← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Maladroit fell to #16
New Topic    Add Reply

Page 1 2

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 782
(5/29/02 2:50:05 pm)
Reply
Maladroit fell to #16
This sucks.

They need a new single.

Take Control please.

Edited by: Kelly Kapowski Loves Me at: 5/29/02 4:09:13 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 612
(5/29/02 2:51:41 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldroit fell to #16
How long did Green stay at #4 or whatever?

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 783
(5/29/02 2:53:03 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldroit fell to #16
I think it stayed in the top ten for at least 3 weeks...maybe 4

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 96
(5/29/02 2:53:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldroit fell to #16
slave thanks

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 613
(5/29/02 3:00:19 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldroit fell to #16
This is turning out weird. Maladroit/"Dope Nose" is neither a flop or a success.

Real Frogs
FREE PORN!!!
Posts: 434
(5/29/02 3:00:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Second single should be Keep Fishin', as it is in tune with what people would associate with weezer, it's a fun, catchy, summer-y song, good for summer.. Take Control should be the third single. It could fail miserably, but it could also be huge, and the third single doesn't have as much riding on it as the second single does; it's not as 'make-or-break'.

hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 139
(5/29/02 3:05:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
it stayed in the top 10 for a full month

BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 200
(5/29/02 3:08:01 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
they need another snl appearance or something

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 359
(5/29/02 3:09:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i bet part of it has to do with interscope not supporting the single or the album (i.e. paying the big radio stations to keep it in heavy rotation). if dope nose were hugely successful everyone would remember that weezer managed to do all this without a label's help for the most part. so they hinder it a little but not so much as to kill their massive profits they'll be getting for having done nothing.

Edited by: this niblet at: 5/29/02 3:10:02 pm
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 328
(5/29/02 3:09:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
fishin' and letterman

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 97
(5/29/02 3:11:01 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I will go ahead and make a prediction... I'll probably be wrong, but I predict space rock as the next single.

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 58
(5/29/02 3:12:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
yeah i agree, a letterman appearence would be good for em..i also think keep fishin' should be the next single..seperate the rock a bit, take control or fall together would make a good third...but fishin second..and tv appearences!

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 614
(5/29/02 3:12:17 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Interesting.

People must be buying it and finding out that they don't like it...then telling their friends that it's no good, stopping the flow of album purchases.

Probably the same thing that happened with Pinkerton.

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 59
(5/29/02 3:14:29 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i hope the fifth record(and its current date, ie feb 03') isnt dependant upon the success of maladroit...that would totally blow..

this better not hinder weezer's plans

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 360
(5/29/02 3:15:29 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i don't think that's the only way to explain it

it could just as easily be that all the weezer fans went out and bought it right away and that there aren't too many casual weezer listeners who buy it on impulse when they happen to see it in a store (as opposed to going out with the intention of buying it)

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 98
(5/29/02 3:18:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I agree with that... nobody's really buying cd's right now anyway... sales are so low compared to last year. The record industry must be pissed.

Edited by: thenewaves at: 5/29/02 3:19:42 pm
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 336
(5/29/02 3:20:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
what is moby ranked this week? hopefully the execs will just say, hell, they beat moby the first week, that means something.

Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 197
(5/29/02 3:23:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
that's not what happened to pinkerton

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 616
(5/29/02 3:26:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
"i don't think that's the only way to explain it

it could just as easily be that all the weezer fans went out and bought it right away and that there aren't too many casual weezer listeners who buy it on impulse when they happen to see it in a store (as opposed to going out with the intention of buying it)"

What's changed since last year though, as far as the circumstances(hardcore fans, casual listeners, etc) that kept Green in the top ten for a month, but not Maladroit?


"I agree with that... nobody's really buying cd's right now anyway... that sales are so low compared to last year. The record industry must be pissed."

...but it's all relative? Something still has to be #1, #2, #3, and so on, despite how many OVERALL records are sold. P. Diddy will probably continue to sit at #1 when Maladroit is way down at the bottom.

