|
Author
|
Comment
|
kyle vh2

Posts: 418
(6/16/02 10:00:56 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
...you make a good point. I guess I assumed he was referring to the 'production wise, structurally, and shit like that' of the songs, instead of the rock opera part of it. If he wanted an opinion on that, I figured he'd say, 'do you prefer this to a regular album'.
|
anToneJ28
oh.
Posts: 463
(6/16/02 10:10:48 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes, when it comes to song structure, a definite yes
|
BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 290
(6/16/02 10:15:31 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Queero brings up a good point and i agree with him. it is all about the quality of the song, but the black hole songs structure is a lot better than the normal maladroit style struction and i would rather listen to a black hole song just becuase of the structure of the song. Queero also brought up the fact that rock operas and concept albums leave room for gay, but i dont see that with weezer...with other bands yes, but Rivers wont let a rock opera/concept album turn out totally gay.
|
renthepen w2910
Registered User
Posts: 13
(6/16/02 10:25:28 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I agree with Querro when he says that "It's just all about how good the songs are. "
This is the only important subject matter. Who cares about how cool is the style when the content sucks? Concept album or not, the only real importance is if the songs are good.
In response to Querro's last post, I wonder if we will dig the unreleased stuff from the green era, like Ayleen and Castle in the sand, if we get to hear these songs in a few years. It is true that we (well I do this) always give more importance to the "rare" stuff, like if it was giving another dimension to the song.
|
kyle vh2

Posts: 422
(6/16/02 10:32:24 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"This is the only important subject matter. Who cares about how cool is the style when the content sucks? Concept album or not, the only real importance is if the songs are good."
I don't think this is necessarily true, I've seen a lot of posts about 'Come To My Pod' and 'This Is Not For Me' saying, 'these are kinda weird, but they sound great in the context'. This context factor is much more important in Songs From The Black Hole than it is in, say, Maladroit.
|
mrtpitiesfools
I like stretch marks.
Posts: 339
(6/16/02 10:32:57 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I would love to hear Castles in the Sand. The title always intrigued me.
|
BullSchmidt61
Registered User
Posts: 294
(6/16/02 10:38:57 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I also agree with Kyle. Prime example of what Kyle said: Another Brick in the Wall part 1.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 363
(6/16/02 10:46:47 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
agreed, it's like having "Happiest Days of Our Lives" without having "Another Brick in the Wall Part 2".
off topic, but i always thought Another Brick in the Wall part 1 sounds pretty cool on its own, though i know what you mean.
|
sch2383
Registered User
Posts: 132
(6/16/02 11:11:52 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I would want to hear all of the SFTBH songs fleshed out before I decide on one or the other. But Queero is right, no matter how much something rocks (or tries to), it will still suck if the contents of the songs suck.
|
scaldalupo
Registered User
Posts: 147
(6/16/02 11:13:37 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I like Happiest Days alone too actually, but consider the point well understood. In the case of Oh No..., it's really a transition piece, but it still is kickass on its own. I don't really think you can have something that isn't great become suddenly amazing when put into context.
|
dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 238
(6/16/02 11:55:39 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
rezee:
I have reason to prefer maladroit. It is because I would rather have a good collection of rocking pop songs than some rock opera that borders on musical t.heatre styles. I love 'blast off' and the pinkerton songs that came from SFTBH, but "come to my pod" and "oh no, this is not for me" just don't stand up as individual songs. I mean "this is not for me" is barely over 30 seconds. And maladroit songs are all consistantly kick ass.
and I've been signing my name for over a year that I've been an ezboard weezer messageboard member, and you're the first to be bothered by it. What should bother you is that I misspelled my own name.
edit: t.heatre is @#%$????
Wilson
Edited by: dageeklove at: 6/16/02 11:57:18 pm
|
raf
African princess.
Posts: 226
(6/16/02 11:57:05 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
da geek, just wondering, what are your favorite bands?
|
Kelly Kapowski Loves Me
in teh butt, plz.
Posts: 987
(6/16/02 11:58:03 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
No on the songs.
Yes on the emotion.
|
rezeeWeerez
I am Penis.
Posts: 499
(6/16/02 11:59:52 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"maladroit songs are all consistantly kick ass"
this is where I disagree with you.
no point in further arguing.
