← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Blender Maladroit review
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
DH Crasher
Registered User
Posts: 13
(5/8/02 6:06:35 pm)
Reply
Blender Maladroit review
this is a full-page featured review of the month:

STORM WARNING
Weezer make a thuderous @#%$-pop masterpiece.
But it's hardly all sunshine.

Weezer. Maladroit. *** out of 5 stars

In eight years, the time it took the Beatles to get from the Cavern Club to the White Album, Weezer's Rivers Cuomo has offered only one intimate detail: an obsession with Asian women., revealed on "El Scorcho" and "Across the Sea," from 1996's Pinkerton. In an age of confession, he's an aloof, withdrawn rock star, Howard Hughes with a Kiss fetish.

Such solitude and sexual frustration define Maladroit, Weezer's fourth album, and first since the bona fide Weezer explosion of '01. Judging by the popularity of Weezer (known to the fans as the Green Album), Cuomo represents white America's latest archetype. Gifted, misanthropic, stiff with anxiety behind mask-like eyeglasses, he has probably spent half his life immersed in the diverting isolation of computers and mass media.

On the face of it, Weezer are one of rock's best bands: a great rhythm sectio, an uncluttered, sonically brilliant wallop, a perfect multitracked, distorted guitar sound and an iconic lead singer. But Cuomo's a clever student who repeats the lessons of his masters: the unrepentant spew of young Elvis Costello, the Pixies' fuzzed-up fragments of surf-rock and early p-unk, the dark pop of the Buzzcocks. Unlike his forbears, though, Cuomo rarely brings anything new to the music.

Still for an idealistic generation of emocore fans who cherishpurity and vulnerability, Cuomo is a hero, their Kurt Cobain. Alone among post Nirvana alternative acts, Weezer maintained a spot on rock radio stations, sounding boyish and retro beside the growling, macho @#%$-rock of Limp Bizkit and Korn.

Back in 1996, Pinkerton explored the "dark side" of Weezer, with a jabbing half-hour of aggressive, three-minute minor-key complaints about sexual insecurities. Maladroit is more of the same. In song after song on the new album, Cuomo gets mad at the girls the way comp-sci majors get mad at faulty software: viciously , imperiously and without fear of reprisal.

As always, Cumo can write a tight pop song: The melodic hooks of "Dope Nose" and "Burndt Jamb" thrill with familiriaty, echoing Free's "All Right Now" and George Benson's "Breezin'", respectively. This loevly pop-p-unk sounds incredible. But all that pleasure comes in the service of meanness, pointed everywhere-- even, on the song "Space Rock," in the direction of Weezer's fans: "They know it all/ And they're pinning you to boards/ It's a game/ And you'll play/ But you can't have fun/ When all they do is say/ Lies."

None of this seems accidental. The album's first track is called "American Gigolo," the title of a 1980 movie about a man whose job givingpleasure so depletes his energies that he can't experience pleasure himself. Cuomo's gigolo, though, can't even GIVE it. "If you want me," he taunts in the chorus, "you can't have me/ If you hate this/ I can't blame you/ 'Cause I'm hurting/ So I'll flame you."

This feels like a new stage in post-p-unk rock: beyond Nihilism, beyond rebellion, into cold emotional blankness. First Cuomo appears to be an insecure, lovelorn guy who's nothing without the millions of teenagers who adore him; then he delights in lashing out at his big, avid audience.

With impressive consistency, these 13 songs achieve formal perfection. There's one catchy riff for verses, another for choruses, another of rthe middle-eight sections , but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected. Maladroit feels like a bloodless quest to write the perfect song. Apply the creative class test to it: Yeah, these songs are all about girls, but what are they about? Craft. Which is Rivers Cuomo's one true love. -- Ben Ratliff

mrtpitiesfools
FUCK.
Posts: 220
(5/8/02 6:13:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
Ehhh that reviewer forgot to point out that most of the lyrics are generic. They don't hold as much meaning as the reviewer gives them. As far as lashing out at his fans, I think that Rivers is more attacking the label and the music outlets, liek MTV, especially in Space Rock. Oh well, decent review nonetheless.

DH Crasher
Registered User
Posts: 14
(5/8/02 6:18:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
also has blurbs "Rivers Cuomo's Currently Listening: Jay-Z The Blueprint and Stevie RAy Vaughan and Double Trouble Live from Austin TX"

and "Weezer their life in CDS:
Weezer **** produced by Ric Ocasek, a bolt from the blue. The inscrutable mix of goofy humor (Undone), unarticulated anger (Buddy Holly) and pop hooks sold over 3million copies and culminated in the departure of Mattt Shharp/

Pinkerton *** with more minore-key pop-rock and feedback intros, and lots of declarations of insecurtiy, this pained howl didn't connect w/ radio and sold only 500,000 copies. Ignored by all but the band's faithful, Pinkerton has become a cherished cult record.