FabFiveFreddy
Registered User
Posts: 22
(5/29/02 3:28:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i'm not sure if this is a good or a bad thing.

looking at the charts it seems bad, but then consider the following:

-dope nose hasn't caught on like hash pipe did.
-interscope hasn't promoted maladroit like they did green.
-weezer hasn't promoted maladroit like they did green.
-green had five years of anticipation built into it.

maladroit should've tanked, but weezer fans pushed the album into the top 3. of course that was just an anomaly though. now it's falling back to a more likely position, given the above factors.

jkam
Registered User
Posts: 104
(5/29/02 3:28:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Ackkkk record sales are lower....well yeah they are lower all the new bands coming out suck like toe cheese. I am tired of all the same rehashed sounding bands in a nice new package and the record companies expecting us to buy into it. They deserve what they get. Not to mention they treat their bands like doodie (weezer as a good example) and give them like 2 cents for every cd they sell. Ani Difranco is smart she makes about 5 bucks a cd. If the record companies spent as much time searching for GOOD bands as they do screwing over there current ones record sales would be better.

If only there were more bands like weezer!

I see the cd bouncing back next week.

Edited by: jkam at: 5/29/02 3:30:44 pm
BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 203
(5/29/02 3:30:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
shopping.artistdirect.com...dwz117.gif

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 329
(5/29/02 3:31:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
weezer aren't going to get the little kiddies and the older, casual listeners (lil' old lady and island story) with dope nose and no record label publicity. Keep fishin' is oobercatchy and interscope needs to push the song (somehow i think they want the album to fail - they don't really have much to loose if it doesn't do as well as green, they'll still make a lot of money w/o paying for hardly anything).

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 784
(5/29/02 3:35:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
the fact is dope nose isnt as strong as a single as hash pipe.

and moby fell from #4 to #10.

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 101
(5/29/02 3:36:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
yeah... doesn't weezer have a couple of months off? They could make some tv appearances....

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 361
(5/29/02 3:39:19 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
"What's changed since last year though?"

it's been mentioned before I could get to it, but what's changed is hash pipe on trl and teenyboppers getting into it.

all i was saying was that I don't think it means sales are dropping off due to bad word of mouth, it's a combination of other factors

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 617
(5/29/02 3:41:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
The only thing that's really different since Green, is the anticipation factor. But that's the kind of thing that only produces high numbers of initial, first week sales anyway...and Maladroit actually debuted higher than Green in the first week, so I dunno.

I guess Green had staying power...Maladroit does not. And Green had singles, whereas Maladroit does not. And people liked Green, whereas they probably do not like Maladroit(even though it's a more interesting album). It's the Pinkerton scenario all over again.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 785
(5/29/02 3:50:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I don't think it's a pinkerton sceanario all over again. This album is much more user friendly on first listen then that album was. Especially for the general music public. I think people like it...it just doesn't have the must have feeling to it yet. When Hash Pipe came out it...it was something different. Dope Nose, while cool, has a similar vibe and can be taken as more of the same....which is what may have happened.

And it may have charted higher, but it sold less copies then green. Dope Nose just isn't getting the support that Hash Pipe had. Whether that's because of radio or it not grabbing people the way that did, I don't know. Hash Pipe, as mentioned above, was all over TRL for a bit there, and really kept mementum going. Dope Nose can't just be a popular radio song, it needs to be a popular video as well. And it hasn't been. Not sure why. And it has never made it on to TRL once. Not even a close call.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 618
(5/29/02 3:50:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
That's my point exactly Niblet. The TRL teenybopper fans that weezer used to have(the ones who kept Green in the charts) are now hearing Maladroit and finding out that weezer doesn't sound TRL-friendly anymore...word is getting around and they're not buying the album.

Of course, it could just be a beard thing.

Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/29/02 3:54:25 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 619
(5/29/02 3:53:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
How come 'more of the same' works for bands like Creed?

