|
Author
|
Comment
|
rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 444
(6/1/02 5:36:20 pm)
Reply
|
An accurate article, finally.
May 16, 2002
Weezer revisits distorted glory on infectious new album, Maladroit
By Josh Korr
Diamondback staff writer
This world would be a far better place if the words "Weezer" and "geek rock" were never again used in the same sentence. Or better yet, if the words "geek rock" were expunged from our collective vocabulary altogether.
It's not entirely fair to blame the commercial failure of Pinkerton, Weezer's 1996 masterpiece, on pigeonholing, any more than we can pin the tepid response to Pearl Jam's last three studio albums on the music press not knowing what to do when the band outlasted the grunge fad.
After all, Rivers Cuomo and company played a major part in creating a certain image, just as Pearl Jam did (compare Eddie Vedder in the "Jeremy" video with Cuomo in "Buddy Holly").
But come on - how many "Revenge of the Geeks" stories did we need to read when Weezer suddenly reappeared and reaffirmed the nobility of pop with a sold-out tour in 2000 and last year's Weezer (The Green Album)? Do we really still have to talk about horn-rims and Dungeons & Dragons?
Lucky for us, Cuomo is a cocky bastard and knows both how good he is and how little such talent needs the modern music machine. He's ignored the entreaties of record-label execs as well as the music press' lazy categorizing and delivered another jewel of a pop-rock album, Maladroit, one year after The Green Album.
The rawk answer to Green's pop sheen, Maladroit finds Cuomo and fellow guitarist Brian Bell in full-on, crank-up-the-distortion-and-shred mode.
The album is a kick in the ass to all the @#%$-metal bands that don't know what melody is and think buying a top-of-the-line fuzz pedal makes them hardcore; the freak-out instrumental chorus of "Burndt Jamb" rocks harder than Linkin Park ever could - and isn't unintelligibly tinny like Rage Against the Machine and its progeny.
Finger-tap metal licks fill out the anthemic pre-chorus of "Take Control," a Brian May riff pops up unexpectedly in the rave-up section of the otherwise plaintive "Death and Destruction" - but this is no metal or glam album, not even a self-conscious faux-metal one.
It's a Weezer album; '80s guitar-god tricks aside, Maladroit belongs in its own sub-genre of rock. Who else but Rivers Cuomo could incorporate the melody of "Do The Locomotion" into the most fun love song since "El Scorcho?" "So jump out, jump out, get your groove on/This one is for you so come on/Get out yer house, girl, and give me a kiss" ("Love Explosion").
Just how good Cuomo is remains to be seen, but this much is for sure: He's a pop genius in the tradition of Lennon/McCartney and Brian Wilson. He has the same preternatural grasp of melody, is a prolific songwriter, and so far has proven likewise incapable of writing bad songs (43 songs, over four albums, without a single melodic misstep).
Like the Beatles and the Beach Boys, Weezer started off making unabashed pop music about innocuous teenage topics.
But the Beatles didn't magically produce Revolver, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band and The White Album - they developed, musically and lyrically, over the course of seven albums between 1963 and 1965; the Beach Boys preceded Pet Sounds with 11(!) albums between '62 and '65. Shunning Weezer aside as a grunge-era novelty act wasted what should have been five extraordinarily productive years, and leaves the band in a curious place.
For all of Cuomo's expertise with melody, harmony and catchy riffs, the band has yet to make an album that sounds as good as it should. The Ric Ocasek-produced Blue and Green albums are too thin and clean; Pinkerton is too sludgy - effectively so, considering the rawness of the guitars and Cuomo's singing, but sludgy nonetheless.
Maladroit's production is uneven. Most songs start out with clear, dueling guitars panned to either speaker, but on some of the loud, harmony-laden choruses, particularly in "Slob" and "Space Rock," everything gets shoved to the center and becomes mush. This isn't emotionally ragged messiness like on Pinkerton - it's just mush. Cuomo's vocals are submerged too far down in the mix, and even Pat Wilson's crash-the-speakers drumming gets lost at times. And new bassist Scott Shriner barely makes his presence known.
