← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Just a thought.
New Topic

Page 1 2

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 278
(5/9/02 12:51:16 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
i would say their earlier stuff is mostly 'quick burns' but their later stuff, i'm thinking specifically abbey road here, are some of those albums that feel almost like a greatest hits album, cause all the songs are just so damn good. that's how i feel about blue, pinkerton and most of green (not a big o girlfriend fan), but it might just be a matter of maladroit growing on me, or i could have maladroit overload after listening to the original demos and mixes through the entire process. right now i have the album set so it plays 'dope nose', 'burnt jam', 'slob', 'fall together', 'love explosion.' but for some reason, the other songs i'm completely burned out on. but to me those songs seem to be the most timeless on the album.

EDIT: spelling

Edited by: Brody783 at: 5/9/02 12:52:56 pm
kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 60
(5/9/02 12:53:50 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
of course compared to eveyone else, he's still got it and then some...but compared to how good we know he can be/"used to be"? I think that's what people are questioning. Private message is really nice, though. Prodigy lover is really well done, but I don't feel like it ever really gets going for some reason.

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 204
(5/9/02 1:49:43 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
on the topic of maturity:

I find the songs on maladroit to be mature in their pop craft. In the same way that maturity is knowing when to be simple and when to be complex, it is also knowing when to use standard structures and when to deviate from them. That's why Burdnt Jamb and D&D still work for me. Although they stray from standard form, they still sound complete.

The songs on Maladroit are not all riff-fests or all alike, but all have managed to have structural and melodic cohesiveness. And those structures and melodies are actually good. That's why I concider Maladroit to be mature in craft.

I don't wanna say blue and pinkerton are not mature, but Maladroit is definately more to the point.

Wilson

dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 205
(5/9/02 1:54:07 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Edit: I have no idea how I made a double post.

pooey on me

Wilson

Edited by: dageeklove at: 5/9/02 7:18:05 pm
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 151
(5/9/02 2:16:54 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
I actually agree with ace about the beatles, their music is so overplayed for me that I usually go for months or years without even picking up one of their albums (be it earlier or later stuff), but I still like them.
I think newer weezer songs have potential to become classics (D&D, Slob), but the albums that will be revered in years to come will be blue and Pinkerton.

I hate to make a Beach Boys comparison yet again, but for several years they (read: Brian Wilson) were considered to be among the best and most important musical talents in the business. After they peaked creatively with Pet Sounds/Good Vibrations/Smile, they were never again held in such high esteem, despite the fact that they still made lots of really good music (Sunflower, Love You), because it was no longer ground-breaking or really very 'important,' it was just plain good music. Nowadays when people want to hear c.lassic Beach Boys they will always look to Pet Sounds or Today!, not to the Surf's Up album.

Private Message and Prodigy Lover are more in the style of 'c.lassic' weezer, but they are still a million miles away from The World Has Turned.

Edited by: Nathaniel Hornblower at: 5/9/02 2:18:19 pm
Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 386
(5/9/02 3:22:50 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Early Beatles albums are quick burns, I agree, but the later ones aren't.. the later ones, which Rivers has been quoted as calling "unlistenable."

What is it he's out to create? "Quick burns" or timeless records?

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 285
(5/9/02 3:26:26 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
the hybrid theory

nobodysrobot
Registered User
Posts: 134
(5/9/02 3:27:45 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
SHUT UP!

nobodysrobot
Registered User
Posts: 135
(5/9/02 3:29:56 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
WHEN I'M TALKING TO YOU

Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 387
(5/9/02 3:30:30 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Quick burns that are timeless.

Like the Beatles' first records.

Interesting.

Is there any desire, though, to walk on the other side and create something in which the listener hears something new every time? Both the simple pop song and the complex rock song are respectable forms.. but I think it's rather restricting to simply commit to one. Personally, I go on writing stretches where I'm writing formulaic three-minute pop songs, then I tire of that and dig into insanely structured songs stretching past five minutes.. then I tire of that and return to the pop formula.

After 375 songs, hasn't it started to wear out a little?

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 596
(5/9/02 3:31:21 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
"Private Message and Prodigy Lover are more in the style of 'c.lassic' weezer, but they are still a million miles away from The World Has Turned. "

It's totally wrong to compare those songs to TWHTALMH. They're two dif styles of music completely.

Private Message and Prodigy Lover are good enough to stand by themselves. People need to stop comparing everything that comes out to the old skool. And I know that's been the same argument that's been had before...but it's really. fucking. old. now.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 286
(5/9/02 3:35:21 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
i think you're all going to be deeply satisfied by my future songs but it's kind of pointless for me to talk about it.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 597
(5/9/02 3:37:12 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
no. no it isn't.

please continue sir.

Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 153
(5/9/02 3:37:39 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
mp3s plz

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 285
(5/9/02 3:38:11 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
why do you think that ace? what's in them that will please us so much? I really like private message and prodigy lover, i don't doubt that the new songs are just as good. Talk alone sucks, but we can't listen, so talk will suffice.

Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 388
(5/9/02 3:39:04 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
I think most everyone here that was dissatisfied with recent efforts has faith that that very thing will happen, as things have been progression in that direction, me included.

But despite the faith, you're right, it is the sort of thing people will have to hear to believe.

Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 154
(5/9/02 3:44:52 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
there have been lots of good positive steps recently: 1. putting Slob on the album 2. the new solos for the green songs, especially KDDO, 3. Prodigy Lover/Private Message, 4. Death and Destruction

I'm definitely a lot more optimistic than I was this time a year ago when we had Green, and its bsides

Edited by: Nathaniel Hornblower at: 5/9/02 3:46:03 pm
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 118
(5/9/02 4:07:41 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
"i think you're all going to be deeply satisfied by my future songs"

Well, we can hope but that's a pretty bold statement considering the different factions of discontent on this board. If it's possible, it would be interesting to hear an explanation of how the music will progress to this new level. Longer songs? More meaningful lyrics? Catchier hooks? Longer/more guitar solos? Even if it's just a few comments, maybe you could throw us a bone.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 273
(5/9/02 4:12:42 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
He already did rapp/rock

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 65
(5/9/02 4:23:52 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
haha ace just left us a heck of a statement...maybe it'll restore some faith in some of the pessimists on this board.

i'm anxious as all heck for album 5 now...mala-what? jk, still a fun album.

anToneJ28
Registered User
Posts: 324
(5/9/02 4:25:59 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
we will be deeply satisfied?
and you also say that you're going for a "perfect album"
wow I like the sound of that.

Real Frogs
You better fuckin party
Posts: 389
(5/9/02 4:28:29 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
I don't think there is anyone on this board who has totally lost hope.

If they had totally lost hope, they wouldn't be here.

phemayle
Registered User
Posts: 61
(5/9/02 5:09:14 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
progression is intresting and i enjoy it

unless its bad

Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 129
(5/9/02 5:43:26 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
exactly real frogs. good point brotha.

ace rocks hard and everyone knows it. it's not a matter of when he rocked, he just does.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 317
(5/9/02 5:44:28 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
cathy is cute when she uses "brotha" ^_^

Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 132
(5/9/02 6:44:18 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
do my ebonics turn you on brotha?

EN1TTY
Registered User
Posts: 28
(5/9/02 7:10:47 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
i agree cathy. ace still gots it.

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 67
(5/9/02 8:45:42 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
ach! misunderstanings today...i didn't mean that anyone had lost all hope (i especially have a lot of faith), just that a few are just getting pessimistic about getting another great album, thoguh they know it's still possible.

Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 100
(5/9/02 8:52:51 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
poor ace... he seems like he's in a somewhat shitty mood lately. he is a little defensive lately with his posts... and i know the comments on that setlist were a joke, but that stuff was harsh and pat/scott had to give him a little pep talk, so he was probably reasonably frustrated. maybe he feels like he's getting a bit depressed and wants to draw inspiration from that? if such is the case, then it's sad that he thinks we'll only be 'deeply satisfied' with the stuff he writes in these moods

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 606
(5/9/02 9:01:26 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
haha. shut up.

Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 101
(5/9/02 9:19:44 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
YOARE SOF UNNY, LOL

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 123
(5/9/02 9:29:14 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
No offense, FlatPepsi, but I don't see where you're getting this psychobabble theory. How are you inferring this onset of depression? Aside from one less-than-stellar show, which even he said happens, he's said the tour's been pretty amazing. He's been posting here fairly often and with actual content. Maybe what you perceive as defensive is just having to deal with the onslaught of reviews and interviews hitting the shelves. It must suck to have to sit back and read articles where your words might have been twisted or your work disparaged.

weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 158
(5/9/02 9:55:21 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
<<"i don't think most people think "wow this is cool...but is it MATURE?" it's a waste of time to think that it matters."

...someone DID think that. That's why it was discussed. >>

i'm simply saying its stupid. =) imo.

and merkin...i'm not confused. i think 75% of you are stuck on thinking pinkerton and blue are these amazing records because of x y and z. well x y and z are subjective too, not just whether or not one person to the next thinks its "good"...my point is that the word "mature" is not an effective means to critique anything because it is subjective as well. by definition it doesn't work either and i think one other poster pointed this out.

ace
Rugged.
Posts: 289
(5/9/02 10:07:43 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
i've been in a weird mood lately

weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 159
(5/9/02 10:09:51 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
do tell

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 319
(5/9/02 10:11:28 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
(offers ace the couch, pulls out a pen and notebook, and adjusts spectacles) please, go on.

zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE.
Who knew?

