← Back to RCA Index

The Rivers Correspondence Board
    > Rivers Correspondence Board
        > Maladroit fell to #16
New Topic    Add Reply

Page 1 2

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 804
(5/29/02 10:22:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
good to hear that ace is taking it in stride.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 409
(5/29/02 10:23:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i'd like a #3 to #16 chart position drop to take in stride, please

Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 5/29/02 10:39:33 pm
The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 633
(5/29/02 10:31:44 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Me be, it was more bold than malicious. You fail to recognize that when I post on these matters of what's commercial or not commercial, it's actually the exact opposite of what you think. I am making an effort to completely seperate myself from my personal feelings about weezer, and look at things the way the casual listener would. That's where I arrive at all of my conclusions. What would make you think otherwise? The whole reason I think Maladroit is a commercial disaster is because I am thinking about it from the perspective of the average TRL Teenybopper. I have often said that the songs I think would make horrible singles are actually some of my PERSONAL favorites on the album. I also said "Dope Nose" would fall, and continue to fall even after the release of the album because of how I felt it would be received in the form of a 'single'(despite it probably being my fave song on Maladroit)...and it has. How am I not taking into consideration what EVERYONE ELSE thinks?

I don't think "Hash Pipe" is award-winning material so I am deemed a narrow minded, indie elitist of some sort? OK. "Buddy Holly" was a music video masterpiece, highly deserving of an award..."Hash Pipe" pales in comparison. It's an alright video, just seems like nothing too special at all.

You're on a high horse or something.

me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 69
(5/29/02 10:50:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
i'd respond and elaborate further, but i don't want this to turn into a personal argument.

i will say this, though: if i'm on a high horse, then everyone is. all i ever do is state opinion here. and all i added in this thread was to say where i'm coming from. and i think that what i've said on this thread is more fact than just my own personal opinion. it's based on reactions ive seen from friends of mine who arent weezer fans (not just the hash pipe vid thing), all the crap i've read over the past year, stuff i've seen on mtv, e-t-c.

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 346
(5/29/02 10:51:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Who gives a fuck if it's alright? You said that it was no better than "Dope Nose", which is wrong!

Ace, if you really want to try different strategies, then make "Take Control" the next single. Do it to it!

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 634
(5/29/02 11:15:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
high horse = "[surfer] you are the epitome of a narrow-thinking indie/weezer fan."

...I simply don't understand what that was based on or how it was even relevant to what we were discussing, especially when everything I've ever said points the opposite direction.

Somehow, not sharing your opinion translates into 'the EPITOME of a narrow-minded INDIE/weezer fan?' Strange.




...and the "Hash Pipe" vid is still not that much better than the "Dope Nose" vid, 'IMO.' ;)

Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 350
(5/29/02 11:16:31 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Wrong, I tells ya!

me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 70
(5/29/02 11:21:48 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
surfer

oh, that.
well, i've just noticed this about you, and i think it, so i said it. but many people on these boards do that, that's just the nature of most of the people here and on the rebel board, and such. it just gets irritating sometimes, and one of those times happened to be just now. no high horse, though.

edit: ok, basically i think you try to know what everyone else thinks, but are never successful in it. that's all. but this is getting dumb so ______.

edit #2: please forget i said anything.

Edited by: me be beatlleweez at: 5/29/02 11:31:52 pm
Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 351
(5/29/02 11:27:23 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Is etcetera @#%$?

etc.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 635
(5/29/02 11:29:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
Noticed WHAT about me?

I could see you calling me stubborn, gay, opinionated, etc...

...but 'narrow-minded INDIE fan???' It's the choice of words that I'm not getting.



EDIT: Haha...'cause I was gonna' say; a narrow-minded person who tries to know what everyone else thinks?...hmmm. That's something to ponder.

Edited by: The Lonely Surfer at: 5/29/02 11:36:06 pm
Cyprine
Registered User
Posts: 77
(5/29/02 11:49:06 pm)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
it's my personal opinion that with the right gimmick, you can pander shit to TRLers. Me Be is definitely right in that "Hash Pipe" was a far more marketable video than "Dope Nose". Maladroit isn't gimmick-filled, which could be the problem, but it's a great album which could stand on its own. I think awareness is still the issue.

darknluvly77
Registered User
Posts: 62
(5/29/02 11:54:22 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
i personally think that we are much more concerned about how this album will do than rivers is. this album could fail miserably and he wouldn't give a shit. all he wants to do is make music and try to figure out the perfect style.

zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE.
Who knew?