- rezeew
|
dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 239
(6/17/02 12:16:51 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
dude, I have a wide range of musical tastes. Ben Folds (Five), Belle & Sebastian, R.adiohead, Pedro the Lion, Nick Drake, Bob Dylan, John Prine, Lucinda Williams, The Beach Boys, REM, Beck, Nirvana, Gillian Welch, Burt Bacharach, The Roots
That covers most genres that I like.
rezee: I'm gonna take back my "kick ass" comment. There are obviously weak tracks on Maladroit. I just don't think any of them are as weak as "Come to my Pod". An argument has been made that though the song is wierd, it would be good in context. Well, I say the song is still weak, and a weak song in context is still a weak song.
Wilson
Edited by: dageeklove at: 6/17/02 12:18:46 am
|
thenewaves
Registered User
Posts: 143
(6/17/02 1:41:14 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
YES
|
Honkey Doorie
Registered User
Posts: 183
(6/17/02 9:04:39 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"Concept albums have incredible potential for gay"
here's one concept album that fits that catagory...
styx: kilroy was here
but if SFTBH could be pulled off the right way it could be as kick ass as the wall (conceptually, not production-wise) and/or SMiLE (from what i have heard of it)
so yes and no...depends...i need to hear more...there is no way to come to a conclusion in one answer..
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 118
(6/17/02 9:29:15 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Id rather have come to my pod / oh no this is not for me than any of maladroit.
|
Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 203
(6/17/02 9:43:35 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
It's hard to say. But I'd say yes, just because there was enough simple pop music in the last two years. I like both Green and Maladroit, but now for something completely different, please.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 265
(6/17/02 9:58:00 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Yes
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 386
(6/17/02 10:10:42 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
in style.. a solid rock album beats a concept album. Concept albums have potential to be horrible missteps but they also have the potential to be amazing and groundbreaking. I don't think it's about that though... it's all about quality of the songs, and i'll take my 37 seconds of "oh no.." over most of maladroit. There's just something amazing and intriguing about sftbh.. meaning the passion in the music (something seemingly fading - and returning at the same time - in the new albums). It's not fair to judge sftbh against anything b/c we only have a few songs - but think of the songs that we have that aren't interludes of sorts (tos, blast off!, ijtotlomd), they're all amazing songs i think, and that doesn't include the songs on pinkerton that were originally supposed to be on black hole. My answer is still yes, without a doubt.
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 119
(6/17/02 10:16:27 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"i'll take my 37 seconds of "oh no.." over most of maladroit"
yes
|
paperfacepilgrm
Registered User
Posts: 123
(6/17/02 10:45:30 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
referring to queeros last post...that its also why i say depends.
i would like the opera if it produced better rock, but i would take the straight up rock songs album over the opera if it procuced the same caliber of rock.
|
say it aint shoe
Registered User
Posts: 91
(6/17/02 10:49:18 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
the word misstep is being said as much as hiatus now.
|
JustJyl
Registered User
Posts: 64
(6/17/02 11:39:12 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes
|
dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 240
(6/17/02 11:40:53 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I just don't see how 'oh no' is better than most of maladroit. Yeh, the melody and words are decent, but it's still hardly a song. More of just a interlude between songs.
But if you prefer it, then so be it.
Wilson
|
redgale
Registered User
Posts: 30
(6/17/02 12:23:59 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes
|
RadiusMan
Registered User
Posts: 428
(6/17/02 12:31:12 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
YES
(No, I'm not dead)
|
FFeJ and Raven
Registered User
Posts: 177
(6/17/02 12:56:18 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 215
(6/17/02 1:18:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"can i assume that all of you prefer this style to, say, maladroit?"
The answer to this question is: YES. I don't know whether it's a good assumption or not but, to faithfully answer your question as posed, yes you can assume that.