Weezer (TGA) **** songs honed to an even higher shine, with Ocasek back as producer, sending sales up to 1 million. Cuomo's powr pop had a new sentimentality verging on the saccharine and a vehemence verging on the cruel: the stubborn contradictory adult was emerging from behind the collgee boy glasses."

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 282
(5/8/02 6:27:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
maladroit is better than green, the stars for each should be reversed, but hey, it is blender, and they did give pinkerton only 3 stars.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 201
(5/8/02 9:45:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
I think the last two phrases are markedly true.

But in defense of weezer. Not all the songs are about girls: slob, dope nose, space rock. I think maladroit deserves more than three stars.

but I'm biased

Wilson

WeezerRawks
Registered User
Posts: 37
(5/8/02 10:44:52 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
I agree that the reviewer seemed to read into the lyrics a little bit more than he should, but it's also interesting how he nailed the "quest for the perfect song" idea, and he could tell that certain songs didn't flow that well. It's been discussed on here forever, but i wasn't sure how obvious that stuff was/is to the casual listener.

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 214
(5/8/02 10:51:38 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
"Maladroit feels like a bloodless quest to write the perfect song. Apply the creative class test to it: Yeah, these songs are all about girls, but what are they about? Craft. Which is Rivers Cuomo's one true love. -- Ben Ratliff

Wow, that guy really nailed it. Surprizing that someone who doesn't roam the boards regularly would catch somthing so subtle.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 280
(5/9/02 12:21:41 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
i've only said as much in about 100 interviews

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 202
(5/9/02 12:24:16 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
oh sure, make the reviewer look dumb.

yeh! you big rock star, you!

Wilson

Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 381
(5/9/02 12:31:41 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
"but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected."

That struck me as ironic.

grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 194
(5/9/02 12:35:27 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
uh ace, can you tell me what verschlagen means in german? seriously, i need to know

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 498
(5/9/02 12:57:58 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
What I don't get is the reviewer says this first:

"With impressive consistency, these 13 songs achieve formal perfection. There's one catchy riff for verses, another for choruses, another for the middle-eight sections..."

then this:

"but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected."


...make up your mind! If the songs supposably achieve 'formal perfection' than how is it that, at the same time, they often sound unlogical and poorly connected or whatever? I'm confused.







Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 79
(5/9/02 1:06:32 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
I think Real Frogs' comment beat you to the punch, TLS.

"Cuomo gets mad at the girls the way comp-sci majors get mad at faulty software: viciously , imperiously and without fear of reprisal."

What the hell.....?

weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 149
(5/9/02 1:15:45 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
doesn't the reviewer just mean as songs that achieve a level of perfection within eac h and every song... HOWever style and content wise (my guess) they have no connection as a cohesive album would like pinkerton.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 500
(5/9/02 1:40:08 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
"doesn't the reviewer just mean as songs that achieve a level of perfection within eac h and every song... HOWever style and content wise (my guess) they have no connection as a cohesive album would like pinkerton."

...that thought crossed my mind as well, and I was gonna' give the reviewer the benefit of the doubt at first...but if you read it closely, it's definitely a reference to the song structures, not the album as a whole.

Read the entire sentence:
"There's one catchy riff for verses, another for choruses, another for the middle-eight sections , but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected."

...they're talking about the riffs, verses, choruses, etc and using "Fall Together" as an example of how the parts in the songs often don't connect logically...all in the same sentence. If a period divided that sentence, it would take on a whole new meaning though(the meaning you suggested). However, that wasn't the writers intent. Why they intended to contradict themselves completely, I don't know.

Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/9/02 1:44:11 am
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 150
(5/9/02 1:47:30 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
american gigolo would be a better example for that rather than fall together! uhm...yeah I'm wrong, i was too lazy to look back. however, i still don't see the contradiction. explain.

"There's one catchy riff for verses, another for choruses, another for the middle-eight sections , but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected."

The different parts are "catchy" but in the song they don't seem to connect. ?

Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 80
(5/9/02 1:53:44 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
The part where they claim that "with impressive consistency, these 13 songs achieve formal perfection" seems to explain what they feel the riffs, choruses, etc. achieve--and that "formal perfection" seems to be entirely opposed to the idea that these pieces "have no logical reason to be connected."
This review stretches in so many ways to say something significant and impressive, it's rather funny. But then, that's kind of the archetypal music review these days, isn't it? Wonderful.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 502
(5/9/02 1:59:03 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
Right, I completely agree about the reviewer using "Fall Together" as an example of a Maladroit song that is unlogical...what?! If anything, it's the one song on the album that makes the most logical sense. Re-enforcing my point that the writer is completely confused and contradictory.

I also completely agree with your deciphering of the sentence.

"The different parts are "catchy" but in the song they don't seem to connect. ?"