Posts: 297
(5/30/02 12:01:42 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"it's my personal opinion that with the right gimmick, you can pander shit to TRLers."


I thought that was common knowledge..

thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 107
(5/30/02 12:48:37 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
green made the money now they're just mess'n around

Edited by: thenewaves at: 5/30/02 12:49:04 am
VonBean
Registered User
Posts: 70
(5/30/02 1:03:45 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Find the perfect style for what, though? If the idea is to follow the style of Limp Bizkit, the perfect style we're talking about closely parallels what the TRLers and the top 40 kids all like, which in my mind is a path toward greater fame.

I also think that no matter what the intentions were that went into the creation of Maladroit, when you put that much time and energy into the process, you end up caring how it gets received by your audience.

hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 141
(5/30/02 1:41:19 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
i dont think the votes for trl songs are actually calculated and then played. i think when mtv sees a lot of votes they think hmm this might make us money, start playing it, work out with the record company to make them big.

hash pipe only made trl because it was anticipating the mtv movie awards. right after the movie awards ended, hash pipe dropped off trl.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 808
(5/30/02 2:14:32 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Geez surfer. You are such a narrow-minded INDIE fan. :)

Seriously though...i dont think any hard feelings were meant and both of you guys stated your opinion succesfully, so it's cool....


and HASH PIPE IS A MUCH BETTER VIDDY SLUT!

and newt is damn right. listen to him ace.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 637
(5/30/02 2:51:06 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Haha...are you the self-appointed peace mediator of this board now?

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 812
(5/30/02 3:00:15 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
haha. dick.

dev3984
Registered User
Posts: 24
(5/30/02 3:47:05 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
in england maladroit fell from 16 to 49 but thats simply because of no promotion except album reviews.

Like i am wetting my pants in anticipation for england-sweden, i am also anticipating some weezer promotion here. A catchy single (imo keep fishin will go down big here) and a decent video and maladroit is going to sell a hell of a lot.

wherewasmymind
Registered User
Posts: 460
(5/30/02 3:47:34 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
ace is fantastic.

ohnoitgo
Registered User
Posts: 14
(5/30/02 5:20:51 am)
Reply
Re: Maldaroit fell to #16
neal3: Bruce, are you settled on a 4-4-2 formation for the World Cup, or do we make too much of a deal about formations? Many of us see talent in Mathis, Donovan, John O'Brien, Stewart, Claudo, Armas and others and wonder how can they get on the field at the same time.
Bruce Arena: First of all, I do believe fans make too much out of formations. If we switch from a back four that would require us to have outside midfielders who can defend against world-class players. There aren't many countries that have those players, we being one of them. So when we talk about our formation it begins with a back four. In terms of finding the right mix for the next six players, that will be my challenge. Obviously we won't be able to get everyone on the field at the same time. We realize that, and look upon that as a positive decision to have to make...

"Coach," thanks for clarifying the game plan.

Edited by: ohnoitgo at: 5/30/02 5:41:04 am
FabFiveFreddy
Registered User
Posts: 23
(5/30/02 10:16:56 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
i hope maladroit's lack of commerical success won't affect ace's confidence. his comments indicate that he doesn't care about such things, but who knows.

going back to his futbol comment, i wonder what stage of development weezer is in now. how many more albums of experimentation before weezer flips that switch for greatness? of course, brian bell stated in that one interview how he feels like the next album has the potential to be c l a s s i c. what a strange and glorious ride.

ace
I am no longer a man.
I paint my fingernails!
Teehee! ^_^

Posts: 310
(5/30/02 10:51:41 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
i care about success more than anyone i know. i just want a stable, secure, MASSIVE kind of success that only comes with being a fully intuitive artist. intuitions take a while to hone themselves and until they do, it's going to be a bumpy ride. i trust myself completely.

Instant kimbean
Registered User
Posts: 25
(5/30/02 10:54:03 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"i trust myself completely"

i'm glad.

FFeJ and Raven
Registered User
Posts: 164
(5/30/02 10:54:22 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
so do we

Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 245
(5/30/02 10:55:55 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"MASSIVE"

Hope you pull of it off ace, I've got faith as I'm sure most of us do here.

FabFiveFreddy
Registered User
Posts: 24
(5/30/02 10:58:09 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
ace, after the recent drama with interscope, do you feel that you now have the freedom to develop that intuition? what happens after album 5?

