|
Author
|
Comment
|
SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 257
(5/8/02 2:31:13 pm)
|
Just a thought.
Have any of you ever come to realize that Rivers will NEVER be able to write an album like TBA or Pinkerton again? By progressing and maturing mentally, one would think it would be impossible for him to produce an album sound like one or the other.
Musically, maybe- but wouldn't the emotion contained in both contribute to the musicality of each song?
How can we tell ourselves we want something that is past the human scope of possibility?
|
thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 75
(5/8/02 2:35:48 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
no I disagree... I think all these things happening now are because they are on a major label and when it's all said and done (OR) weezer know's it going to be their last album they'll make one for the fans that's what we want!.... ok I'm getting my hopes up... but I think ace still has got it!
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 1049
(5/8/02 2:41:08 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
He's lost it. Or most of it, at least.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 274
(5/8/02 2:48:06 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i don't really doubt his ability to write the kinds of songs we love, i think he just plain doesn't want to. he wants to write tight, structurally sound, pop-rock compositions. that's quite a contrast to something like pinkerton's loose, structurally hellish pop rock songs. i think he could go back to that sound and voice in a minute. the voice is just changing from singing from the gut to singing from the throat. but i'm not really sure if we can judge if the emotional weight would be the same. he's obviously a much different person now than he was when he wrote pinkerton and even blue. probably a much happier and in control of what's going on person. something like pinkerton won't happen again unless something god awful happens to the man, and even then i don't know if he'd write about it. and i wouldn't wish anything bad on the guy, so i'm just happy raking in the tracks he gives us.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 188
(5/8/02 2:59:50 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i couldn't agree more...i think the only thing keeping ace from writing/singing songs like the first two albums is ace...
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 297
(5/8/02 3:02:10 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i think the post-mala material sounds pretty good
|
thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 77
(5/8/02 3:02:17 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I don't think they'd ever go back to a pinkerton style sound with scott in the band.
edit: this doesn't mean I don't like scott though
Edited by: thenewaves at: 5/9/02 12:20:16 am
|
FabFiveFreddy
Registered User
Posts: 15
(5/8/02 3:06:54 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i'm curious. why do you say that about scott? from what i've read, it seems like he's into all kinds of music, and he's content with his role as thugged out bass player/backup singer.
|
Salvatore Paradise
Registered User
Posts: 207
(5/8/02 3:26:58 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Well, he was working on the melodies for those songs for years and years, through alot of varied, challenging circumstances that could inspire good lyrics. It's really hard to recreate that, especially within the confines of pop songs about love. It's nice to see some different styles and topics coming up, but I don't think it's possible to do what he did again.
|
Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 210
(5/8/02 4:12:44 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
As Rivers moves away from the "girl songs" as he put it, I think the structure of the songs will most likely begin to slowly morph away from the old too kind of naturally. I'm still crossing my fingers for the day Weezer starts to jam live, or on even a studio album. Ahhh I can dream can't I?
|
skratchaholik
Registered User
Posts: 57
(5/8/02 4:12:53 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
he can write another pinkerton...he just refuses to.
|
mcnellis
Registered User
Posts: 108
(5/8/02 4:33:24 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i think ace saying that he wishes the old fans to go away is pretty good sign that he will never do another "old" weezer record. he will do whatever makes him happy. i mean who wouldn't in his position?
|
scaldalupo
Registered User
Posts: 118
(5/8/02 4:42:15 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
He absolutely could write the same kind of thing he used to, but that's precisely what he doesn't want to write. If he didn't stop himself from going too crazy with the structure, took a little time off from touring and really tried to hone down some songs, I'm sure he could get songs that sound like Blue or Pinkerton. If that's what he wanted. Which he doesn't.
About the whole old voice/new voice thing, it seems to me that he's just singing the best way for the song. All the songs used to be tuned down, and now they're not, so he sings differently to go with that. Except for Slob, about which some people said, "Well at least he sings with the old voice on that one."
|
kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 58
(5/8/02 5:05:18 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
it's not always about going back to an old style, just progressing in style while keeping the quality of the music as high. blue to p.ink was a big change in style, but the quality was still top notch.
