There are other instances in Spielberg movies where I feel the same way about certain parts or scenes (like the old man at the veteran's graveyard with his family scenes, which serve as bookends to Saving Private Ryan) .....poor execution. I liked A.I for the most part and enjoyed SPR. My comment was mainly aimed at Pearl Harbor. Michael Bay represents everything that is wrong with Hollywood Movies today, and this, I say with much conviction.
|
Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 196
(5/5/02 2:59:34 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I remember Ace, no one can forget the RollingStone Pinkerton review.
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 256
(5/5/02 3:13:51 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
Yes, Rolling Stone, the fucking paradigm of musical criticism.
But you're wrong. Pinkerton got three stars in the initial review from the magazine.. not the review it should have been, but not a pan like it would be later. Fucking mercurial bitches.
|
the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 135
(5/5/02 4:28:34 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
Andrew W.K. earned each of those 4 stars by partying harder on every second of his album than any of us will ever party even if you add up all the partying we'll ever do.
I will defend Andrew W.K. to the death.
Edited by: the citizen of wen at: 5/5/02 4:35:55 am
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 78
(5/5/02 4:59:51 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I'm gay. Yeah.
Edited by: Queero McGayguy at: 5/5/02 9:37:00 am
|
Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 197
(5/5/02 10:30:16 am)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I hope your joking about W.K. getting 4 stars?
|
skratchaholik
Registered User
Posts: 44
(5/5/02 12:25:15 pm)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
anyone getting a push like WK from the start from MTV and mass media will get a 4 star review, guaranteed.
|
kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 57
(5/5/02 12:55:36 pm)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
i know p.ink got slammed by many a critic, but blue? I don't think i've ever seen a review below 3 stars or 7/10...not by any "major" source. somebody refresh my memory. it did however set a new record for the use of the words: kitsch, jangly, pop rock, and melodic in a paragraph.
Edited by: kodos88 at: 5/5/02 12:56:46 pm
|
Real Frogs
Pimpin' ain't easy.
Posts: 257
(5/5/02 1:01:15 pm)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
No, I'm not kidding.
I don't think I've ever seen a review of Blue right off..
|
catch624
Registered User
Posts: 63
(5/5/02 1:12:22 pm)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
I agree that it just takes time to recognize classics of all kinds. And records or movies that are immediately critically acclaimed, hailed as classics---instant classics if you will--usually don't hold up.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 266
(5/5/02 6:02:03 pm)
Reply
|
Re: I am gay.
led zeppelin was seen by critics as shitty back in the day.
|