Aside from my being a smartass, the problem is that the question is too non-specific and open to interpretation, and you can see that people have made their own assumptions about what you meant regarding style. It's especially problematic since Maladroit, as has been pointed out by countless critics, is not a cohesive, one-style-only collection of songs. So you could be asking opera vs. typical rock album or one type of sound vs. another type of sound or one style of singing vs. another style of singing or (one of our favorites topics lately) intensity vs. a decided lack of intensity. If you want to talk intensity, I'll take sftbh over Maladroit without question. It's easy to say YES because sftbh is something we all want to hear and the one thing we can't/don't have right now. But style is hard to pin down and I wouldn't take 37 seconds of Oh No over Death and Destruction, so saying yes or no is too hard.
edit: due to brain aneurysm
Edited by: roofrat at: 6/17/02 1:34:09 pm
|
jsublime
Registered User
Posts: 21
(6/17/02 1:23:01 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
how could you choose 'oh no' instead of maladroit? It isn't as good as any of the other stuff from sftbh, and you'd rather listen to it than a whole album of decent yet fully produced songs? That doesn't make sense.
|
Brody783
Registered User
Posts: 365
(6/17/02 1:29:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
i hope ace doesn't take us too literally and starts making 28 second underproduced songs by himself.
edit: YES
Edited by: Brody783 at: 6/17/02 1:33:17 pm
|
Darcy17
Bestest friend
Posts: 20
(6/17/02 1:29:49 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 216
(6/17/02 1:31:49 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I meant to say I wouldn't TAKE Oh No over D&D. Oh No is transitional, as has been pointed out. But it makes me want to hear more, to hear all of sftbh, in fact. But I wouldn't trade in D&D for that one song regardless of intensity and what it portends. So ace's question is not well-stated and that was the point I was attempting (poorly) to make.
|
hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 180
(6/17/02 2:36:24 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
for style, im guessing that he really doesn't mean rock operas under 1 minute. i think he means that musical style aka old weezer
|
peachchaos
Registered User
Posts: 68
(6/17/02 2:37:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes
|
jackkoho
Registered User
Posts: 120
(6/17/02 2:54:54 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
jsublime, i can choose oh no over maladroit, because i think those 44 seconds are better than any 44 seconds on maladroit. and all the production in the world can't help a mediocre song.
|
MerkinMuffley
Head Professor Dept. of Weezology Harvard University
Posts: 532
(6/17/02 3:02:27 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
possi-ply.
edit: a tentative yes.
Edited by: MerkinMuffley at: 6/17/02 3:03:18 pm
|
hoblie
black
Posts: 102
(6/17/02 3:12:57 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Maladroit is all killer.
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 1814
(6/17/02 3:41:25 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
FUYCJ YOU ACE
|
Cathylala
FEMALE
Posts: 136
(6/17/02 3:45:14 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
yes.
Sidenote: i agree with that one guy that you would go down in history making a new innovative record that has the style of rock opera. If that's what you're refering to as the "style". But i'm not saying you should have duets with another artist in every single song you make from now on. your voice is great.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 239
(6/17/02 3:55:51 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Maladroit is better than any concept album not done perfectly. Thats the problem with concept albums, they leave no room for error. Its all or nothing.
However, from what I've heard of sftbh, I would definitely take it over a pop-rock album like Maladroit. Because I think ace would pull it off perfectly.
Also, no one should want Oh No This Is Not For Me over Maladroit. Its hardly a song on its own. But, like others have said, in the right context (aka a complete and perfect sftbh) it would rule.
|
zilched
Registered User
Posts: 191
(6/17/02 4:19:58 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
[@#%$]for style, im guessing that he really doesn't mean rock operas under 1 minute. i think he means that musical style aka old weezer [/@#%$]
Exactly. He's talking about the melody, instrumentation, etc. of SFTBH vs. Maladroit, NOT concept album vs. pop album.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 240
(6/17/02 4:22:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
That's just your assumption
|
Queero McGayguy
***HERO***
Posts: 1815
(6/17/02 4:39:23 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
SEEMS I WAS WRONG. I really didn't see the point in asking it the way he did, as it's pretty obvious that everyone HERE would say yes.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 241
(6/17/02 4:46:29 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Actually I think your interpretation makes a lot of sense. It just seems that ace intentionally asks unclear questions so I just dont get why some people insist on arguing over their meanings.
|
dageeklove
Registered User
Posts: 242
(6/17/02 4:53:04 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
If it is 'style' we are talking, then I would rather not hear anything in the 'style' of "come to my pod" for future weezer. As far as instrumentation, and melody, 'oh no' and "blast off" are great (esp. blast off), but for structure, call me old-fashion, but I like choruses and prefer weezer's songs to have them.