Can he make another album that sounds like blue or p.ink? Maybe not exactly, but for the most part, i think the answer is yes. I mean people can evolve and even get rusty, but someone as talented as rivers doesn't just lose his talent completely--despite what some say. If you can lose it all, it's not called talent. Either you think he has it somewhere in him and he's just not feelin' it (by choice or not), or you don't think he's talented. I'm gonna get slammed for that i know. Will he and can he or two different things.
Does he have it in him to make a album of that caliber with an even more different sound? we'll see. i'm sure we all want nothing more than to make all his critics look like idiots by making an album back on par with the first two.
|
squraish
Registered User
Posts: 110
(5/8/02 5:08:12 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
so what if he doesn't write an album like the others, even if he still can. he's done it, let him move on. or do you really want every album to sound the same? GAY.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 189
(5/8/02 5:11:31 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I think scott's presence is going to do a lot for the quality of the music we hear from now on...i doubt it's just by coincidence that he joined the band and then all of the sudden it seemed like everyone was excited about making music again...they've got the potential again to make some 'holy shit' music...maybe i'm wrong...that's just the impression i get
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 284
(5/8/02 6:50:42 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
The Pinkerton/Blue days of Rivers are over. He's no longer that 20 something with his eyes set to make music from his heart in an effort to reach rock-stardom. He's that 30 something that wants to just play and record as much as he can while constantly living the Rock Star life style.
|
Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 126
(5/8/02 7:45:43 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
squraish..i agree with you. i'm just going to keep along with weezer and stick with them, because i see their music as ever changing. variety is good. when you hear their music even nowadays, you can still tell it's weezer. i may be the only one on this board looking forward to Maladroit. i don't see why people can't move on. if you want e.mo listen to dashboard confessionals.
Edited by: Cathylala at: 5/8/02 7:55:02 pm
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 592
(5/8/02 7:46:38 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Nevermind. I like the taste of penus.
Edited by: Kelly Kapowski Loves Me at: 5/8/02 7:47:12 pm
|
Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 128
(5/8/02 7:49:45 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i'm invincible.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 36
(5/8/02 7:57:16 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i'm glad they are moving forward. They are finally learning how to ROCKwith scott's help, my only wish was that mala was heavier
edit: i decided i didnt want to get banned so i toned it down
Edited by: phoebecaulfield at: 5/8/02 8:08:12 pm
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 300
(5/8/02 7:59:46 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
phoebe is either drunk or set on sabotaging =w='s music.
edit: to clarify - i was suggesting that more metalish music was a bad direction to head in, rather than the blue-ish, upbeat Private Message/Prodigy Lover style
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/8/02 8:13:23 pm
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 37
(5/8/02 8:03:13 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i am neither, i just think take control is one of weezer's best songs ever
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 39
(5/8/02 8:18:22 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i disagree, i think there is a lot more energy and the guys really shine when they play more metalish music, i would like to see them head in that direction more
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 302
(5/8/02 8:19:13 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
again, phoebe is either drunk or set on sabotaging =w='s music.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 40
(5/8/02 8:24:08 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
again, how can you not appreciate the boys giving us the rock? the harder the better...
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 111
(5/8/02 8:25:18 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"the guys really shine when they play more metalish music"
do you mean in concert or in general?
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 41
(5/8/02 8:28:00 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
in concert, its good on album, but when they rip into heavy riffs live its enough to make you spontaneously orgasm
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 303
(5/8/02 8:29:23 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
conclusion: she's drunk and horny
|
SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 106
(5/8/02 8:32:00 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
she partied to hard and now is a drunken mess......the nose bleeding is inevitable at this point just give it a few min.
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 283
(5/8/02 8:33:10 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i don't think rivers has lost it, he's just kinda buried "it". I still expect great things from him.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 42
(5/8/02 8:40:16 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
....nothing like the taste of blood to keep you from passing out....
but for real, you can only take so much whiney music and then you just have to rock out
|
SandwichesTime
JUST A FEMALE
Posts: 90
(5/8/02 8:42:55 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
ya, i think he still has it. there's something to lead me to beleive that he still writes good songs, but...i dunno maybe we will never see them. if you honestly prefer any weezer music to the blue and @#%$ era things.....wow... you are deffinately different.
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 112
(5/8/02 8:46:50 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"i don't think rivers has lost it, he's just kinda buried "it"."