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 786
(5/29/02 3:54:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
That's not it at all. There is no such thing as TRL radio friendly. There have been some horrible songs (more so then usual) that have stayed on the TRL top ten just because it was a new video from a band they like. Weezer is liked.

Also, when a new video preimeres...it is almost customary for Carson or whoever the host is at that time, to introduce it as a TRL premiere and play it in it's entirety on the show. That never ever happened for Dope Nose. Which is weird. They were a big TRL band for a while...so the video should have been premierd on it. Is this because of the label not pushing MTV into it or because MTV is dumb? Who knows.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 787
(5/29/02 3:56:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Surfer:

Because Creed has a much BIGGER fan base across the music board, young and old...

plus, in all of their songs...they have catchy choruses...which besides the "Oh..Oh's..." Dope Nose doesn't really have. Hash Pipe had the very catchy, and different, falsetto, and a pseudo-catchy chorus.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 620
(5/29/02 3:57:08 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Payola.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 621
(5/29/02 3:58:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
...and I think there is such thing as TRL Radio Friendly. You just described it.

Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/29/02 3:59:20 pm
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 788
(5/29/02 4:01:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Even so...

It still should have at least had a premiere on TRL to get the word out there. It's very weird that it didn't.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 362
(5/29/02 4:04:26 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
still as far as the trl crowd goes i still don't think it's bad word of mouth as much as they just don't quite realize it's out there.

carson hasn't told them that they want it.... and that is probably because interscope isn't paying the usual bribes

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 623
(5/29/02 4:06:05 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Hence 'payola.'

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 789
(5/29/02 4:06:29 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
that's exactly what i just said above...just in different words and somewhat long winded.

Real Frogs
FREE PORN!!!
Posts: 435
(5/29/02 4:07:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Exactly.. when they premiere the video on TRL, that's MTV telling the teenyboppers that this is what they need to listen to.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 363
(5/29/02 4:07:42 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i know... i said this earlier in the thread as well

the part that i disagree with you on is that some people bought it, didn't like it, and are killing it with bad word of mouth

edit: sorry for the confusion kelly - i was talking to surfer

Edited by: this niblet at: 5/29/02 4:14:25 pm
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 790
(5/29/02 4:10:48 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I never said that. I don't think the album has bad word of mouth at all.

And if it did, the only possible place it would is with the easy listening crowd who really dug island and thought this would be as laid back poppy as that.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 624
(5/29/02 4:26:26 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Well, my point is the album just isn't going to cut it commercially...even with the right promotion...and it's all playing into why the album is tanking.

The thing is...the record label, MTV, TRL, etc, etc have to feel that the product is marketable to begin with before they'll start pushing it, or backing it with corporate $$$. If they don't feel it has the potential(whether they promote it or not), they simply aren't going to waste resources on it. Their theory is that TRL kids aren't going to 'get it' no matter what...and they're right.

The label agreed to put out the album and show a few TV advertisements since Rivers already got the project rolling, but I'm sure Interscope heard the record and went "nope, this thing is a dead end." Same with TRL and "Dope Nose." And I'm sure those TRL teenyboppers that DO know about Maladroit and have heard the album start-to-finish are also thinking "this is not what I like." Word is out that it's simply not as 'instant' or listener friendly as Green.

It's a self-produced, commercial flop...similar to Pinkerton, but not quite to the same degree. As we know though, there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 792
(5/29/02 4:31:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I disagree with everything you just said in regards to people getting it and liking it.

But I am too lazy to type a response other then that.

Real Frogs
FREE PORN!!!
Posts: 436
(5/29/02 4:32:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Actually I want to disagree.. I've had a lot of mainstream-music listeners (who know me as the source of any weezer info) asking me about "that new weezer song.. I heard it on the radio once, and I love it.. but what is it? What record is it on? I wish they'd play it more.."

So I don't know.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 625
(5/29/02 4:32:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
You are allowed to disagree.

BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 205
(5/29/02 4:33:22 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
mtv.com says:

"While country artists surged up the chart this week, hipster musicians have taken a tumble. Moby's 18, which debuted on the last chart at #4, will fall to #10; while Weezer's Maladroit will dive 13 places from #3 to #16."

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 365
(5/29/02 4:33:49 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i guess i'm just more cynical than you or whatever

i feel like there's political issues beyond the record company not thinking it was marketable enough. since when have they been good judges of music. they're able to make certain things successful with their money, it often doesn't matter how bad it is.

Real Frogs
FREE PORN!!!
Posts: 437
(5/29/02 4:34:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
hah, thanks TLS

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 176
(5/29/02 4:35:25 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Here in Germany it's even worse, Maladroit fell from #7 to #34. And I just started to hope Rivers would decide to tour Germany again.
I don't know what it's like in the US, but the reason why it fails here is obvious. I haven't seen the Dope Nose video on television at least once. I don't even know if German music channels got the video. There needs to be good single soon, or Maladroit will be a flop.
As much as I fear to say it, but I think that (besides Take Control, Keep Fishin or Burndt Jamb) Possiblities could be a good single. It rocks and is catchy. It might not be a very good song in our eyes, but neither is any Blink 182 song, and hose are successful.

hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 140
(5/29/02 4:39:40 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
if it goes at this rate it will sell less than pinkerton

kodos88
Registered User
Posts: 96
(5/29/02 4:39:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
yeah, i see your point, but possibilities might be a little too short (I have a feeling that's part of the reason why why photograph wasn't the first single).

also, i would hate to see the day the band tried to pander that much to the mainstreamers. if the music is great, screw the charts.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 251
(5/29/02 4:49:27 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Point #1.
=======
The Dope Nose video is not TRL material.

Why?

Rivers has a weird beard.

Point #2.
=======
Maladroit is as good as Green in terms of the commercial viability of the songs. However, Green lost weezer a lot of its hardcore audience. The Pinkerton kids I know will never rush out and buy a weezer record again. They felt stung once, and won't be stung again. The TRL kids that Green won for weezer are not the kind that are going to prop up Maladroit unless Rivers goes back to looking normal (NON-CHILD MOLESTER). The only real thing that won them over in the first place was the anticipation of Green (That's what got it onto TRL). If Maldroit is going to be saved, it's got to come from a new demo: the nu-metal crowd.

Although a video for "Slave" that effectively parodies all the weezer cliches could work.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 367
(5/29/02 4:51:54 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i don't think the nu-metal crowd will ever get into weezer...

well, perhaps the part of that crowd that is only there because it is mainstream could be won over, but not the ones that are genuinely into that music

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 626
(5/29/02 4:58:26 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Niblet, what do you think the political issue would be?

If they felt like the album could do really well, why would they hold back on promoting it the best that they possibly could? They would never sacrifice potential money over some political issue. That's the most important thing.

They obviously don't have complete confidence that it will do well even if pushed heavily, and since it costs alot to promote a record, they don't want to risk the possibility of LOSING money. As long as they keep Maladroit promo funds to a minimum, they're playing it safe.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 368
(5/29/02 5:04:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
there have been plenty of political issues around maladroit for a while. if it were to become HUGE, it would serve as an example for what a band could do without the record company's help.

it's not like there was much of an initial investment on their part, whatever they're getting is easy money. i think they're sacrificing making it even bigger for the big picture - keeping the labels in a position to hoarde all the money that the industry generates.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 627
(5/29/02 5:10:00 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
"The TRL kids that Green won for weezer are not the kind that are going to prop up Maladroit unless Rivers goes back to looking normal (NON-CHILD MOLESTER). The only real thing that won them over in the first place was the anticipation of Green (That's what got it onto TRL)."