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 379
(5/30/02 10:59:50 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
what do you consider "success" to be?

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 341
(5/30/02 11:02:59 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
ace, when you describe this success...who would you say has obtained this success, besides someone like the beatles (i would guess)?

hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 142
(5/30/02 11:30:52 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
he said once he wants a fan base like u2 has

caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 83
(5/30/02 11:37:53 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Well, the fan base might not be as big as U2's yet, but it's ten times more rabid.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 416
(5/30/02 11:48:05 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
My concern is that the type of popularity is not only about the music. Maybe ace should study the sociology of taste as well; music becomes extremely popular like U2 not only because the music is good, but because there are structural reasons within the society that the music has become accepted. Look at Pinkerton: when it first came out, it wasn't given the warmest reception by critics; now all the critics love it. Nothing about the music has changed - it's the social climate that has.

Phenomena like U2 emerge from a certain amount of media hype and cognitive framing. Music is sort of an ambiguous stimulus, and it takes more than just carefully crafted music to get to that Beach Boy, U2, Beatles, REM, Green Day, Nirvana, Pearl Jam-type fame.

Reading up on science of social trends might be just as important in learning how to achieve that popularity as crafting the perfect pop song.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 255
(5/30/02 12:11:30 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
will all the social studies majors please raise their hands?



Merk raises some very good points here. There are, however, examples of bands that have been consistently lauded regardless of social clime (although the exact degree of popularity, of course, exhibits some flux). Some, like U2 and Metallica, have managed to change with the times - although they more and more seem to react to the world around them rather than shape it they way they used to. Others, like the Beatles and @#%$ Floyd, have a limited catalog whose recordings haven't changed since the day they were releaed, yet continue to sell, regardless. Bands like Aerosmith never developed their craft and now must rely on outside songwriters to write their hits. Or rather, their craft is in their particular sound, rather than their songs.

Right now, rivers is focusing on his songwriting craft. So much of what I want to hear from weezer, though, is that particular weezer "sound", becuase it seemed to go hand in hand with good songs. Hopefully ace will turn his attention that way once the songs are "there" - once his songwriting intuition is secure.

GumbyTom
Registered User
Posts: 138
(5/30/02 12:17:23 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Success is nice.

I haven't been disappointed yet.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 417
(5/30/02 12:19:16 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"There are, however, examples of bands that have been consistently lauded regardless of social clime"

My point is not just that bands because popular because of fleeting trends, but a bunch of contingent factors affect whether or not bands will reach that U2 status and whether the media/public will dub certain bands as "timeless" or "trend-defying." hell, the beatles did the cutesy, clean-cut thing for years, and had they not, I am not sure they'd be the legends they are today.

In addition to workin on his craft, ace might want to look at the best way to frame/sell the band.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 256
(5/30/02 12:24:37 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
it's very difficult to do that when the whole business is in a state of flux and upheaval.

framing the band is easiest when there's something definite to frame it against - right now there's just no framework, no "movement".

bathroommonkey
Registered User
Posts: 102
(5/30/02 12:24:55 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
i dont think U2 types success can be had, I think that the success of Niel Young or Elvis Costello is within reach. Those two artist dont sell as much as U2 but they have very good base audiences and are respected.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 257
(5/30/02 12:28:20 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
actually, the only real thing i see to frame against right now is hip-hop. no doubt scored when they shifted their production style to something more like hip-hop's.

gwen is cooler than ace, though (no offense), and it worked because she helped eve get a hit.

FFeJ and Raven
Registered User
Posts: 165
(5/30/02 12:29:50 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
ace probably wants bands studying weezer to find the key to success in 20 years, the way he studies nirvana, green day, the beatles, etc. now. he wants to be an influence on the music people (outside of the rcb) create.

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 155
(5/30/02 12:53:08 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
If you're trying to think of the best way to sell a band, it helps to keep in mind that most TRL viewers don't care what the music sounds like. They like what they are told to like and listen to what they think the cool kids are listening to or what that Carson tool tells them to listen to. The thing that could bounce this album back up the charts is a good video, because the other major thing that the TRL viewer likes, unlike the majority of people that post here, is the look. Flash over substance. If it looks good, they're buying. If weezer can hire a good director with a cool concept, Maladroit can rebound. Hopefully, the video would consist of an i.rony-laden concept that mocks the TRL target audience and/or the record company without either even realizing it.