Posts: 227
(5/9/02 10:21:32 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
we still love you

bathroommonkey
Registered User
Posts: 65
(5/9/02 10:41:24 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
i have been in a weird mood also, kinda why do i need to even wake up in the morning mood.

Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 102
(5/9/02 10:58:06 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
roofrat - i didn't mean he was being defensive in a negative way. sorry if it came across like that. i agree with you. i was just saying that lately he seems to be taking criticism to heart more than usual, and might be kinda down on himself these days.

ace, you gotta remind yourself that people who bitch and moan the most are the ones that think the most highly of you

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 217
(5/9/02 11:31:58 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
weird moods make for good song writing

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 510
(5/10/02 12:23:08 am)
Re: Just a thought.
Yeah, I have no animosity towards Ace, whatsoever. The negative comments that come from this board are not motivated by hatred, anger, or dislike for Rivers...by any means. People just get caught up in the debates(I know I do) and the fixation of being able to express to him personally, behind a cyber buffer, what we really think about his music(be it good or bad thoughts). It's never personal.

I still buy his albums and enjoy listening to them more then most music, and I'm still in his fanclub. That doesn't mean I won't ask him about his constantly changing approach to songwriting, or challenge him to a discussion as to how he could possibly think his new material is somehow FAR superior to his old material, since those sort of questions have been the intended basis for the 'correspondence' from the very beginning. I'm sure he MUST have anticipated that he'd be receiving comments like that from people when he first got into this whole thing. I'd be curious to know now though, what he considers 'over the line', or personally offensive. Some of his quotes in the Pulse article lead me to believe that he is actually hurt by some of what he reads on here, and that surprises me. He is a rockstar, and he is above us...he has no reason to feel bad about what a bunch of internet losers have to say about his music. At least that's how I would look at it if I was him...plus the fact that nobody REALLY means any harm. People just want an explanation as to why weezer's music is suddenly less than 100% likable, and why they don't passionately love EVERY SINGLE song anymore(the miracle of Blue and Pinkerton era =w=). It's a valid question.

phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 51
(5/10/02 12:28:04 am)
Re: Just a thought.
i am the gayest poser in existence, who realized that the previous post was stupid and made no sense so i want it to go away

Edited by: phoebecaulfield at: 5/10/02 1:04:51 am
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 511
(5/10/02 12:50:56 am)
Re: Just a thought.
As far as musical accomplishments and celebrity status is concerned, he IS above us. I never said he's not a person.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 512
(5/10/02 12:52:02 am)
Re: Just a thought.
What?

Bob511
Registered User
Posts: 85
(5/10/02 1:40:51 am)
Re: Just a thought.
"Some of his quotes in the Pulse article lead me to believe that he is actually hurt by some of what he reads on here, and that surprises me. He is a rockstar, and he is above us...he has no reason to feel bad about what a bunch of internet losers have to say about his music."

Actually, this struck me as rather surprising as well, especially given the extremely tongue-in-cheek nature of the comments on this board. It usually seems pretty easy to distinguish the genuine critiques from the hyperbolic bullshitting that goes on, so I sometimes wonder where the overnegativity comes in.

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 141
(5/10/02 4:12:31 am)
Re: Just a thought.
Bathroommonkey, you need to stand up in the morning to post on this board.

GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 123
(5/10/02 6:25:37 am)
Re: Just a thought.
I know this is a few pages ago, but regarding the whole slow-burn talk:

there are only five albums that i can listen to over and over and over and over again, that i don't get burnt out listening to.

one of those is the beatles' abbey road.

the other four are weezer albums.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 326
(5/10/02 7:02:25 am)
Re: Just a thought.
says the 'hardcore' weezer fan: "Gumby must have the US-Pinkerton, the UK-Pinkerton (vinyl), *and* the Japanese-Pinkerton."

Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/10/02 1:57:26 pm
Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 103
(5/10/02 7:59:07 am)
Re: Just a thought.
dis

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 127
(5/10/02 9:22:22 am)
Re: Just a thought.
"...those sort of questions have been the intended basis for the 'correspondence' from the very beginning. I'm sure he MUST have anticipated that he'd be receiving comments like that..."

He probably did but his hope might have been that they would tend toward the constructive rather than the inflammatory. This forum leans more toward constructive than most but it isn't the only place he's been reading. There's a lot of angry, unmonitored crap slung on the internet and the majority of it is baseless and unsupported. People under cover of anonymity think cruelty is the new cool.