This is probably closer to the truth. Lost implies a lack of intent. He seems to be taking a different direction with intent and purpose. It doesn't mean he can't get back to the sort of creativity people complain of missing but it would suck if it was only to recreate the past. I find it disconcerting when he says he can "get that back", whether it's the voice or a particular sound. Not unless it means recapturing the drive and creativity and level of enjoyment that would infuse the music and entire process with what was motivating them during their earlier recording and touring.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 43
(5/8/02 8:48:27 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
mala is a more mature album than p.ink and blue combined, the band just "clicks" on it
|
SpaceGhostC2C
Registered User
Posts: 108
(5/8/02 8:49:30 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
he did it twice he can do it again i have no doubt about that but why would why would you want to keep doing the same thing for the rest of your life, thats just boring. Its good to explore new directions and styles. Thats what keeps life interesting.
|
SandwichesTime
JUST A FEMALE
Posts: 92
(5/8/02 8:55:01 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
eh nevermind
Edited by: SandwichesTime at: 5/8/02 11:17:26 pm
|
SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 258
(5/8/02 8:57:59 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
the word "it" has been overused in this thread.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 276
(5/8/02 9:12:55 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
the ironic thing is, during a pinkerton interview, rivers thought he'd taken the 3 minute pop song as far as it could go. instead, he took it in a totally different direction.
|
scaldalupo
Registered User
Posts: 119
(5/8/02 11:15:02 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
What people are saying makes it sound like he's no longer talented and can one day "get it back". He's still very talented, he just chooses to use that talent to make a different kind of music. Personally, I prefer the first two albums and the b-sides of that era because that is the kind of music I prefer and I think that that is what he does best. And he was the best at what he did. That's why so many people are pissed off that's not what he's doing now, correct?
They're currently still making very good music, it's just different. The most important thing to remember though is that Rivers is making the music he wants to make and is very proud of it, as he should be. He's not trying to make another Pinkerton and just failing every time.
I know this has all pretty much been said before and/or should go without saying, but it seems that some people still don't understand it.
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 144
(5/8/02 11:19:55 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
the subject is quite boring in fact.
|
devin11
Registered User
Posts: 48
(5/8/02 11:34:52 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Part of me thinks "he's completly lost it."
But the other part...makes me remember that it's rivers we're talking about here. I think he could bust another blue albumesque song out in an hour or less if he wanted to.
but he doesn't.
that's the only thing.
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 378
(5/8/02 11:37:44 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Rivers hasn't lost it. He just refuses to make the songs the way we want them.
Edit: He is still writing good songs. They are presented incorrectly.
Hmm, if only there were some way to prove this...
Edited by: Real Frogs at: 5/8/02 11:43:25 pm
|
SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 261
(5/9/02 12:04:31 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
just out of curiousity- but who are we to judge what he is "capable" of?
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 310
(5/9/02 12:06:11 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
SKYBLUE YOU STARTED THE FUCKING THREAD:
"Have any of you ever come to realize that RC will NEVER be able to write an album like TBA or Pinkerton again"
YOU ARE RETARDED. THE ORIGINAL SUGGESTION POSTED ABOVE IS RATHER INSULTING (AND NOT INSIGHTFUL/HELPFUL) ....BUT THEN TO BE A HYPOCRITE AND ACCUSE OTHERS OF QUESTIONING ACE'S CURRENT ABILITY IS JUST NUTS.
MOLLY, YOUR ORIGINAL COMMENT IS (in my opinion) WHAT RIDD IS TALKING ABOUT WHEN HE REFERS TO LACK OF RESPECT.
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/9/02 12:17:32 am
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 145
(5/9/02 12:15:50 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
hmm...does anyone see a pattern.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 192
(5/9/02 12:16:33 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i do i do
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 146
(5/9/02 12:21:30 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
high-five, bish
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 379
(5/9/02 12:22:01 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I am a bit confused with the hypocritical sort of comment there..
But the first comment wasn't necessarily negative, and didn't say that he was gonna turn out bad music for the rest of his life. She just said he'd never write another Blue or Pinkerton because he has progressed and matured mentally, and I think that's true..
But that's not to say he won't write another amazing album. It will just be different. I hope he does.
Eh, that's how I interpreted that...