...you think the TRL kids were anticipating Green PREVIOUS to its actual release?...5 years after the commercial flop that was
Pinkerton? Before most of them were even old enough to know who weezer was? That's what won them over?

childcraft
Registered User
Posts: 64
(5/29/02 5:11:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
promotion.

the reason why Hash Pipe made it on TRL was because Weezer was playing at the MTV Movie Awards. To the teenybopper market, Weezer was barely known, or, was at the very least known as "those guys who did that Happy Days video a long time ago". MTV had to promote Weezer so the audience would know who the hell they were.

If you notice, ITTS barely got any rotation on TRL but it was such a great pop song, it got heavy rotation everywhere else (ie radio, commericials...olsen twins).

Maladroit had no Leno, no Letterman, no SNL, no TRL, no TV Shows, no Movies, no promotion (except maybe that one commericial during the Osbournes)

Dope Nose is catchy but Hash Pipe is catchier. Hash Pipe is more marketable for movies (American Pie 2) while Dope Nose is maybe a more obscure and not as universally embraced.

Now say if Keep Fishin and Take Control were released, it could very well save Maladroit (look at Linkin Park. That "In The End" or whatever song helped that album more than any of their other singles or even JEW and "The Middle") Everyone loved Keep Fishin when i played the DC Demo back in summer 01'. And Take Control is just harder, more rockin, and will catch on with a "rock" audience.

ohnoitgo
Registered User
Posts: 13
(5/29/02 5:20:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
I hate to even bring this up, but has anyone considered the impact of the beard?

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 369
(5/29/02 5:21:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
have you read the thread?

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 254
(5/29/02 5:22:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
"...you think the TRL kids were anticipating Green PREVIOUS to its actual release?...5 years after the commercial flop that was
Pinkerton? Before most of them were even old enough to know who weezer was? That's what won them over?"

My phrasing was wrong. Hash Pipe got onto TRL because of the 5 year hiatus and everyone's high hopes. The TRL kids were won over (temporarily) because it was on TRL, and by definition that's what the TRL kids bought. Contributing factor: the band was cuter then (no offense to scary scott).

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 370
(5/29/02 5:26:26 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
because of the 5 year hiatus? i don't think anyone thought they should be on trl because of that. i think that the label was just backing them because they stood to make a lot of money if weezer managed to make a comeback. this time they don't have as much of an investment to protect.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 405
(5/29/02 5:27:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
maladroit maybe a creative success, but it's just not commercial....and the green album "look" was easier to sell, more MTV-friendly.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 69
(5/29/02 5:34:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
As much as it sucks, I have to agree with wen about the "cuter" band look with green. TRL kids are morons who will listen to anything when they think the band is "hot" (hence the popularity of N*Sync).
Also, I think whoever said Weezer lost some of the hardcore Pinkerton fans with Green is right on--one of my friends refuses to buy Maladroit because he hated Green so much and wanted his money back.
The 5-year hiatus isn't a huge reason Green did so well--the uber-produced, poppy sound is why it was such a success. Plus the MTV Movie Awards and other appearences helped. I wonder if there are any plans for that with Maladroit. Maybe if they release another single, they'll go on late night show.

bathroommonkey
Registered User
Posts: 98
(5/29/02 5:40:08 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
devils advocate says

could this be an example of what happen when there is only one year between releases

does the average Weezer fan really want a new CD every year

dont get me wrong I want new releases as fast at they can be produced, but couldn't this be the real problem. because the music is good.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 795
(5/29/02 5:42:03 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
no.

other bands have done it, and been sucessful.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 70
(5/29/02 5:46:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
"does the average Weezer fan really want a new CD every year"

Why wouldn't they?

me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 63
(5/29/02 6:06:01 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
exactly. that's not it at all. last year there was a HUGE buildup, a FIVE-YEAR wait for the new album, from a band that had gotten this massive cult following, in addition to all the other fans who just liked weezer a lot when they were around, in addition to the people who heard hash pipe on the radio or saw it on mtv (since it was promoted and played a LOT more heavily than dope nose, and the video was more eye-catching, imo).

you can't even compare the atmosphere around the release of green to that of maladroit. it's not fair to do that. and that situation really can't be recreated again, i don't think, even if weezer decides to wait another 5 years or even 2 years before releasing their next album. which, i mean-- why should they do that, first of all-- just so there's more of a buildup?? and they WON'T do that, anyway.

maladroit was promoted in a pretty weird way, and dope nose hit the radio and mtv in a weird way, as well. if it had been promoted better, in the normal fashion, and if it had had a cooler video, i think it would have done a lot better, which would have automatically translated into better sales for maladroit. if the next single is chosen well and has a great vid behind it, sales can definitely still pick up.