"Some of his quotes in the Pulse article lead me to believe that he is actually hurt by some of what he reads on here, and that surprises me. He is a rockstar, and he is above us...he has no reason to feel bad about what a bunch of internet losers have to say about his music."

Internet losers? Watch it, I resemble that remark! Actually, I think I take exception to the statement of him being above us. I guess I'd need clarification on your meaning before I disagree but if you mean superior and better than us, I don't see that. Granted, his life is outside the norm and by that standard he lives and operates on a different plane than us. But I don't think you can place him above us simply on that standard. He may be a better example of the human potential than many of us but not simply based on his rockstar status. Just my opinion and I'll stop reading into what you were trying to say.

As for being hurt, logic and reason have little to do with feelings and if you hear people over and over telling you that your music sucks and that you suck and hey buddy fuck you and the horse you rode in on, it must start to get to you. Weezer are bringing the rock and some people out there are the most selfish embodiments of the true id and only want what they want when they want it and preferably more of it. If music is your life and your work and you put your heart into your songs, to have people shit all over it has gotta hurt even if you tell yourself they're just internet losers.

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 281
(5/10/02 9:37:12 am)
Re: Just a thought.
gumby tom - i agree wholeheartedly. i do tire of maladroit as of late, but i think i had overkill on that and need to take a break. i love green now, and in a year i'm sure i'll be obsessed with maladroit and so on. all weezer albums, abbey road, most @#%$ floyd albums and the who live at leeds are the only albums i can listen to constantly without getting tired.

jsublime
Registered User
Posts: 9
(5/10/02 2:58:35 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
right on, roofrat

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 519
(5/10/02 3:21:12 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
When I say he's 'above us', I'm not suggesting that he's somehow a higher BEING or that he should even feel as though he is(since he's far lacking in many non-musically related areas...i.e. - social skills). Just that, being in the position he's in(super mega rockstar with a back catolog of major label albums and top 10 hits), if someone completely disrespects him or his work, he can easily dismiss it on the premise that he knows 'how it's done' and we don't. And even if there are other talented songwriters on here with great potential who also know 'how it's done', it should still be easy for him to rationalize, in his mind, the fact that he is 'better'(whether that's true or not) and therefore not feel so hurt by anything an anonymous message board poster might say about him. His songs have probably made him over a million dollars...no reason for him to feel bad about anything he's done, whether we like it or not.

Ace is weird though...sometimes he acts supreme(on RCB). Yet in the magazines he claims he's deeply hurt by the internet fans, and says we're actually right about certain things...so he must doubt his own judgement to a degree. But then he says we don't know what good songs are...so it's confusing.

Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/10/02 3:43:45 pm
ace
Rugged.
Posts: 291
(5/10/02 3:40:35 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
lets just talk about random s**t for a while please

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 327
(5/10/02 3:41:54 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
good call, ace. so i was fuckin the lonely surfer's sister and she says to me ....




edit: tls and i are buds... i'm just messing around, and, no i wouldn't do his sister. she's a beast.

Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/10/02 3:45:08 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 520
(5/10/02 3:45:10 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
I just want a setlist from the =gp= Oasis cover show.

JohnnyNo05
Registered User
Posts: 156
(5/10/02 3:50:10 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
ace, which of your guitars is your favorite right now? still the explorer?

phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 53
(5/10/02 3:50:50 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
phoebe needs to learn to read before she posts

Edited by: phoebecaulfield at: 5/10/02 3:52:56 pm
catch624
Registered User
Posts: 72
(5/10/02 3:52:04 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Hopefully, no matter how huge a megastar Rivers is or becomes, he's still human. I'm sure that a person in Rivers' position builds up a certain amt of armor, but no one is impervious to constant bashing.

And if we're internet losers, so is Ace. Pretty good company.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 176
(5/10/02 3:59:47 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
one beard i went down to the beard and bought a beard-pack of beard and drank it all

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 521
(5/10/02 5:18:10 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Random off topic posts don't go over too well on RCB.

Ace isn't an internet loser...he's a winner who uses internet. He could choose to live in a dumpster behind McDonalds and he'd still be a winner. No one can take his rockstar status away from him, regardless of the lifestyle he chooses off stage/outside of the recording studio.

...and BTW, I have a sister???

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 334
(5/10/02 5:24:53 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
TLS - why i am i so hung up on your sister?

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 523
(5/10/02 5:45:57 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
Because you're so ultra clever, and a man of superior intellect. I believe we've already established this though.

ridd1
- - - - - -
Posts: 691
(5/10/02 5:50:01 pm)
Re: Just a thought.
closed

Page 1 2 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>


Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index