If Cuomo is going to take the next leap forward, he needs to figure out how to use the recording studio as an instrument - as the Beatles and Beach Boys did 35 years ago. He has to figure out whether the anonymous Scott Shriner (who replaced the anonymous @#%$ @#%$) is really the right replacement for long-departed bassist Matt Sharp, who gave Blue and Pinkerton much of their personalities with his playful falsetto backing vocals and actual bass lines.
And, now that he's proven beyond a doubt that pop isn't a dirty word, Cuomo needs to move beyond verse-chorus-bridge-solo-chorus and quickie lyrics and explore the things that pop can't do.
|
thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 118
(6/1/02 6:11:04 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
I agree w/ this part... not so much the maatt scott stuff, but the studio... more studio wizardry -p-l-z-
"If Cuomo is going to take the next leap forward, he needs to figure out how to use the
recording studio as an instrument - as the Beatles and Beach Boys did 35 years ago. He
has to figure out whether the anonymous Scott Shriner (who replaced the anonymous
@#%$ @#%$) is really the right replacement for long-departed bassist Matt Sharp, who
gave Blue and Pinkerton much of their personalities with his playful falsetto backing
vocals and actual bass lines."....
Edited by: thenewaves at: 6/1/02 6:11:50 pm
|
wherewasmymind
Registered User
Posts: 469
(6/1/02 6:28:11 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Burndt Jamb has an actual bassline, one of the best and most fitting I've heard. Too bad it is buried on the album version.
|
MerkinMuffley
Natalie spy
Posts: 429
(6/1/02 6:39:56 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
the misinformed shit about scott shouldn't cancel out some of the better arguments of the article (about the studio and whatnot)
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 6/1/02 8:02:44 pm
|
phemayle
Registered User
Posts: 90
(6/1/02 7:15:30 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
good article, i like the fact the writter belives and tries to prove that we havent seen the best of weez
"But the Beatles didn't magically produce Revolver, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band and The White Album - they developed, musically and lyrically, over the course of seven albums between 1963 and 1965;"
thats the problem, the way the music biz system works now an artist can't grow fully... seven albums between 63' and 65'... now thats prolific
|
me be beatlleweez
FUCKING NERD
Posts: 89
(6/1/02 7:52:24 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
good article, definitely. i really don't like that stuff said about scott in the end though. he basically judged scott's abilities based on how well he was able to hear the basslines in the mix. retarded.
Edited by: me be beatlleweez at: 6/1/02 7:53:35 pm
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 1449
(6/1/02 8:11:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
*raises post count*
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 344
(6/1/02 8:23:38 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
well, that is good for some guy who probably didn't hear scott's ability through the maladriot sessions and the live shows. It's all about potential.
|
Newt Floss
gay, yet useful.
Posts: 358
(6/1/02 8:41:31 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
If Scott would just give in and sing falsetto, he'd be the the best evar!!!
|
thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 119
(6/1/02 8:54:36 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
the falsetto would be nice...
|
gogokain
Calm down.
Posts: 415
(6/1/02 9:12:37 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
I think there's a reason why Brian does the falsetto shit now.
|
ridd1
*queen of the forum*
Posts: 918
(6/1/02 10:07:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
scott does the falsetto bit in Surf Wax. Pretty good, too.
|
Johnny5alex
Registered User
Posts: 38
(6/1/02 10:07:46 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
i dont think thats what he meant me be. the fact that there arent as complex of bass lines as m.atts, is what i think he is trying to say
|
zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE. Who knew?
Posts: 301
(6/1/02 10:32:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
What's nice is that the reviewer focused on both credible positives and negatives of the album. He didn't just simply say such such sucks, but rather gave advice. I do agree with the recording studio bit, probably the best advice I've heard in awhile, would definitely help to clear some of the inconsistancies up.
|
darknluvly77
Registered User
Posts: 64
(6/1/02 10:34:27 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
yeah but did he compare scott's basslines to m.ikey's at all? listen to the green album and then listen to maladroit. big difference!!