Edited by: me be beatlleweez at: 5/29/02 6:08:39 pm
phemayle
Registered User
Posts: 85
(5/29/02 6:06:16 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
if cds wernt so overpriced and over promoted then we could have a new cd every 6 months.

thats the way it used to be. and thats the way it should be. but most artists (and i use that term very loosely) now and days dont have the talent to write a new album every 6 months.

record companies can bitch about the internet all they want, but until they start droping prices drasticaly and make them reasonable then im gonna keep on buring my cds , and only buying the albums of bands that are my fav. and i support.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 71
(5/29/02 6:43:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Sales could definitely go back up if the next single has a good video and actually gets backed by the label. Here's to hoping no Siega.

Slim Mackeral
silm pensi *lolz*
Posts: 479
(5/29/02 6:54:41 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
is this really a surprise?

Cyprine
Registered User
Posts: 75
(5/29/02 7:22:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Maladroit was actually really cheap as far as CD prices went.

I can't say it not selling as well has much if anything to do with the CD's own "flaws"; like it has already been pointed out, this is mostly due to lack of promotion. Did "Dope Nose" even make it on TRL once? The video wasn't memorable enough, and like it or not, the MTV kids control a huge part of today's music economy. Which brings up the point that people just aren't buying as many CDs anymore, now that they can download and burn. In any case, I'm hoping that Maladroit sells will take a turn-around in the summer, when they start touring and maybe doing a bit of promoting. Remember, the day the album came out, the band wasn't even in the states, they were starting their Japanese tour.

"Slave" or "Take Control" would both make excellent singles, a decent video producing more tv/radio play can help the album sell. I hope the band will consider releasing another single. What Maladroit needs is a strong one. "Hash Pipe", like it or not, was catchy as hell.

I think the scandal with Interscope and the "politics" behind it had little to do with this drop in album sales. It wouldn't be to their advantage, in addition, I think the Interscope situation is less serious than we've trumped it up to be. Both, though perhaps reluctant partners, are working towards some semblance of a common goal.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 796
(5/29/02 7:26:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Dope nose has never been on TRL.

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 73
(5/29/02 7:30:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I think you're right that they are working toward a similar goal but the label really isn't promoting this album like they did with Green. The whole brouhaha with the label is affecting how Maladroit is doing.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 343
(5/29/02 7:32:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
The video sucks and that's why it's not on TRL.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 797
(5/29/02 7:34:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
I don't understand how it ended up sucking.

It was such a great concept to begin with.

Weezerphile
Registered User
Posts: 232
(5/29/02 7:37:38 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Yeah, Siega is a fucking genius. I can't wait for his movie.

Cyprine
Registered User
Posts: 76
(5/29/02 7:38:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I think Interscope promoting not as much is not nearly as detrimental as the band not promoting as much(in relation to TGA).

I see Maladroit ads in most of the major music publications, even in a few newspapers, I heard they aired an ad during "The Osbournes". Arguably, the Interscope situation even helped Weezer by building up controversy, they gained a bit of cred by going against teh man.

Once an album is released, it seems to me like the ball is in the band's court.

Edited by: Cyprine at: 5/29/02 7:38:56 pm
caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 74
(5/29/02 7:43:13 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
The fight with Interscope certainly was public enough to probably ultimately help out the band, but I don't think the label did enough to push Dope Nose on the radio and MTV. And maybe the way Maladroit wound up on the radio has something to do with it. It sort of trickled on instead of having a definitive release date. And then when Rivers had to write those letters asking them to not play the song, some stations did stop playing it. Then it came back again. Kinda confusing, I guess.