Alternatively, they could bow to pop pressure and just intercut gratuitous cuddly animals painting Rivers' fingernails with scenes of models in their underwear shaving off his beard to the strains of Take Control. I doubt it gets more anti-Siega than that and it probably wouldn't tarnish weezer's record, thereby allowing ace's plan of world domination to move forward unhindered.

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 122
(5/30/02 1:04:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
the thing is that weezer, in the minds of most people, is a band of happy nerds who sing about buddy holly and sweaters. hash pipe was successfull not because it broke the mold of what weezer was, but because people thought the idea of these happy nerds singing about a hash pipe was funny. it's that whole i.rony and tongue in cheek thing that has followed the band everywhere their entire career.

on the other hand, when dope nose came out with rivers sporting a beard in the video, i think it gets two reactions from the two main audiences in todays music, nu metal fans and TRL fans: the nu metal kids say: "these guys arent real druggies, they're trying too hard to look like it" ; and the TRL kids are seeing a bearded misanthrope instead of their happy nerd, and hence they reject it as well. which explains why maladroit sells roughly 175,000 copies the first week, which is probably around the number of fans who would go out to see a weezer concert, and then bombs the next week. maladroit and dope nose, outside of the true fans of the band, has been pretty unsuccessful. but i think with the right singles (keep fishin followed by take control) and the right promotion, sales can get back on track.

i think the only way rivers can get out of the stereotype is if he made some sort of cameo in a limp bizkit video. but then again, thats a double edged sword, since his "hardcore" fanbase would turn on him in a second, and the general populace still might not accept weezer in the limp bizkit/no doubt, etc vein of pop. ace has always had to walk on that fine line.

it'll be interesting to see how things turn out. i think three different scenarios could happen; 1) ace goes back to the clean-cut nerd image, writes happy songs, and creates his own small niche in pop music. 2) ace continues to try to break the weezer image, but fails and weezer drops off the map. or 3) ace writes an undeniably c.lassic album and completely changes the landscape of modern music.

now the question is, what are the elements needed for a @#%$ album from weezer....i think its a combo of blue and pinkerton.

Edited by: TotalRequestLive at: 5/30/02 1:06:31 pm
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 200
(5/30/02 2:07:18 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
screw record sales. its supposed to be about 'art' or something. the chicks are great though

Edited by: Nathaniel Hornblower at: 5/30/02 2:11:19 pm
InsaneCuomoPosse2k2
Registered User
Posts: 59
(5/30/02 3:41:55 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
well all that matters is that interscope doesn't shit a brick over this. which i dont think they will. although im starting to wonder if it'll take another big drop in week 3 or stay in the high teen area. this should not effect album 5. the release on that sounded like a done deal however im not so sure we're gonna get that 6 song summer ep now.

TotalRequestLive
Registered User
Posts: 123
(5/30/02 4:08:11 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
itll keep sliding until another single comes out

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 342
(5/30/02 4:21:18 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
but u2 has not been consistently popular. they weren't popular for at least 3 years in a row, when that POP album came out and a couple of albums before that that just plain blew butthole. very few artists have the type of success where you can screw up but it doesn't matter because you'll still sell the same amount of albums. that's usually only trendy stars who can pull that off, if this is indeed what ace is talking about.

agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 192
(5/30/02 4:36:04 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"If you're trying to think of the best way to sell a band, it helps to keep in mind that most TRL viewers don't care what the music sounds like."

As much I think the trl audience is a manipulated group who fall victim to most, if not all, of the industry's ploys to take their money, that statement is just not true. It may be true to an extent that they will listen to something if it's cool or whatever, but the only reason anyone (yes anyone) really listens to music is if they like the sound or not.

I have had many talks with people who dont give a shit about "fighting the man" and whatnot. I will say, how could you buy otown's album? They are pathetic enough to openly admit to being a manufactured band. And they will say, I dont care about that. I like the songs. They sound really good.

Anyone who listens to music cares about the sound. The trl audience may be manipulated, but that doesnt mean that they dont like what they listen to.

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 430
(5/30/02 4:42:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
I wish the music industry wasn't so corrupt... it takes a LOT to get past the strict-business aspect of it all. If somehow ace could whip up some-sort of intense, amazing album that catered to the basic and complex music needs of society (without sounding like limp or creed)- then maybe they could make more out of their dent in pop-music history.