Wilson
|
Noheadalettuce
Registered User
Posts: 33
(6/17/02 5:19:29 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
With Weezer's increasing creative control there is no reason they couldn't do a straight pop album, followed by rawk album, followed by a rock opera, followed by whatever-the-hell-else they want to do... a bluegrass album, followed by an album mixing all of the above.
I don't think people are really suggesting that Rivers should only write rock operas or short conceptual songs with no choruses. I prefer the few nuggets we have from sftbh, but I think both "styles" are cool. The aspect I enjoy about sftbh is that Rivers seemed to be taking artisitc chances with it, and as long as the creative freshness is there in the future (which seems to be more of the case lately) I'll be happy.
All that stuff aside, I think what we've heard from Black hole is pretty f'n sweet.
|
caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 140
(6/17/02 5:23:30 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I think a big thing for me is that I really love Blastoff and Tired of Sex much more than anything on Maladroit. Those are two fantastic songs, so when I said "yes" earlier, it was because I was thinking of the structures/melodies/emotion/etc. of those two songs compared to Maladroit. I like "Oh No..." too but that's not the main reason I'm leaning toward SFTBH.
|
me be beatlleweez
*edits/makes no sense*
Posts: 144
(6/17/02 8:04:54 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
i like the power and intensity of sftbh, and the varied song structures. in terms of songwriting, though, each maladroit song stands up better on its own than some of what we've heard from black hole. but as some people have said, this can contribute to the greater good of the concept album.
BUT.... leaning more towards a "yes" than "no"... if i'm taking the question the right way.
|
mrtpitiesfools
I like stretch marks.
Posts: 358
(6/17/02 8:39:09 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
SFTBH is geared towards a singular goal, where each song represents a piece of the whole. Each piece can be 3 minutes, or 30 seconds, but as long as they get to the point, and flow, they do their job. I dont think we would see many happy fans if Maladroit had 44 second songs. I like the concept album idea, especially the story, but if I had to choose, I would want a Maladroit type album over a concept album. I do think that the songs on SFTBH are really something though.
|
renthepen w2910
Registered User
Posts: 14
(6/17/02 9:43:20 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
After reading all your posts, I feel like I changed my mind a bit. I agree that the context of the concept album is what makes the songs more important than a typical album where all the songs are thrown out on a disc without any order. I guess that the key word to describe what is cool with an opera is the STRUCTURE of the whole thing.
On another note, I think that the pop/melodic sound of the old material is superior to the summer2k/mala rock sound. I am not asking ace to stop writing his rock songs based on cool guitar riffs, but maybe just understand that he is good at writing melodic stuff. If he doesn't want to do this anymore (I don't assume it, let's just pretend), all I ask then is that he releases all his earlier demos in the next few years; if he feels like he can do something great from the sftbh idea, let's hope he'll work on it in order to write a great opera.
|
mrtpitiesfools
I like stretch marks.
Posts: 359
(6/17/02 11:07:17 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
The problem with concept albums is where do you go after you make one? Do you think Ace would have returned to writing more Blue-type songs had SFTBH been released? Or would we have gotten another concept album? I think that Pinkerton was a stepping stone, and in a way, SFTBH could have possibly killed Weezer in the long run. Lets face it, the average album buyer wants easy to follow-formulaic shit. A concept album would probably tank nowadays.
|
caribooo
Registered User
Posts: 141
(6/17/02 11:18:52 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I don't know if SFTBH would have killed Weezer. Pinkerton didn't do well and Weezer's certainly not dead now. I think it might have wound up being a similar situation (tanking because it wasn't the kind of music that was popular at the time, leading to a prolonged hiatus).
|
Noheadalettuce
Registered User
Posts: 34
(6/17/02 11:24:57 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Plenty of artists have made other types of albums after making concept albums. David Bowie made Ziggy Stardust and Diamond Dogs in the early 70s and produced several great non-concept-albums after that.
You're right though, releasing black hole as a sophmore effort, while being a very cool and bold move, would have fared even more poorly than Pinkerton and possibly ended the band. However, now I think they are getting to the point where they shouldn't have to worry a lot about commerical success, and they could pull off a sftbh if they wanted to. Awhile back on the dot com board Rivers was asking people for name for a record label... that would definately give them more control.
|
mrtpitiesfools
I like stretch marks.