How does it exactly work with bands getting on shows like Letterman and the MTV Movie Awards? I assumed that had something to do with the label, or are those bookings up to the band? Is that what you're referring to as band promotion, Cyprine?

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 628
(5/29/02 8:39:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Maladroit is getting 'standard' promotional push from the label(magazine ads, MTV commercials, etc.) AND the 'Maladroit Story' got a hell of a lotta' press due to the odd circumstances surrounding its making. I think I almost saw more weezer cover stories this time around than when Green came out. Maybe there isn't as much sneaky, behind-the-scenes, MTV/LABEL/RADIO big wig favor exchanging happening this time around(that's only far-fetched speculation anyway), and maybe weezer could be making a few more late night TV appearances than they have been...but I think there is more than enough going on to keep Maladroit afloat(and in the top 10) if it was actually commercially viable...but it's not. It's much more a content problem, than a marketing problem...IMO.

Also, the "Hash Pipe" video was almost equally as forgettable as the "Dope Nose" video. If anything, the "Dope Nose" vid is more attention grabbing due to the now-famous beard. So, I don't think the actual video is a problem either. An extremely gimmicky video CAN be a huge booster for a single, but in the case of these two videos, there's nothing special about either of them and their success/lack of success has to do with the actual song. "Dope Nose" is simply nowhere near as commercial as "Hash Pipe"...and that also goes for Maladroit as a whole.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 802
(5/29/02 8:42:52 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
No. Fighting naked fat guys in 20times funnier then japanese people on bikes.

zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE.
Who knew?

Posts: 295
(5/29/02 8:46:25 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
So I'm coming in a little late with this one, but ah well. I agree that the sales have to do with two different points: That it isn't five years after the last record was released, and that there were a lot of people who were disappointed with Green, therefore don't even want to try Maladroit.

Many of my friends have not bought it yet, and don't plan to, even though I tell them it's so much better than Green. Who knows, maybe next week will be better, that's just my view on the whole situation.

Edited by: zen brain at: 5/29/02 8:54:41 pm
phoebecaulfield
The Worst Person Ever.
Posts: 97
(5/29/02 8:49:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
NIN's the fragile debuted at #1 the first week and dropped off the charts forever after that, and many people consider it their best cd.

the market just isnt there for good music

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 345
(5/29/02 8:57:39 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Surfer, are you fucking joking? "Hash Pipe" was nominated for a video award because it wasn't forgettable.

brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 330
(5/29/02 9:01:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
it's true that the band hasn't self-promoted as much (besides touring, but that usually only reaches people who will buy the album). I think rivers' attitude of not wanting to play the industry games and whatnot have kept them away from promoting the album more. But even w/o the industry games, the sales aren't horrible.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 629
(5/29/02 9:14:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I could be wrong, but it seems like the fans GAINED through Green far exceed the old fans that were LOST...and besides, there aren't that many old fans, at all, who have 'completely' given up on weezer either. In most cases, the people who used to really be into weezer back in the old days, but were disappointed in Green, still buy their albums(despite that disappointment) because it's new weezer material and that's enough.

Chances are, these people who have actually stopped buying =w= records as a response to Green, never were real fans to begin with...so they don't count. They just liked the first couple albums and don't care either way about weezer in the long run. It's normal for bands to lose a few fairweather buyers here and there throughout their career. I think it's safe to say that =w= still has almost all of its old fans AND a shitload of new fans on top of that.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 407
(5/29/02 9:15:21 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i agree. Green was just more marketable. It sold to core fans + others...... mala is selling to a fraction of that.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 630
(5/29/02 9:20:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
To me, the "Hash Pipe" video is so insignificant, as far as the concept, special effects, and originality is concerned. It just looks like another Siega video to me. The 2 seconds of sumo backup vocals were funny...THAT'S IT. The song("H*** PIPE"!) is what made that video standout.