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 165
(6/1/02 10:50:17 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
The same guy reviewed TGA: www.wam.umd.edu/~jskorr/weezer.html
I was surprised that he claimed to have not purchased TBA until spring of 2000. One of my first thoughts on reading this latest review was that he seemed like too much of a fan to be truly objective as a reviewer for a publication. He's definitely a fan and pretty well-informed but, with the exception of his apparent bass player bias, I guess it's a fair article/review.
|
mike or mike cool
tooloudturnitdown
Posts: 26
(6/1/02 11:19:32 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
twas a pretty decent article. The only part I disagree with is scott being anonymous. He's all over that fucking album.
|
this niblet
Aronofsky
Posts: 384
(6/2/02 12:28:24 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
wow, that review of green is really good too
i'm gonna have to try to ignore anything other than what this guy writes after album 5 comes out
|
SkyBlue523202
skyblue rules...
Posts: 463
(6/2/02 1:25:19 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
take out the false-interp of scott and you've got yourself a solid piece of writing.
|
Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 250
(6/2/02 1:36:52 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
At one time i remember Ace claiming that he didn't want a band that couldn't sound live just like they did on the album. This could thwart the movement to using the studio as an intstrument. Than again, we are talking about Rivers Cuomo, who changes his mind every day, so who knows.
|
ace
I am no longer a man. I paint my fingernails! Teehee! ^_^
Posts: 312
(6/2/02 9:24:44 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
check out the new keep fishin' for a step in this direction
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 196
(6/2/02 9:26:47 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
is that the maladroit song you have been reworking ace? are we getting an mp3?
|
Slim Mackeral
silm pensi *lolz*
Posts: 498
(6/2/02 9:36:14 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
of course it is.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 197
(6/2/02 9:40:19 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
yeah it was a stupid question. i was more asking about the mp3.
Edited by: agentman007 at: 6/2/02 9:41:29 am
|
ace
I am no longer a man. I paint my fingernails! Teehee! ^_^
Posts: 314
(6/2/02 9:56:51 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
of course you are
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 1457
(6/2/02 10:23:05 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
PI
|
Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 185
(6/2/02 10:23:33 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Well thank you! I can't wait to hear it! What did you change about it?
|
Q Burt
Rock!!!
Posts: 119
(6/2/02 10:23:58 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Matt's basslines weren't "more complex" than Scott's! Both bassplayers are a completly different style and I guess the writer just likes Matt's style better!
|
zen brain
HOLY SHIT. FEMALE. Who knew?
Posts: 302
(6/2/02 10:50:48 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Agreed Q-burt. Some people will just never accept that Matt's gone and will never like any further bass player. Kind of like Buddyhead, they are obviously Matt fans, and have since just found every reason to bash Weezer whenever possible, even though some of the things are quite humorous.
I honestly feel Scott's the best bass player Weezer's ever had.
|
tired of chex
Registered User
Posts: 45
(6/2/02 10:57:09 am)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
thanks ace.
scott r0x0rz.
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 345
(6/2/02 12:14:49 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
haha.. told you all that the next single should be keep fishin'.. we wasted a whole goddamn thread on how to improve slave too.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 205
(6/2/02 12:21:49 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
the Beach Boys recorded 12 albums between '63 and '65
|
Weezer99er
Registered User
Posts: 252
(6/2/02 7:02:28 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Ace, aren't you concerned with people buying Maladroit after hearing your 'new' Keep Fishin, and then being disapointed when it sounds different on the origanal album? Will future releases of the album have the new version on it?
|
Real Frogs
FREE PORN!!!
Posts: 565
(6/2/02 7:55:59 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
Thank god for this.
That generic, sterile, uniform studio sound started getting under my skin around the second minute of "Don't Let Go."
Yes, yes, this is good.
|
gogokain
Calm down.
Posts: 417
(6/2/02 8:10:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: An accurate article, finally.
I hope the new Keep Fishin' is just like the pointfest version, but with a string quartet and no percussion.
|