Posts: 362
(6/17/02 11:27:55 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
If Rivers had his own record label, I would love to see how it was run, and who would jump on it. He seems very pro-artist, it might be attractive to many under the MTV radar bands. Would Weezer be allowed to release an album under their own label? I think there would have to be some settlement with Interscope, unless they used the Goat Punishment name.
|
idahoprime
Registered User
Posts: 91
(6/18/02 12:19:52 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
well they still have the contract to fulfill. After that i suppose it would be fair game. but what do i know
|
BottleOBlues
Registered User
Posts: 97
(6/18/02 12:42:27 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
No and Yes
I'm glad pinkerton came out instead of sftbh. more personal. i enjoy every song together and apart. the rock opera is a neat idea but i don't prefer it to pinkerton at all. As long as the content there, i'm very happy with a "regular style" album. Blastoff is one of the most kick ass songs i've heard from weezer but songs like "come to my pod" and "oh no,..." don't really do it for me. i can see combined with the rest it might make them better but i like songs that can stand on their own as well as with others.
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 266
(6/18/02 11:46:18 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
in response to what bottleoblues said:
obviously pinkerton owns sftbh. you cant relate to Blast Off! in any comparable way to say El Scorcho or Falling for You. ace said himself that pinkerton was more 'far more special,' which clearly makes sense since it was based in personal experiences rather than about invented characters.
Edited by: Nathaniel Hornblower at: 6/18/02 11:50:25 am
|
raf
African princess.
Posts: 229
(6/18/02 11:59:52 am)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"maria, i'm red with shame".
|
Nathaniel Hornblower
Registered User
Posts: 267
(6/18/02 12:02:41 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
::correcting::
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 221
(6/18/02 12:55:13 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"songs like "come to my pod" and "oh no,..." don't really do it for me. i can see combined with the rest it might make them better but i like songs that can stand on their own as well as with others."
Well, it's really pointless to even compare/contrast with a song off Mala, since as has been said ad nauseum, CTMP and Oh No were never intended to represent the same type of complete work. They're interludes or transitional pieces that bridge songs in the whole opera scheme. It's unfair to consider them for comparison as anything otherwise. And since we don't have anything from Maladroit in that same vein, the question interpreted in that way is moot. The songs have to be held up for comparison as a whole in order to make a fair assessment with Maladroit and, even then, we don't know if the real question is style of album or style of music/lyric/intensity. Without clarification, the question can't be answered. Especially in one word.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 242
(6/18/02 4:53:52 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Its also unfair for you people to say Pinkerton owns sftbh. We havent heard the black hole album, remember?
|
wherewasmymind
I'm satisfied
Posts: 578
(6/18/02 5:11:40 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Oh, wow, we havent? No shit! I thought everyone had a copy.
|
DaFlavah
Registered User
Posts: 208
(6/18/02 5:22:20 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
Thats true.
And its not necessarily a sure dud if it's a themed album. Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness was a multi-platinum, double record.
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 243
(6/18/02 5:22:33 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
You use sarcasm well. I'm surprised you didnt pick up on it in my post.
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 223
(6/18/02 5:37:21 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"And its not necessarily a sure dud if it's a themed album."
Not to mention, you'd have to determine what standard you're using to measure its success. Commercial success, critical success, etc. If its potential for commercial success was known, is it necessary to crush the project because of that? Weezer can find commercial success through other album releases. If they really are gaining pull and influence with the house of discs, they should take that power for a ride and release whatever the hell they want. They can sandwich projects they want to do between projects they know will bring in the green. That way ace can polish up sftbh and we can all benefit from its release plus he can bust out other songs/projects that are languishing, known only by their numbers on a spreadsheet and otherwise never to see the light of day.
|
mcnellis
Registered User
Posts: 149
(6/18/02 6:01:41 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
but one word from interscope can block any album weezer makes untill the end of time. we got TGA because interscope hated all of the the ss2k demos. To get the SFTBH realesed they should do it on a indie label and save the money maker albums for a major label.
|
wherewasmymind
I'm satisfied
Posts: 579
(6/18/02 6:10:37 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
"we got TGA because interscope hated all of the the ss2k demos."
we got TGA for several reasons.