EXPANDING ON THIS.. rivers is older now, and has different goals. There are elements of blue and @#%$ that are fairly immature.. but that's why I love the fucking records. Everyone these days is trying to make a "mature" record, and it's just.. not the way to go. I don't know. It's late and I'm not very articulate. I'll probably say something else about this tomorrow. I have a half-formed idea in my head, but i'm just too out of it
Edited by: Real Frogs at: 5/9/02 12:26:18 am
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 147
(5/9/02 12:25:16 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
technically she said "will never be able" which implies lacking capability.
|
grossepointekate
FEMALE
Posts: 193
(5/9/02 12:26:13 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i think merkin was just saying that the initial statement was kind of putting a limit on his capabilities...and then to come back and tell someone else they have no right to decide what his capabilities are seemed kind of contradictory....
yeah, i like the nice long run on sentences...
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 380
(5/9/02 12:30:10 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
When you are 24 years old, you are able to be/think/act/write music like a 24-year-old.
When you are 31 years old, you aren't able to be/think/act/write music like a 24-year-old.
It's not a question of his skills as a songwriter, or a lacking of capability.. when you're five years old, that is the only time in your life you can actually be five years old. After that, you aren't capable.. you haven't lost talent or ability, but you aren't capable of that and never will be again.
I think Rivers is capable of making more amazing music than he is now, and hopefully it will all come in time.. but for all the people expecting another blue or pinkerton.. it's not gonna happen. Though I wish as hard with you that it would.
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 311
(5/9/02 12:32:13 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i bet at some point in his life, he'll take on a new project (rather than the pop song one he's engaged in), and then we'll see some more of the type of stuff we appreciated in pinkerton.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 497
(5/9/02 12:34:20 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Maladroit is mature?
|
kyleisweezer2
Registered User
Posts: 62
(5/9/02 12:36:17 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I think so, at least. But maturity has both good and bad sides. The youthful energy is usually gone, but the knowledge and experience of the craft is refined.
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 382
(5/9/02 12:36:27 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
to its creator, i believe
edit: response to tls
Edited by: Real Frogs at: 5/9/02 12:37:14 am
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 148
(5/9/02 12:38:20 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i think i just vomitted.
|
starby
Registered User
Posts: 102
(5/9/02 12:39:48 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
fukingdammit real frogs. that's just what i have been saying (well in my head); you can only write about who and where you are at the moment and still be sincere.
if rivers tries to write another pinkerton, it would be insincere and pushed out of him. but on the other hand, if he writes another green or maladroit, it would be expexted now that he is beyond his age of wonder and excitment and into his age of 'seen and done that shit'.
he is no longer a kid, as most of us are, so he honsetly believes that pinkerton is worthless and that kind of wriiting is too revealing, which we believe to be the epitome of songwriting. oh well. skyblue's right.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 499
(5/9/02 1:24:49 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
To me, in comparison to Blue and Pinkerton, Maladroit sounds far more like the typical work of a teenager or inexperienced songwriter messing around with metal riffs, B.S. lyrics, and obvious/formulaic song structures that have already been proven to 'work' time and time again. What's so mature about that? 'Mature' implies sophistication...maybe some contemplative lyrics, some acoustic work, challenging song structures(ala Burt Bacharach, Brian Wilson, etc.) or layering of instruments, etc. THAT is mature music. Maladroit is NOT mature(by any relative standard). It's a juvenile riff-fest.
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 383
(5/9/02 1:30:33 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I agree with you.
I never said I thought Maladroit was more mature. I said I think Rivers believes it to be.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 44
(5/9/02 1:34:33 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"...maybe some contemplative lyrics, some acoustic work, challenging song structures(ala Burt Bacharach, Brian Wilson, etc.) or layering of instruments, etc."
no, that is what an sophomoric musician thinks is mature, maturity is not showing off and making good music
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 501
(5/9/02 1:42:47 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Tell me what it is then.
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 81
(5/9/02 1:55:14 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I love how complexity and dynamics are inherently "showing off"...
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 384
(5/9/02 1:57:55 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
There is a difference between showing off and using talent.
Complex music in any form is not inherently showing off.
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 151
(5/9/02 2:00:22 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
rivers probably doesn't think good music = complex. doesn't anyone just want to rock anymore?