Argue.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 803
(5/29/02 9:28:09 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
it had a goofy vibe to it that dope nose is missing.

The video for dope nose takes itself way too seriously, where as the video for hash pipe did not.

me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 66
(5/29/02 9:29:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
surfer:

no.

three of my friends taped the video for me when it first premiered, none of them weezer fans. all of them thought it was a hilarious video, and they all loved it.

you are the epitome of a narrow-thinking indie/weezer fan. you just have this inability to see things beyond that. *normal people* really liked that video. fucking 12 sumo wrestlers slam into each other and it slows down to show the blubber flying. they zoom in on a guy's ass that has a huge zit on it. plus the band looked great.

this video was much, MUCH better than the dope nose video. more people talked about it, more people liked it, more people remembered it. and videos are very important for selling a lot of records these days.

Edited by: me be beatlleweez at: 5/29/02 9:29:32 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 631
(5/29/02 9:35:42 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Thanks for your uninformed 'fan type' assessment me be.

ace
I am no longer a man.
I paint my fingernails!
Teehee! ^_^

Posts: 308
(5/29/02 9:41:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
in preparing for the world cup, the u.s. men's national team plays a number of "friendly" matches against other teams. These games provide an opportunity for the coach to try out different formations, players and strategies without tarnishing
his world cup record. the fans, however, get upset when they see the u.s. losing 2-0 in the second half and the coach STILL toying with unproven players or formations. they want to win EVERY game. the coach remains steadfast in his approach, knowing that, in the interest of the development of the team, he must allow them the space to experiment, gather first-hand experience of all techniques
and extremes and hone their instincts so that, one day, they can be the greatest team on the planet.

kyle vh2

Posts: 335
(5/29/02 9:44:25 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
I don't think people want to wait until the end of the world cup to get another great weezer album.

raf
from africa
Posts: 98
(5/29/02 9:45:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
genius, bro.

weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 176
(5/29/02 9:46:35 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
dope nose video takes itself too seriously?? bahahaa..........

the best part of hash pipe to me was the green background. it just struck me as being smart. siega does a fine job.

raf
from africa
Posts: 99
(5/29/02 9:48:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
one day, my friends.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 372
(5/29/02 9:49:03 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i guess ace agrees with surfer about the content of the album accounting for its chart position

or maybe he's saying that he's just not trying to make it more successfuly than it is

Dude E
Registered User
Posts: 100
(5/29/02 9:49:48 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
But if you're already winning every game, why try to change things?

bathroommonkey
Registered User
Posts: 99
(5/29/02 9:51:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
this was but a test to see if that style worked

mr bridegur
Registered User
Posts: 100
(5/29/02 9:55:16 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
because apparently, dude e, it doesn't take the GREATEST TEAM EVER to win every game. ace wants the GREATEST team ever, not just the good team that somehow still manages to win all the time

oh, and i forgot to mention that i want the GREATEST TEAM EVER as well

Edited by: mr bridegur at: 5/29/02 10:27:17 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 632
(5/29/02 9:58:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
ace's 'plan' seems to teeter back and forth between completely spontaneous and highly calculated.

me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 67
(5/29/02 10:05:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
bridegur- yah.

surfer- sorry if that sounded malicious. it wasn't meant to be. but much of what you'll post, especially in trying to figure out what the general populace would like, is completely off-target in a very indie-minded fashion. most of the people i know are NOT like that at all, and i was never *really* part of that world, so i see most things from a more generalized perspective. when you post on this kind of messageboard every day, it's easy to forget that EVERYONE ELSE doesn't do so, and nobody looks at things the way that we do.

in conclusion, i don't know what else you posted in this thread and therefore can't comment on it, but the hash pipe video was VERY instrumental in getting a lot of hype for the green album. and this was, of course, added to everything else that was good for the atmosphere surrounding weezer at that time (as well as the higher sales, in general).

so yeah.

Page 1 2 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index