...however, that does not change the fact that in the previous sentence the reviewer had just said that all the songs achieve formal perfection. A song that doesn't connect properly(regardless of how catchy each improperly-connected part may be) is still not a formally perfect song as they tried to suggest.

weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 152
(5/9/02 2:08:56 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
indeed. i guess maladroit was too much for the poor fellow. the album is a bit off though isn't it? there is just something about it that is intrinsically contradictory. i like that though, it is part of the weezer charm. but yes i get it now about why the writer is contradictory. we should write a letter!!!

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 138
(5/9/02 5:58:40 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
The statement that the parts of the song don't fit together fits to American Gigolo, not to Fall Together.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 271
(5/9/02 10:55:52 am)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
The only reason that he doesn't think it connects is because he thinks Maladroit is an emocore album.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 281
(5/9/02 12:19:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
if nothing else, IMO, maladroit's songs are formally perfect. that was my primary objective. all of the parts to any one song were written at the same time, in the same place, in the same creative thrust. i am fascinated that other listeners can hear these songs as pastiche-style compositions.

scratchy2213
Registered User
Posts: 17
(5/9/02 12:28:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
Just because they were written at the same time doesn't mean they sound like they were.

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 114
(5/9/02 12:49:29 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
"There's one catchy riff for verses, another for choruses, another for the middle-eight sections, but often, as in "Fall Together", they sound as though they were written in different places and have no logical reasons to be connected."

There are any number of reasons why a reviewer might say this, the most likely of which is that they haven't taken a good listen to the songs individually. If you listen to the entire album then try to formulate an opinion, it's probably hard to focus back on any one song and the impression overall might be more disjointed. Trying to get their copy in under the wire probably inspires complete crap in terms of real, valid impressions.

But maybe writing the music and lyrics in the same time and place isn't enough for the listener and only you as the writer can hear the connections and fluidity. Bringing it to the band and everyone putting their fingerprints on the song must make a difference and maybe that's what's being picked up on. Besides, for the songs that started off with different lyrics, or even no lyrics, I don't see how you can claim that they were completed in a single place/time. Not unless your writing style includes crafting variations from the start. It's interesting to consider the process.

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 61
(5/9/02 1:04:10 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
i think the only song that kinda feels like it was put together in pieces was american gigalo. It has that great chorus "I've seen this game before...", but the verses are a sharp contrast, and "clash" with the chorus. An abrupt feeling that probably made the author say what he did. I think that's partly why people haven't backed that song as much as any others.

zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE.
Who knew?

Posts: 225
(5/9/02 1:09:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
American Gigalo is supposed to have that contrast between the verses and chorus, I don't think it sounds put together at all. At first I didn't like this song at all, but the album version sounds awesome, good way to open the album.

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 62
(5/9/02 1:12:39 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
yeah, i know it's supposed to, but i'm just saying how the reviewer could listen to that song and come up with his conclusion.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 283
(5/9/02 1:14:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
zen brain is right. that "sharp contrast" arose naturally and was a compositional necessity, not the result of cramming together two unrelated parts.

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 279
(5/9/02 1:19:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
that contrast is my favorite part. i have a problem with the verses, but the "if you want me, you can't have me" part and the "i've seen this game before..." part rock.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 314
(5/9/02 1:22:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
the idea that a song should be written with one inspiration, in one sitting (and that this process is "natural") seems sorta romanticist (or e.mo) to me.

Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/9/02 1:26:17 pm
SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 112
(5/9/02 1:27:00 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
i agree but isnt the purpose of writing a song to capture the true emotion and feeling of the moment and using the song to express that to others? So writting it in one sitting with one inspirational driving force, however e.mo it may be, is what conveys the true meaning in the song

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 203
(5/9/02 1:33:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
I think the contrast in gigolo is necessary, as well. The song would be rather stagnant without it.

And I don't see writing things in one sitting as Romantic; I just see it as a compositional style. An emotion or a moment can be captured just as well when writing a song over the course of a week or month. Compositional time doesn't have anything to do with it.

Wilson

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 115
(5/9/02 1:35:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
seems like a sound way to capture a mood/feeling/intention for a song. and ace probably meant the musical composition, not the lyrics, when he referred to one place and time. that makes my above post grounds for ritual suicide but it'll have to be later, since i'm at work.

SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 113
(5/9/02 1:38:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
it might depend on the person too. I for one have trouble expressing myself so when something happens i like to capture the feelings i have right away so they are not lost.

Over time ones feelings tend to change and could cause a contrast in his or her composition but thats not the case here as ace already stated

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 63
(5/9/02 1:38:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Blender Maladroit review
I never doubted that it was natural and it necessary for the song. I just can understand how the reviewer heard it and came up with the conclusion that it was "unnatural" just because it seemed so different, though it wasn't of course.

Edit: addendum

Edited by: kodos88 at: 5/9/02 1:42:29 pm
<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index