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 82
(5/9/02 2:02:09 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
No.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 45
(5/9/02 2:02:24 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
thats exactly what he is doing, he is rocking.
fuck complexity, complexity is overused, there is a reason the beatles's white album is so awesome, i am getting at the same idea....
simplicity is the key to great music
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 503
(5/9/02 2:10:23 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
We're talking about what is or isn't MATURE music. Not the difference between good and bad music.
There's lot's of good music that isn't mature(Maladroit would fall under that), and I agree Maladroit is generally good music(singing is in key, band sounds tight, etc)...to call it mature is bold though. It doesn't resemble anything close to what people would commonly refer to as 'mature' music, period.
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 153
(5/9/02 2:16:15 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
what makes music mature. and why does it need to be mature. is mature music better than immature music.
by the way i think maladroit is 758923 times more mature than the blue album in that it is a lot more "worked out" and based on more education and experience. you can hear the difference. at least i do.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 504
(5/9/02 2:21:15 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Listen to "The World Has Turned and Left Me Here" next to any given Maladroit song. Which sounds more mature to you?
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 46
(5/9/02 2:23:34 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
mature
\Ma*ture"\, a. [Compar. Maturer; superl. Maturest.] [L. maturus; prob. akin to E. matin.] 1. Brought by natural process to completeness of growth and development; fitted by growth and development for any function, action, or state, appropriate to its kind; full-grown; ripe.
i think it is safe to say that rivers has not fully devoloped as a musician yet, but each album shows he has learned more about music, ric ocasek (sp?) said that he is much more talented than what he puts down in the studio, just because you can use something doesnt mean you should
an immature artist will assume that the most complex arrangement is always the best, but rivers is mature enough/intelligent enough/insightful enough to know that complexity isnt always what is best for a song.
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 47
(5/9/02 2:25:18 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
take control kicks The World Has Turned and Left Me Here's ass
|
anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 318
(5/9/02 2:27:17 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
NO
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 154
(5/9/02 2:36:47 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
surfer...listen to surfwax (my least favorite weezer song) and then listen to slob... your point is a difficult one to make.
i don't think this maturity & complexity thing is constructive at all or leads to anything positive. i much prefer when being critiqued knowing what effect the piece at hand has. that way i can know if its accomplishing what i want it to. in the case of maladoit i think what ace wants is to rock and have a good time and it's working for me.
Edited by: weezerfan9544 at: 5/9/02 2:37:58 am
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 505
(5/9/02 2:41:32 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Music is not the same as a ripe banana...what people commonly view as maturity musically does not necessarily follow the formal definition of the word...
And even if weezer's new music could be compared to the maturity of a banana, it wouldn't be ripe, it would be something closer to rotten.
So many Maladroit songs are the opposite of complete or developed(i.e. "Burndt Jamb" & "Death and Destruction"). They're not even tastefully brief in my opinion.
Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/9/02 2:56:26 am
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 83
(5/9/02 2:49:52 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"i think it is safe to say that rivers has not fully devoloped as a musician yet, but each album shows he has learned more about music, ric ocasek (sp?) said that he is much more talented than what he puts down in the studio, just because you can use something doesnt mean you should
an immature artist will assume that the most complex arrangement is always the best, but rivers is mature enough/intelligent enough/insightful enough to know that complexity isnt always what is best for a song."
An equally immature artist might assume that extreme simplicity is always the best, but a more mature artist would realize the proper measure of complexity and elegance is the preferred state.
Look, I'm not going to claim any sort of authority to judge Rivers' musical development. But your argument is pretty ridiculous here. You cannot respond to a call for greater complexity with "Too much complexity is a lousy, immature, bad thing"--because a dearth of complexity is no more mature than an excess of it. Holding back talent is not intrinsically mature; recognizing the time and place for the elements is.
But, good lord, if you'd rather "Take Control" than TWHTALMH--really, what's the point, then?...
|
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 385
(5/9/02 2:52:12 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
A mature musician knows when to be short and simple and knows when to be complex.
Take Control is far inferior to TWHTALMH. Quit sucking up.
"Butterfly" is far more mature than anything on maladroit or green.. and it's just about as fucking simple as it gets.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 506
(5/9/02 2:53:19 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I'd say "Surf Wax" and "Slob" are both exceptions to their respective albums. "Surf Wax" being the one less-than-mature song on Blue, and "Slob" being the one semi-mature song on Maladroit. However, I'd still say "Surf Wax" is cleverly immature(inspired by youthful exuberance, not immaturity...and the structure is pretty unique...good guitar arpeggios too) and "Slob" is wanna-be mature(it sounds more or less like an angry teenager lashing out at their parents, rather than a mature 30 year-old adult).