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 156
(5/30/02 4:50:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
That's probably true, agentman. But I still think the majority of what the typical TRL fan buys is what they like to look at over what they like to listen to. Even more so, what they are manipulated into watching and thinking is "popular", which them becomes popular by default. If they are listening to the music and buying based on that, then they don't even fit into what I would define as the typical TRL sheep. But judging by the crap that hits and sticks at the top of the charts, I still think the majority of young record buyers purchase flash over substance.

the citizen of wen
custom title
Posts: 258
(5/30/02 5:11:26 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
How flashy is Vanessa Carlton?

0% flashy.

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 432
(5/30/02 6:22:58 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
is she the chick who is playing a piano on something that's being driven on a highway... or is she the other chick who looks EXACTLY like her?

Johnny5alex
Registered User
Posts: 28
(5/30/02 6:28:18 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
brody, the u2 comments not really true, their two albums before pop were achtung baby and zooropa, which were both pretty successful. the zoo tv was huge and was a breakthrough in touring. pop the album wasnt that successful, but the tour for it wasn't a flop...

wherewasmymind
Registered User
Posts: 461
(5/30/02 6:28:49 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
I wish I had the same confidence in myself as ace does, on a personal level. Most people don't.

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 434
(5/30/02 6:34:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
what are you talking about!

Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 343
(5/30/02 6:36:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
true johnny5, but their popularity had dropped quite a bit after pop and before ATYCLB. but true, they have been more consistently popular than any other group today.

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 638
(5/30/02 6:57:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Jimmy Eat World - "The Middle" - Modern Rock Billboard Chart: Peak position #1 - 31 weeks on the chart...all over TRL.

...explain that one.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 816
(5/30/02 7:03:46 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
that wasn't a constant on TRL. In fact, it was barely on there. Made it as a close call more then anything.

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 435
(5/30/02 7:26:16 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Surfer: EASY- ATTRACTIVE PEOPLE IN THEIR UNDERWEAR.



wait... what was the question?

Edited by: SkyBlue523202 at: 5/30/02 7:27:17 pm
RBHIDWes
Registered User
Posts: 21
(5/30/02 8:12:49 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
does anyone have the actual sales numbers for the first week on both green and maladroit? i think thats a more telling story.

raf
from africa
Posts: 107
(5/30/02 8:25:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
green - 215,000
maladroit - 152,000

i think.

Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 817
(5/30/02 8:26:12 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
already discussed it.

VonBean
Registered User
Posts: 71
(5/31/02 12:17:07 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
I think some of the questions here that allude to different kinds of success are key. In my opinion, I wonder if the music business is set up in such a way as to limit the viewpoints of artists in order to make the most amount of room for the massive market of the TRL crowd. Would anyone consider themselves a 'success' if they were the king of that kind of music? What if it made you very, very, rich? While I agree that it takes time to hone one's intuition, I also wonder if in some ways this kind of success requires someone to first tune it out, because such independent creativity would challenge the TRL consensus of what constitutes success in the music biz. Of course, in order to tune it out, one must be cognizant of it first. Is it a case of getting to the top before you can bust out what you consider to be your best stuff, independent of financial pressures, etc.?

Brody783: correct me if I am wrong, but did you suggest that U2 made all crap prior to Pop? I consider Joshua Tree to be one of the greatest rock albums of all time. All time. I don't want to get in a debate about U2 here, but I think it should be more that everything post-Pop wasn't remotely as good as the U2 of the 80s.

Johnny5alex
Registered User
Posts: 30
(5/31/02 1:05:34 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
brody was saying in the few years prior to pop that u2 wasnt as popular, not that they werent good before pop. they were good in 80s yes, its true. hes not debating that. but the fact is, they were still very popular in thew few years before pop

ace
I am no longer a man.
I paint my fingernails!
Teehee! ^_^

Posts: 311
(5/31/02 4:26:21 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
my definition of success:

68.66.32.232:85/korea/weezer.html

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 67
(5/31/02 4:32:23 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
ah..i agree with you there...

as long as your music is making it across the globe and across cultural boundaries and enjoyed by many weezer is successful...

chart ratings are rather unimportant in the whole scheme of things...much greater emphasis on the impact that your music has than on the record sales..

...although it can be argued the other way, i think i agree with you there ace..

edit: i duno if that was a joke...god its late...er..early...but i still hold to my views..

Edited by: or0phin at: 5/31/02 4:33:34 am
Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 181
(5/31/02 4:33:17 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
It seems as if they'd prefer telling the kids about Weezer in school rather than telling about Mozart or something. Now that's quite an accomplishment.