|
brokemyrecord
Registered User
Posts: 389
(6/18/02 6:20:10 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
any weezer album up to 7 (i think) is contractually obligated to be released on interscope (as i understand it anyway), unless they get dropped. I don't think the indie record route will work, but an even nicer, cheaper way to do it is on the internet and they seem to be leaking a song or two every once in a while, so it'll just take patience.
|
weezerfan9544
Registered User
Posts: 187
(6/18/02 6:29:54 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
could someone send this to me please.
aim: ninety544
|
agentman007
Registered User
Posts: 245
(6/19/02 5:19:04 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I was thinking about everything Karl said about the two sftbh track lists. Supposedly ass.chun's list is the most recent. That leaves something still unexplained. In the aim conversation with ridd and/or kyle, why did rivers say that 50% of the songs were the same for both sftbh and Pinkerton? If the ass.chun's list was the correct list, then the only song that is on both albums is Tired of Sex. This fact leaves a hole in Karl's theory.
|
hash browns
kyle is a fag
Posts: 183
(6/19/02 6:32:06 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
i thought the exact same thing, that makes no sense.
|
karlophone
Media Pimp.
Posts: 91
(6/19/02 7:02:40 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
thats why i still give equal weight to both lists. even though the assy list (DAT running order) was assembled like a year later. it sounds to me like RC still puts more weight on the OG list.
assy just has a jpeg of the cd label. which i figured out, making me look at it closer, making me realize it was totally different than the cassette.
|
wherewasmymind
I'm satisfied
Posts: 584
(6/19/02 7:55:32 pm)
Reply
|
Re: another piece of the puzzle from RC
I would like to see that picture.
|
Jim2131W
Registered User
Posts: 48
(6/19/02 10:30:35 pm)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
see below
Edited by: Jim2131W at: 6/20/02 9:55:41 pm
|
Jim2131W
Registered User
Posts: 49
(6/19/02 10:33:09 pm)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
*nevermind*
|
eXxy
It is impossible for anyone to be more gay than I am.
Posts: 197
(6/21/02 11:33:36 am)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
yes
|
Rock1984
Registered User
Posts: 214
(6/21/02 1:39:22 pm)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
I guess Rivers just said that we already know 50 percent because he didn't like that music when the interview was made and just wanted to prevent people from wanting more SFTBH. As we all know, he thinks different about his music now, perhaps if we asked him again he'd admit that we don't know so many songs.
|
BottleOBlues
Registered User
Posts: 100
(6/22/02 12:37:24 am)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
nathanial and roofrat, i never compared either of the albums in question to maladroit. not even remotely. what you're forgetting is that i was just stating my opinion to ace's question. no right or wrong answer.
i was stating my opinion for "regular" albums because they lack the interludes which aren't as strong as regular songs.(yes i know, they aren't meant to be as strong.) My preference for the more personal type of album was feedback to ace saying that i enjoy the personal aspect instead of created characters. In conclusion all i way saying was, although i'd like to hear both types of albums, i prefer a personal "regular" album to a invented concept album. hmm, that should straighten things up.
Edited by: BottleOBlues at: 6/22/02 12:42:33 am
|
roofrat
Registered User
Posts: 233
(6/22/02 9:47:09 am)
Reply
|
Re: completely off topic message for ace
"i never compared either of the albums in question to maladroit"
The reason I thought your comments were aimed at Maladroit was because ace's original question about Oh No was whether we "...prefer this style to, say, maladroit?".
But now with the context or your comments more defined, I think I mostly agree with them, although I kind of like the interludes. He used a musical interlude in Pinkerton to good effect and I think it could work again, whether just musical or music/lyrics. It seems that a project like sftbh would work great once but to work in that medium more might be forcing the songs into a pattern and that would make achieving the personal, that so many of us enjoy, more difficult. At least I would think so.
|
disallusional
Registered User
Posts: 11
(6/22/02 8:42:52 pm)
Reply
|
.
How many times I've listened to:
Oh No This Is Not For Me - Around 20
Maladriot - 1/2
|
Flat Pepsi
Registered User
Posts: 157
(6/22/02 11:31:20 pm)
Reply
|
Re: .
it's also like a one minute long song
|
Newt Floss
Well-endowed playa
Posts: 424
(6/23/02 12:16:06 am)
Reply
|
Re: .
1/2? What the fuck? Did your CD player run out of batteries?
|