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 48
(5/9/02 2:58:19 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"A mature musician knows when to be short and simple and knows when to be complex."
i agree 100%
and i think take control is heavier and more "hardcore" than TWHTALMH, i prefer heavier music with more of an edge.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 507
(5/9/02 3:01:07 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Frogs has got it again.
I mean, let's use Burt Bacharach as an example. He's widely accepted as a 'mature' songwriter, right?
Listen to "Trains and Boats and Planes"(super simple chords and structure...almost @#%$), and then listen to "Walk On By"(crazy chords and changes all over the place). He uses simplicity AND complexity when appropriate. That's the sign of maturity.
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 312
(5/9/02 3:01:31 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
phoebe, my 14 year old brother has a sweet garage band -- totally hardcore with an edge, you should check 'em out
|
Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 84
(5/9/02 3:02:57 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"and i think take control is heavier and more "hardcore" than TWHTALMH, i prefer heavier music with more of an edge."
Like what you want, but a "heavier edge" hardly seems to be a valid, mature justification for judging "musical ass-kicking"...
Edited by: Bob511 at: 5/9/02 3:29:08 am
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 49
(5/9/02 3:04:25 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
are they very industrial marilyn manson-ish?
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 155
(5/9/02 3:04:44 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
at least we are on a similar page. well my approach is that i dislike the sound of surfwax. i don't know anything about music. but i listen to tons of it and i think surfwax is annoying. slob for lack of a better word...is interesting. i don't think it's as angsty as you perceive it. i read it as a man throwing out some old baggage. Like a release. It actually has a calming effect on me. at least i can respond to something rather than in surfwax which does absolutely nothing for me.
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 508
(5/9/02 3:07:33 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"and i think take control is heavier and more "hardcore" than TWHTALMH, i prefer heavier music with more of an edge."
...your PERSONAL preference for 'heavier music with more of an edge' has no bearing on what most people view as mature music...
Again, this isn't about what's good or bad, or what you happen to like best.
Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/9/02 3:10:06 am
|
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 50
(5/9/02 3:07:42 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
thanks, i will like what i want.
i agree, i have been blurring the lines, i apologize.
i quit, you win, i am a moron who knows nothing about music.
goodnight.
Edited by: phoebecaulfield at: 5/9/02 3:10:40 am
|
anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 320
(5/9/02 3:17:28 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
surfwax is fucking great during the 3 part harmony slow-down, and I really love the "all along the undertow" part right before that. the rest of the song is okay, but those parts really make for a great song for me. that what was so great about old weez. even if there were little parts of the song that weren't your favorite, there was always a great brigde, or ending to make you love the song. nowadays, you can hear about 1:00 of the song, and predict precisely what the song will be like for the rest of the duration. like queero said one time, i was pretty interested when I heard the :45 second clips off of geffens website for those 3 green songs back in like march of last year, but I was quite disappointed when I learned that I had heard the whole song those 45 seconds.
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 156
(5/9/02 3:24:36 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
i don't think most people think "wow this is cool...but is it MATURE?" it's a waste of time to think that it matters.
antone...i have TRIED to like surfwax but i absolutely can't listen to it. someone great once said "too many notes!" i am honestly shocked by how popular it is and especially it being on the setlist on the tours...ESPECIALLy the encore of all things. i see little connection between surfwax and the old weezer because what makes me like almost all of weezers songs so much is that i love the whole song not just one tiny part.
|
anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 321
(5/9/02 3:29:58 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
it's still probably my second least favorite song on blue
behind undone
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 157
(5/9/02 3:32:24 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
im the same...just the other way around. :)
|
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 509
(5/9/02 3:36:27 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"i don't think most people think "wow this is cool...but is it MATURE?" it's a waste of time to think that it matters."
...someone DID think that. That's why it was discussed.
|
SandwichesTime
JUST A FEMALE
Posts: 94
(5/9/02 5:56:21 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
this thread is an explosion of my agreeing with surfer. yessssss
|
catch624
Registered User
Posts: 70
(5/9/02 6:02:18 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I have a problem w/ the word mature. That word assumes that a finished state has been reached. Maturity implies that the growth stage is over and i don't think that's the case w/ Rivers' songwriting or w/ Weezer as a band.