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 68
(5/31/02 4:34:12 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
classical music shouldnt be forgotten though..mix the old and the new...

Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 182
(5/31/02 4:36:23 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Well, actually I'd be really happy if I'd hear Weezer in school at all, don't get me wrong.

or0phin
Registered User
Posts: 69
(5/31/02 4:38:25 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
true, i always wished that a 'modern rock class' was taught at my college...

my personal goal is to teach a 'history of rock' class when/if i become a prof...focussing on major bands from every decade..which would of course include nirvana and weezer...

catch624
Registered User
Posts: 86
(5/31/02 6:15:16 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
The u2 remarks are not accurate, since Pop was not really well received and the tour, in spite of making money, was considered a failure by the media. Many U2 fans were waiting for the band to repeat the sound & success of The Joshua Tree, which they basically did w/ All That You Can't Leave Behind. See a parallel w/ the Weezer fans that are still waiting for another Blue or Pinkerton?

I think core fans know that each record is just a step on the journey. Since Ace is in it for the long haul and not just the immediate gratification of a hit single, i don't think the rapid demise (if that's really what it is) of Maladroit is that big of a deal.

And while the sound counts too, the image is all important in the TRL world, and they just aren't gonna buy the beard. But ultimately, who cares as long as Weezer gets to keep making the records they want to.

this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 380
(5/31/02 9:07:23 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
has anyone listened to the mp3's on ace's link? lmao!!!1!1!!

RASTE MY DEY!!!

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 445
(5/31/02 10:55:53 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
classical music is great- just as satisfying to play as listening to a weezer cd.

mikeweezer21
Registered User
Posts: 69
(5/31/02 10:57:14 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
Those mp3s are @#%$. The waste my day/doowah guy needs a recording contract...

SkyBlue523202
I STILL RESPECT YA, BABY.
Posts: 450
(5/31/02 11:40:44 am)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
in-fucking-credible- ACE has reached the peak! (j/k)

BPrend
Registered User
Posts: 80
(5/31/02 1:00:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
those mp3s are the single greatest things i have ever heard

Johnny5alex
Registered User
Posts: 31
(5/31/02 1:13:43 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
catch624, who are you referring to? cause i said that pop wasnt that big of a success, but the tour was commercially successfull. but yeah, the media did like it. my point was the two albums before pop and the tour for them, zoo tv, were huge, unlike what brody first said

hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 143
(5/31/02 1:19:53 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
those girls are lame, the guys rock it hard though

UserGay
Registered User
Posts: 20
(5/31/02 4:52:34 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
hoho that is some funny shit.

Johnny5alex
Registered User
Posts: 35
(5/31/02 5:01:45 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
you can tell the one dude on the guys one thinks hes really funny

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 641
(5/31/02 5:25:17 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
U2 has a sound that transcends time. It will always carry over to any stylistic change or shift in cultural climate that may occur, and still sound new, fresh, and cutting edge.

Bono is also really good at pulling off the cheese and the phony(or not so phony) passion...and he speaks his political mind on a variety of awareness issues. It helps make his band seem more 'important', giving them that honorable legendary status.

Alot of you guys are probably right...there's alot more to it than just the music(which is Ace's sole focus)...as far as being HUGE anyway. Think about The Beatles(John Lennon), Bob Dylan, Grateful Dead, etc; bands that are widely recognized as EXTREMELY important to the history and evolution of pop music/pop culture. They were all top notch social-political bullshitters.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 422
(5/31/02 5:32:28 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
U2 indeed has a boring, timeless sound.

the should have been a one-hit wonder (Sunday Bloody Sunday)

The Lonely Surfer
Registered User
Posts: 642
(5/31/02 5:37:21 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
(New Year's Day)

roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 161
(5/31/02 8:58:14 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
one hit wonder? they already had hits with I Will Follow and Gloria off their previous two albums. they had so much energy back then and War made you feel they had a message even if your view was through a lens of cynicism. they kicked ass back then and have had amazing longevity.

MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 430
(6/2/02 1:46:47 pm)
Reply
Re: Maladroit fell to #16
"We're actually releasing the next album on EBay, 'cause we think we can get a better royalty rate." --Pat Wilson of Weezer (2001).

From LA Times

Page 1 2 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Topic Control Image Topic Commands (Moderator only)
Subscribe Click to receive email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers Correspondence Board - Rivers CorrespondAnce Home Page -



Powered By ezboardÆ Ver. 6.8.5.4
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.

← Back to RCA Index