Quite the opposite. That's probably why Maladroit seems more "immature" to some people----maybe it doesn't sound like a finished, well thought out product and that's ok w/ me. I like listening to a band going thru changes and i think that's just what we're getting to hear. It's not like this is the only new Weezer record we're gonna have to listen to for the next 5 yrs. That is, if Rivers' productivity even begins to approach what he's hinted he & the band are capable of and what they want to do.
|
jkam
Registered User
Posts: 81
(5/9/02 10:12:49 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Rivers is very capable in doing what he wants to do. If he feels that pinkerton was a bad album that is up to him. To be honest he mentioned in the pulse article that e-m-o is just bad music. If pinkerton was the only e-m-o stuff I would say he is wrong but if it creates bands like dashboard confessional I would run for the hills. It is obvious that rivers musical taste was always rooted with the heavier rock so it is suprising we haven't heard a more metal sound until maladroit. For me weezer has always been about how catchy the songs are and how I just want to sing along. Even if you hate the green album it sticks in your mind and if it is on you are going to sing along. I think sometimes everyone takes everything too seriously...and even though I may be an older fan I can look upon the new stuff with a fresh set of ears. It is definitely more interesting to me to hear a new sound every album then to hear a band that can't show any variety. Rivers is on a journey and I am happy to be along for the ride.
Edited by: jkam at: 5/9/02 10:14:48 am
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 313
(5/9/02 10:37:18 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I think TLS' and RF's frustration above is less about being upset with the quality of weezer's music and more about pheoboe's and weezer9542's confusion of what they like with what is considered a mature sound.
a quick breakdown:
1) ace writes mature music in his blue/p.ink phase
2) ace decides he'd rather pursue the project of the perfect pop song - a project that structurally excludes some of the 'mature' elements
3) TLS and RF don't like the new direction, phoebe and 9542 do.
....but liking or disliking the new direction doesn't reflect on whether blue/p.ink have a more mature sound - they do. but whether that aesthetic appeals to you or not is a subjective call. (for example - Smashing pumpkins exhibit a mature sound which i don't find particularly appealing).
While one might argue that it's less mature to aim to capture 'emotional extremes' (as i think ace has done in interviews), i think that is a separate question from whether or not the music is mature.
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/9/02 10:53:55 am
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 150
(5/9/02 11:07:49 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
the weezer songs that stand the test of time will not be on Green or Maladroit
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 291
(5/9/02 11:55:20 am)
|
Re: Just a thought.
I'm late for class, so i'm just going to have to say that I agree with Surfer on about 95% of his points. Mature music is knowing when to be simple and when to be complicated.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 277
(5/9/02 12:01:21 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
Nathaniel -
dead on. the songs on green and maladroit are the songs that get stuck in your head all day and by the time you listen to the CD it's boring, especially maladroit in my opinion.
blue ive listened to for what? 8 years now? and 5 or 6 with pinkerton? have yet to grow tired of them, never even got bored with them.
maladroit i am completely bored with. it's the difference between the songs the beatles were making and the songs the beatles rip off bands were making. the beatles songs were timeless, the rip off bands weren't. i guess it feels like ace is writing a bunch of one hit wonders now, as opposed to @#%$ albums. but i do think that private message and prodigy lover are headed in a good direction...
|
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 282
(5/9/02 12:45:39 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
IMO, most beatles songs actually are very "quick burns". if i had to listen to one beatles album for 8 years, i certainly would grow bored.
|
hacky bag
Registered User
Posts: 60
(5/9/02 12:48:14 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
ace, you still got it.
you people listen to prodigy lover or private message. jesus, patience jiggaz, patience
|
zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE. Who knew?
Posts: 223
(5/9/02 12:51:09 pm)
|
Re: Just a thought.
"the weezer songs that stand the test of time will not be on Green or Maladroit"
For the most part I agree, but on the other hand blue and pinkerton already have had time to let those songs become great. I can see songs like d & d and burndt jamb becoming part of my favorite weezer songs. We've all had years to let the other two albums sink in, give these some time as well.
|